BLOG VIEW  |  HEADLINE VIEW
SUBMIT NEWS  |  RSS FEED  |  SEARCH

Sins of the Brother

TUESDAY MAY 20 2008 5:30 PM

Submitted by OhSoOrdinary. Edited By crispy.

TAGS: Abuse, Iraq, Military, Humanity, Quran

[Editor's note: OhSoOrdinary submitted this article from Iraq, where she is currently serving with the U.S. Army.]

A great deal of our mission here is psychological. The Iraqi people need to believe that siding with us serves their interests better than siding with the insurgents and the militias. That’s why we run humanitarian aid missions and build infrastructure in their towns and villages. Those big, expensive, time-consuming overtures of friendship do very little to help us when things like this happen. I was in the cafeteria when I first saw this story on CNN's The Situation Room. I was horrified.

An American sniper was removed from Iraq after he used a copy of the Quran for target practice, the military said Sunday, a day after a U.S. commander held a formal ceremony apologizing to Sunni tribal leaders.



American commanders launched an inquiry that led to disciplinary action against the unidentified soldier, who has been removed from Iraq, Buckner said. Members of the local U.S.-allied group said the Quran was found with 14 bullet holes in a field after U.S. troops withdrew from a base in the area.


Are you serious? Why don’t you just shoot me instead, guy?

Iraqi police found the bullet-riddled Quran with graffiti inside the cover on a firing range near a police station in Radwaniyah, a former insurgent stronghold west of Baghdad, U.S. military spokesman Col. Bill Buckner said.


When a story like this breaks, two things happen: violence in that area goes up and locals lose trust in us. One stupid ass is all it takes to undermine everything we’re trying to do out here. That’s why that elaborate ceremony was held with generals and television cameras. It’s a really big deal. But, when I saw this story, that’s not what I was thinking about. I wasn’t really thinking. I was looking around. I was listening. Just about everyone’s eyes were on the television. The reactions were all very striking to me.

”Isn’t that near [location omitted]? I don’t want to run missions down there if it is.”


”Humph. That’s how you win hearts and minds…”


”Why is this getting so much fuckin’ press? You know how many [humanitarian aid] missions I ran since I’ve been in this God-forsaken country? When do I get to be on CNN for risking my life to give these fuckers flour and shit?”


”Ooooh… their Holy Book desecrated! Who fucking cares…”



Just like that cafeteria full of soldiers, I have mixed feelings when I see stories like this. My first feeling was that of annoyance. Public opinion of the war and the troops isn’t exactly awesome and this doesn’t help. All the militant liberals who believe we’re all a bunch of villains with blood on our hands raise these stories up and say, “See! Look at the bastardly bastards!” It’s so hurtful to be seen that way by our fellow citizens when the children of this foreign country smile at us and wave when we drive by.

But then I was angry. This jerk has undone so much legwork by so many other service members. All those joes who ran patrols and all those Humint teams who developed rapports with the sheiks and tribal leaders may just as well have stayed on the FOB. Now, whoever has to run missions in Radwaniyah is in even more danger. The herder who would have warned them of that man who had been digging by the road that morning might not speak up this time. The shop owner who always tells them when new people move into the village might just keep things to himself this time. They might be all on their own.

Later that evening, because it is within my nature to do so, I found myself trying to understand this Staff Sergeant. It wasn’t hard. Hating all of them is very easy.

There is a profound sense of kinship in the military. Calling it strong is a gross understatement. Calling it profound is an understatement still. Before we deploy, we spend a year or so living and working with the same people. They become our brothers and our sisters. Then, we all leave for a country full of people who want to kill us. When we land on our FOB, we make a silent and largely subconscious promise to each other: “I’m going to take care of you. I’m going to make sure you’re okay and we’re going to come home together.”

When that promise is broken, it is a kind of pain that I cannot easily describe to you. Everyone experiences it differently, but for me it manifested itself first with anguish and guilt. It tore at my insides and sorrow bled into my soul. It changed into anger. I was so angry at the person who set that IED. He killed my Crouch. He killed my brother. I didn’t know who he was, but I hated him.

