• commentary
  • MONDAY NOVEMBER 5 2007 12:00 AM

Why The Writers Are On Strike



Television and film writers will officially go on strike one minute after I post this. 12:01 AM, Monday. This will probably be an ugly strike and you will hear a lot of nasty things said about writers. We will be portrayed as spoiled brats who are putting an entire industry out of work to make a couple extra bucks. By the time the strike is over America will think we all sit around feeding our white Persian cats freshly killed Tuna, while throwing diamonds at our pool boys bottom as we are being fed caviar by our personal chef/masseuse, Armando.

The truth is, most writers in the guild are middle class or below. The median income is about that of a schoolteacher. Do some writers make a fortune? Of course. Are there writers who barely scrape by? A lot more than the ones making a fortune. But you won’t be hearing that story because we are fighting against media companies. How fairly do you think this strike will be reported on channels owned by Disney, Fox or Viacom? So, expect to hear a lot about our Land Rovers, Porsches, Armando and all of the crew people we are putting out of work by striking.

Already, we are being attacked by the masses for our greedy stance, which is the way the new America operates. Everyone seems very happy to allow those at the top to make as much money as possible and anyone who asks for a tiny bit of the billions is greedy. Meanwhile, the companies making billions by firing employees and cutting pensions are somehow honorable. It is bizarre and idiotic thinking, but that is where we find ourselves.

The Writers are fortunate to have received the Teamsters backing. While not ordering their members not to cross picked lines, the teamsters have been told they may honor picket lines and their union will back them up. Studios have reacted by calling teamsters in to their offices in groups and asking them if they planned to cross the line. They have been threatened with unemployment if they do honor the line, which would violate the studios contract with the teamsters. Teamsters have it written into every contract that they cannot be punished for refusing to cross a picket line. It is a huge sacrifice if they do honor the line and they didn’t come to this decision lightly. But they understand the larger implications: This dispute is not just about writers. We are the first union that is fighting for our rights and equal pay when it comes to the Internet. What we do now will affect every union in Hollywood.

Here is one Teamsters opinion on the strike.


I could just say, "Teamsters don't cross picket lines." I could just say, "I need a vacation." I could just say, "I believe in the rights of the working man." While that is all true, the real reason is more complex. I believe this is the opening round of a long battle that every union member in Hollywood will have to face as our contracts expire.

The digital world is not in the future, it is here now. It is now possible to watch Television and Movies entirely on the Internet, and the network sites, with ads galore, are proof. This is not a hypothetical. It is profit-making reality. If the writers are denied fair payment for reuse, I do not believe the Directors, Actors and the rest of us will fare any better when our turn comes.


The studios would like the world to believe we are fighting over the money we receive for DVD sales. That is completely untrue. The fight for DVD money ended years ago. Currently writers receive 4 cents for every DVD sold. We’d like to increase that to 8 cents. DVDs cost 10 bucks. Aren’t we a bunch of money grabbing bastards?

The reason the focus will be on DVDs is because years ago the Guild agreed to a terrible contract on home media sales. The studios told us that DVDs and home videos were not yet an established business. They claimed they couldn’t set up a payment system for writers until they knew whether or not it was successful and how it would fall into place. They were, of course, lying. Writers were then stuck with a terrible contract for twenty years. Now the studios are saying the EXACT SAME THING about the Internet. Again, it isn’t an established business, so how can they commit to a payment plan? Blah, blah, blah.

What the producers did not understand was the deep feelings of anger that writers have had for years over the DVD contract and how we were taken advantage of after negotiating in good faith. Every time we look at a DVD on a store shelf, we are reminded of how we are getting screwed. And now the anger has a place to go because the producers are giving us a chance to win a battle we have been simmering about for 20 years. Way to bring to union together, fat cats.

I’ve never seen the Guild this unified. Two weeks ago we voted to authorize a strike and 90% supported the action. On Thursday night we had a meeting and Guild members were completely behind our negotiating team. Not one member voiced their opposition. We know whom we are fighting. We understand the battle we are fighting.

This is not an average negotiation. This is a 20-year negotiation. In the '40s the Guild was formed after a strike threat. In the '60s the Guild walked for health, pension and residuals. In the '80s the Guild walked for Cable coverage, DVD payments and home video. Now there is a new medium and if we don’t take a stand, many writers will lose their ability to survive. As will actors and on down the line.

This is all about Internet streaming and downloads. The Guild has put forth an offer of 2.5%. That is 2 and a half cents for every dollar. Producers have countered with ZERO and will not come back to the table until we agree to that generous offer. So, basically they will not negotiate until we agree to not negotiate. Producers claim they are not making any money off of the Internet, that it is just “promotional.” In the proposal they offered, they stated “promotional” includes shows that are “aired in entirety” and for which they “receive a fee.” (NBC made $15 million “promoting” shows on iTunes last year.)

