Thank you @lisaberry for tagging me!
Sweet over sour (I've always had a sweet tooth)
Treat over trick (Who doesn't love a tasty treat)
Witches over vampires (I live in Massachusetts, which is a very witch-centric, pagan-friendly place; plus, Salem)
Candy apple over caramel apple (I didn't know there was a difference until recently)
Haunted house over costume party
Scary stories over horror movies
Ghosts over aliens
Ouija Board over bobbing
Graveyard over abandoned house
Chocolate over gummies
I think my answers reveal an interest in all things gothic and mystical, even though I'm not necessarily very gothic, per se.
Anyway, I'll pass this along to @rare and @melina