I’ve only lost one brother. I’ve only broken one promise. But over 4,000 promises have been broken over the last five years and I can understand how that hate for the person who took your brother could infect the rest of your psyche. It could make you call them towelheads. It could make you exploit the language barrier to make jokes about them. It could make you look for a reason – any reason at all – to pop off a few rounds. It could make you lust for revenge. It could. But, it shouldn’t.

Members of the Armed Services are very often held in high regard. As such, we are constantly reminded that each one of us represents all of us. So, when an unnamed Staff Sergeant plants a few rounds in a Quran, in the eyes of the public, we all do. That’s unfortunate, because the vast majority of us make a choice contrary to this Staff Sergeant. We choose to retain our humanity.

It’s easy to dehumanize an entire race of people when you think they’re trying to kill you. Especially when they all look the same. Especially when there’s a language barrier. Especially when they follow the rules you and yours have set for them. It’s really easy to see them and the things they love as a little less than human and a little less than precious. It’s easy. It’s really easy. But it’s not right.

It’s not right to use Qurans for target practice. It’s not right to massacre entire families for revenge. It’s not right to throw puppies off cliffs. It’s not right to treat detainees like animals. It’s not right to sacrifice one’s humanity by succumbing to hatred.

Members of the Armed Services are very often held in high regard, but we are a microcosm of society. All I ask is that you remember that for every Soldier, Marine, Sailor or Airman who succumbs to hatred, there are ten thousand of us who do not.

[Hat tip: Argene]

OhSoOrdinary can't wait to go home, wash her hands of this whole mess, and start her bright, shiny, new life.

 

Previous

PAGE: 

1 ... 

19 | 20 | 21

Next

motorfirebox

motorfirebox

Pittsburgh, PA
March 2004

MAY 31, 2008 04:02 AM

that's not at all the point mec_nukka was making. he said, quite clearly and specifically, that he doesn't consider islam worthy of respect because it is, according to him, designed to be used as a system of government--an aspect he claims is unique to islam. mec_nukka is ignorant, by both the popular definition of the term (obviously), as well as the literal definition--by his own admission, he doesn't have the first god damn clue about the role other religions and philosophies are arguably designed to play in relation to government.

LSlice

LSlice

Montclair, NJ
December 2007

MAY 31, 2008 01:46 PM

motorfirebox said:
that's not at all the point mec_nukka was making. he said, quite clearly and specifically, that he doesn't consider islam worthy of respect because it is, according to him, designed to be used as a system of government--an aspect he claims is unique to islam. mec_nukka is ignorant, by both the popular definition of the term (obviously), as well as the literal definition--by his own admission, he doesn't have the first god damn clue about the role other religions and philosophies are arguably designed to play in relation to government.



I don't consider it worthy of respect either. But then again, that's the way i feel about all religions. Of course that doesn't mean I believe in forcing those views on people who want to be religous.

I'm actually kind of a fan of the "subvert Islam" strategy. You, no, PORN NOT BOMBS. Frankly, I think the sexual repression that Islam encourages probaly leads to alot of the violent stuff. I mean, think about it. You're a mulsim. You believe if you whack off you go to hell. But if you blow yourself up in a public square, you get your 72 virgins.

Secular culture and education was quite effective in breaking the yoke of official chrsitianity. I think given time, and the absence of violence and occupation to give legitimacy to the ideas of the radical muslims, you would see a more moderate islam take root.

LSlice

LSlice

Montclair, NJ
December 2007

MAY 31, 2008 01:47 PM

But to clarify on one point- trying to convert muslims to christianity while serving US guard duty- not too smart.

mec_nukka

mec_nukka

I'm lost
April 2008

MAY 31, 2008 05:10 PM

OhSoOrdinary said:

mec_nukka said:
The blog's just a yuck dude. Not to be taken too seriously.



That guy is the same kind of weak-minded individual I was talking about in my piece. Succumbing to hatred. And you think its funny. You're just as weak.

You're a piece of shit and not worthy of a uniform. Go ahead, flag me you piece of shit. I dare you. I have no patience for scum like you.



*flag*

Coyotemike

Coyotemike

Kearney, NE
May 2006

MAY 31, 2008 05:13 PM

mec_nukka said:

OhSoOrdinary said:

mec_nukka said:
The blog's just a yuck dude. Not to be taken too seriously.