So, why are we so concerned with this money? Residuals are the name of the game for writers. We aren’t employed constantly and it allows us to survive during the rough times, which we use to write scripts and come up with pitches. Guess who profits off of that system? The studios. If we agreed to their demands, the studios would be killing their own product, plain and simple. No one would have time to write because they would have day jobs, which would mean far less new ideas being pitched. The money ABC has made of off Desperate Housewives is probably more than the residuals paid to the entire Guild over that same period. A writer was living on residuals when he created the show.

The poor producers claim they’re not making money off of the Internet, even though they show commercials during shows and charge for downloads in a medium that costs them almost nothing in overhead. At the same time, they are boasting to their shareholders how profitable the Internet will be and that that they ARE already making money. So, which is it?

To date the producers have been nothing short of disgusting in their approach to negotiations. We wanted to meet in early July. They waited until mid-July. They then gave us a 30-page proposal that had nothing to do with the issues at hand and wanted writers to take massive pay cuts. (Way to unify Guild members, idiots.) Then they wouldn’t meet until late September. Since September, producers have yet to even discuss any of our demands. They just refuse to talk about them. We took 9 of our 25 demands off the table, important substantial demands, and the producers responded with NOTHING. They simply refuse to negotiate. All they have been doing is attempting to use the media to undermine our negotiators in hopes of splitting the Guild. Their actions give us no alternative but to strike.

How long wills it last? Nobody knows, but I would expect it to go on for some time. I think writers will lose homes, the California economy will suffer and then the entire country. (Entertainment makes up 7% of the US economy.) But we will hold strong, for the simple fact that we are really, really angry and have been for quite some time. Many shows that began this season will die miserable deaths. Shows with declining audience numbers that are difficult to follow, like "Lost", may disappear as well.

What the studios seems to not understand is that it is their best interest to keep the writers working for them. They are following a plan that has completely undermined the music business. Treat those you count on like crap and those people will find their own way. I have one word for studios to mull over: Radiohead. If they don’t think writers will use this time to figure out a way to take their product directly to consumers via the Internet, they are out of their minds. We will and at that point they can remember fondly that 1% download money they saved.

 

Previous

PAGE: 

1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6

 ... 36

Next

Comments
scorp17yh

scorp17yh

Brookings, OR
November 2004

NOV 05, 2007 07:51 AM

It would be nice to see the actors, who would not have a living if not for the writers, support you but I sincerely doubt they have that much class

minimalism

minimalism

Argentina
OLD SKOOL

NOV 05, 2007 07:58 AM

It's really nice to see this kind of support from the members towards Union workers. I didn't get nearly as much backing when I spoke on behalf of the MTA workers on strike in NYC. I work as a conductor in freight service and understood completely the real reason behind the strike, which again was portrayed by the media exactly the way they are trying to play the Writer's Guild now. It's sickening to think we have to fight and beg for scraps just to get by in this day and age, and that non union workers, making even less and with less benefits often times speak out against the unions at times like this. What i think they fail to realize is that the things we ultimately end up fighting for and winning sets a standard for non union workers to strive for. Benefits and pay increases that we get raise the bar for all laborers.

ogrebushi

ogrebushi

Delta, BC
March 2005

NOV 05, 2007 08:01 AM

Good luck on this, irregardless of the fact im in a union, hope yah guys wind up with a bit more of the pie, and can get back to making things fer me to spend time watchin

JoLeigh

JoLeigh

SUICIDEGIRL

Florida, USA

NOV 05, 2007 08:09 AM

CHEERS!!!

good luck

gdarklighter

gdarklighter

San Diego, CA
August 2005

NOV 05, 2007 08:17 AM

Rock on, and good luck.

voyeurs

voyeurs

Los Angeles, CA
December 2003

NOV 05, 2007 08:18 AM

You were rather flip in acknowledging "putting an entire industry out of work to make a couple extra bucks" but how do you really feel about that issue? I hope you gave it more thought than the congress' authorization to go to war. Because that's what this is becoming.

I'm inclined to be sympathetic to the writers' plight here - but I'm not sympathetic to the strike in the least. I'm part of that population that stands to lose a lot if there's an extended work stoppage. But I don't have a vote in the matter so I hold you guys responsible for pulling the trigger. I hope you know what you're doing...

attn_ho

attn_ho

Brooklyn, NY
February 2004

NOV 05, 2007 08:25 AM

voyeurs said:
You were rather flip in acknowledging "putting an entire industry out of work to make a couple extra bucks" but how do you really feel about that issue? I hope you gave it more thought than the congress' authorization to go to war. Because that's what this is becoming.

