Today is Memorial Day, a holiday to honor the lives lost and sacrifices made by America's servicemen and women. The President visited Arlington National Cemetary and gave a speech honoring our veterans past and present.. Others took the occasion to try to score cheap political points. Over at Real Clear Politics, someone thought it was an ideal occasion to address an issue that isn't getting a lot of attention. The question raised is 'Purple Hearts for PTSD?'
Since the 1960s the combination of the antiwar and non-serving sectors of academia, the media, the leaders of various peace causes, the "allergic-to-combat" upper income sector of society and the shrinkocracy have made various cases with various levels of proof that try to establish that not only was the old Mothers for Peace poster correct that "war not healthy for children and other living things," but that it causes far more casualties than are normally counted.
Veterans have always found war downright hazardous to their health. But now their own lobbying groups such as the Veterans of Foreign Wars, American Legion, and Vietnam Veterans of America, and employees of the Veterans' Administration itself have decided to facilitate a blizzard of dubious veterans' benefit claims worse than the wildest dreams of any welfare queen.
Wow, what an incredible asshole. All anti-war sentiment is from people too scared to serve in uniform or overly obsessed with psychoanalysis. Better yet, all those Veterans groups you thought existed to offer support and assistance to veterans trying to readjust to civilian life are just out to scam Uncle Sam out of your tax dollars.
Claims of injuries from Post Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) are being used to grossly inflate the casualty rate and establish a whole new class of dubious "victims" out of veterans who served their country and are now being induced to serve themselves by both those who hate the American military while, of course, ritually praising their "service," and veteran lobbyist groups who claim to speak "for veterans" while increasing their ability to sell veterans on the benefits they get by paying for membership.
Which brings us to the questions that prompted me to post this. How do we define PTSD? The author or the piece, Thomas Lipscomb, obviously believes it isn't quite a 'real' injury and shouldn't be treated with the same seriousness as combat wounds. PTSD is tricky all around since, as a disorder, it's only been recognized within the last twenty five years. NPR discusses the history of PTSD and some of its effects here.
When Jack Smith returned from Vietnam twenty-five years ago, there was no tidy explanation for the feelings he was having.
We know that as far back as World War I soldiers have experienced shell shock, various strong emotional and occasional physical symptoms to the stresses of combat. However, as the NPR piece notes, there were many challenges with the diagnosis of what was once called Post-Vietnam Syndrome, including soldiers being misdiagnosed with schizophrenia, some were even subject to shock treatment. Eventually, PTSD was listed in the DSM II, although it is still a controversial issue. As the NPR and Thomas Lipscomb both mention, it is the most commonly 'faked' disorder. Sometimes, those attempting to collect VA benefits for it aren't even soldiers.
From Lipscomb:
In doing so, they [Veterans Groups and psychologists] have helped veterans and in some cases people who simply claimed to be veterans make hundreds of thousands of PTSD injury claims in what military records fraud expert B.G. Burkett calls "by far the largest collection of military disability fraud cases in the history of the United States, all alleging PTSD."
Seventy percent of the disability claims presented to the Veterans Administration come through what is called "a membership representative," who often works for one of the veterans' lobbyist organizations and helps applicants with the difficult paperwork. One of the recent candidates for president of the Vietnam Veterans of America had to disqualify himself when it was revealed that he had admitted drawing up phony claims for disabilities by VVA members to the Veterans' Administration.
Since a 100% disability payment for PTSD can be worth more than $30,000 a year for life, it is not surprising that a high percentage of veterans working for the VA also receive payments for PTSD themselves. It also makes the grantee eligible for a 50% disability payment under Social Security. Together they total over $40,000 a year, tax free and inflation-indexed.
So, we know that among any group as large as the United States Military there's going to be a few trying to scam the system, but if the system can't even decide what PTSD should merit in terms of benefits, it creates a lot of grey area as to who is scamming and who is actually looking for help. And, worse, there's evidence that the Veterans Administration is aware of PTSD's scope and scale and wants to find a way to avoid diagnosing it.
The message, dated March 20 and titled ''Suggestion,'' said: ''Given that we are having more and more compensation seeking veterans, I'd like to suggest that we refrain from giving a diagnosis of PTSD straight out. Consider a diagnosis of Adjustment Disorder, R/O PTSD.'' R/O stands for ''rule out.''
''Additionally,'' it said, ''we really don't or have time to do the extensive testing that should be done to determine PTSD.''
So, on this Memorial Day, let's ask ourselves what we can and should be doing for the troops that serve and protect our Nation and its interests. As evidence mounts of not just PTSD, but also epidemic suicide rates among soldiers returning home, we have to ask what the true costs of this war are. How are we defining our wounded and what can be done for those whose scars are psychological and not physical? How can we do right by those that have served, while preventing dubious and unscrupulous people from profiting from falsified illnesses and disorders? How do we do right by those that have sacrificed so much for us?

















PAGE:
1 | 2
ChrisSick
Philadelphia, PA
March 2008
MAY 27, 2008 11:44 AM
QuargWarrior
Norcross, GA
February 2008
MAY 27, 2008 03:17 PM
SockPuppet
I'm lost
July 2006
MAY 27, 2008 04:49 PM
QuargWarrior
Norcross, GA
February 2008
MAY 28, 2008 10:01 AM
PAGE:
1 | 2