That guy is the same kind of weak-minded individual I was talking about in my piece. Succumbing to hatred. And you think its funny. You're just as weak.

You're a piece of shit and not worthy of a uniform. Go ahead, flag me you piece of shit. I dare you. I have no patience for scum like you.



*flag*



Weak, man. Very weak. Why don't you go play with someone at your own mental level and maturity. I hear they have openings in several preschools right now.

mec_nukka

mec_nukka

I'm lost
April 2008

MAY 31, 2008 05:15 PM

motorfirebox said:
that's not at all the point mec_nukka was making. he said, quite clearly and specifically, that he doesn't consider islam worthy of respect because it is, according to him, designed to be used as a system of government--an aspect he claims is unique to islam. mec_nukka is ignorant, by both the popular definition of the term (obviously), as well as the literal definition--by his own admission, he doesn't have the first god damn clue about the role other religions and philosophies are arguably designed to play in relation to government.



I don't want to beat this to death, because this has gone on for quite a long time, and the staff has already privately expressed their annoyance with me once, and I'm not trying to cause problems, but just to be clear, you're mischaracterizing my positions.

1-my lack of respect for Islam comes from a myriad of directions, not just matters relating to governance.

2-I didn't say there aren't any other things calling themselves religions that were also in-and-of themselves systems of government - I said I knew of no others. You listed six ideologies that I guess you're claiming fit the bill. Ok, maybe. I'm not in a position to confirm or reject your claims at the moment (though at first glance, they look pretty wacky - Pharaonic Egypt? wtf?), but it doesn't matter anyway, because even if in some magical alternative dimension of reality that your mind occupies there are indeed six other major religions operating on the planet today that, like Islam, are not just religions, but also developed systems of state, jurisprudence and ass-hygiene rules, and that, like Islam, command their adherents to impose that system of state on the entire world, it doesn't change my original point.

3-My point was (I could have made many other points, but I'm trying to keep a low profile on this site so as not to further annoy the staff, so I just stuck to that one): In Iraq, given that Islam is both a religion and a form of government, and that form of government is non-democratic, then if the US mission is to build a democracy there, then it only makes logical sense to make converting people from a non-democratic political religion to a non-political religion part of the strategy. I don't see how you can deny the logic of that. Your points, whether valid or not, are just an irrelevant diversion. Like a mildly bothersome mosquito that I have now crushed by sticking to my main point.

(And now I will go back to being silent so as not to annoy the staff.)





motorfirebox

motorfirebox

Pittsburgh, PA
March 2004

MAY 31, 2008 06:20 PM

LSlice said:
I don't consider it worthy of respect either. But then again, that's the way i feel about all religions. Of course that doesn't mean I believe in forcing those views on people who want to be religous.


not respecting a religion is a personal choice (acting on that disrespect may or may not be, as the soldier in the original article showed). not respecting a religion because you haven't bothered to educate yourself about it is just stupid.

Previous

PAGE: 

1 ... 

19 | 20 | 21

Next

Now Hear This

Last Comment 4 HR by orbro

Now Hear This

Last Comment 4 HR

There's like a half-hour of video here. You should do a vlog. More ...

Asshole Fuckface Roundup #74

Last Comment 5 HR

Parents who are accustomed to carrying guns around may not think anything of going into child-related... More ...

An Encounter With Jonathan Shaw's Narcisa

Last Comment 6 HR

thanx gurlz... u rrrrrule!! xx jonathan shaw and narcisa More ...

SuicideGirl: Bob

Bob

Terrible Woman's MySpace Alias Leads to Teen's Suicide.

Last Comment 21 HR

But, it's delivered poorly...really poorly. Unless, it's not a joke, in which case, it's a good place... More ...

Bail The Shit Out Of Detroit

Last Comment 11/30/08 by Shalome

Bail The Shit Out Of Detroit

Last Comment 11/30/08

Oh my fucking god. More ...

Filtering the Truth: Religion - Friend or Foe?

Last Comment 11/30/08

I'm just going to skip over the mass orgy that's going on and say my piece: I don't think religion is... More ...

SuicideGirls Interview: Dita Von Teese author of The Art of the Teese
SuicideGirls Interview: David Mamet
SuicideGirls Interview: Frank Black