I'm inclined to be sympathetic to the writers' plight here - but I'm not sympathetic to the strike in the least. I'm part of that population that stands to lose a lot if there's an extended work stoppage. But I don't have a vote in the matter so I hold you guys responsible for pulling the trigger. I hope you know what you're doing...



you could always transfer your skills over to porn production. they never seem to have writer problems!

Gylrek

Gylrek

Chula Vista, CA
August 2007

NOV 05, 2007 08:26 AM

you don't get something for nothing the writer will probably win as they should ,but the cost will be instead of $10 to see a movie you'll pay $12, instead of $5 to rent a movie we'll pay $6 or $7. that $1.99 down load will cost $3.99 . because in the end someone will have to pay for this and nobody is going to cut into their share, they will just pass it on to the consumer and their families . But why should that bother anyone?

minimalism

minimalism

Argentina
OLD SKOOL

NOV 05, 2007 08:27 AM

If you are part of the population that stand to lose a lot because of a work stoppage, then maybe you should have stood up for these workers before they had to go as far as striking. Any Union worker will tell you a strike is always a last resort effort. None of us want to strike. You seem to think we have nothing to lose by being unemployed during all this.

Shal

Shal

Los Angeles, CA
October 2002

NOV 05, 2007 08:29 AM

Gylrek said:
you don't get something for nothing the writer will probably win as they should ,but the cost will be instead of $10 to see a movie you'll pay $12, instead of $5 to rent a movie we'll pay $6 or $7. that $1.99 down load will cost $3.99 . because in the end someone will have to pay for this and nobody is going to cut into their share, they will just pass it on to the consumer and their families . But why should that bother anyone?



Aside from the fact that you just pulled those numbers out of your ass, it sounds like you'd prefer that people not get paid for work they do.

Huh.

UrizenSpeaks

UrizenSpeaks

Los Angeles, CA
May 2004

NOV 05, 2007 08:30 AM

Well said, FTR. And if any of you movie fans are wondering how that's going to impact your viewing, it probably won't in terms of movies until '09, since most studios have been stockpiling projects for the next coulpe of years.

However, late night talk shows are going down the tubes starting... now. No fresh material on a daily basis means... no Daily Show. And is a life without Colbert, and a surge in reality TV and reruns a life worth living? Support the writers ppl.

FearTheReaper

FearTheReaper

NEWSWIRE

I'm lost

NOV 05, 2007 08:37 AM

softdog said:
This kinda, sorta, not exactly, but still reminds me of another situation.

Everyone seems very happy to allow those at the top to make as much money as possible and anyone who asks for a tiny bit of the billions is greedy...This is not a hypothetical. It is profit-making reality. If the writers are denied fair payment for reuse...poor producers claim they're not making money off of the Internet, even though they show commercials during shows and charge for downloads in a medium that costs them almost nothing in overhead. At the same time, they are boasting to their shareholders how profitable the Internet will be and that that they ARE already making money. So, which is it?


Hmmn. I think it's about time some other content providers formed a union and started getting better terms on their contracts. Don't you?



You mean the whole "standard argument" thing. Yeah.

FearTheReaper

FearTheReaper

NEWSWIRE

I'm lost

NOV 05, 2007 08:37 AM

wink84 said:
How about when all this strike business is over, let's just leave "The Big Bang Theory" off the air? No, in all seriousness one would have to feel pretty jilted to go about something as risky as a strike. Best of luck to you.



When I was at the membership meeting, a group of us were talking about shows. Someone mentioned Big Bang Theory and I said, "That's my favorite worst new show" Then a friend of mine said, "Thanks, I'm the show runner."

oops.

PRockGirlScout

PRockGirlScout

Portland, OR
October 2005

NOV 05, 2007 08:37 AM

Ironically enough, I'd love to post a video of the bit they did on Weekend Update on SNL about this very thing. But you know...

FearTheReaper

FearTheReaper

NEWSWIRE

I'm lost

NOV 05, 2007 08:39 AM

dholokov said:
As much as I hope that everyone involved gets a fair deal, I can't believe that there are not thousands upon thousands of Americans who would jump at the chance to be a scab writer for half of what writers are paid right now. I further suspect thatfor all but the absolute best television programs, their work would not be appreciably worse than current professionals.



Of course there are. And they will try. A few will get in. When the strike ends, they will find themselves isolated and unable to find work. But mostly, they are just shitty writers.

What you see on TV and in films has been destroyed by studio notes. It is insane how they are able to zero in and kill a good project with their own idiotic ideas that the writer is forced to address.

Previous

PAGE: 

1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6

 ... 36

Next