BLOG VIEW  |  HEADLINE VIEW
SUBMIT NEWS  |  RSS FEED  |  SEARCH

Democrats Try to Make Radio Suck Less

FRIDAY FEBRUARY 2 2007 9:00 PM

Submitted by legionnaire. Edited By legionnaire.

TAGS: Radio, FCC, Democrats, regulation

Commercial radio blows. It's no secret, it wasn't ever that great, but it has faced such a steep decline in recent years that the notion of how bad it is has almost become a cliché. Outside of satellite, college and internet radio stations everything available on the radio has begun to sound homogenized, and for good reason. Two companies, Clear Channel and CBS Radio together control over 25% of all radio stations in the country, a phenomenon made possible by the Telecommunications Act of 1996, which removed ownership restrictions on radio stations within a given market, claiming it would increase competition. The opposite happened, and almost all commercial radio stations in the US are now owned by five companies. So it's no surprise that it's hard to go anywhere without hearing the same six-song playlist of focus group tested crap on the radio.

Congressional Democrats have finally woken up to this fact and have made it part of their agenda for this year's legislative session, pushing the FCC to tighten ownership restrictions and increase the diversity of the radio marketplace.

Recent FCC policies on media ownership, said Sen. Byron L. Dorgan (D-N.D.), have been "a spectacular failure."

He railed against rules that allow one entity to own eight radio stations in a large city and against proposals to allow one owner to have three TV stations in a city. "More concentration means less competition," Dorgan said. "The public-interest standards have been nearly completely emasculated."

But FCC Chairman Kevin J. Martin, who has close ties to the Bush White House, defended the agency's policies.

"The commission has tried to make decisions based on a fundamental belief that a robust, competitive marketplace, not regulation, is ultimately the greatest protector of the public interest," Martin said.


Here's the problem with Martin's idea—in theory, anyway, a free market should increase diversity and lead to an effective marketplace, giving consumers what they want. But when dealing with something like portions of the electromagnetic spectrum, which by government mandate are a fixed resource. Only limited frequencies for FM and amplitudes for AM are allowed for commercial radio broadcasting, as dictated by the Radio Act of 1927, which divvied up the available bandwidth setting upper and lower boundaries on what could be transmitted, and granted the FRC (which later became the FCC) the exclusive right to license portions of that bandwidth to companies that wanted to broadcast on them. So since there are a limited number of frequencies available, and broadcasting on any of them requires a government license, by definition they represent a limited resource, the opposite occurs. Unlike the idealized free market that Adam Smith envisioned, a company with innovative radio programming ideas could not just step into the marketplace and become a dominant plaer solely through a superior product because that company would need licenses to do so. Removing limits on how many stations a company could own in a particular market also meant that a large company (like Clear Channel) could step in and buy up all of the radio stations in town, giving listeners the stark choice of either listening to what the company wanted or turning off their radio.

The nature of the commodity (portions of the EM spectrum) essentially dictates that, ironically a lack of government regulation can and does lead to monopolistic business practices that hurt consumers. Clearly the changes in the marketplace over the past ten years should be sufficient to stand alone in illustrating that point for anyone wondering. And in fact, two internal FCC reports, both suppressed independently reached this conclusion—one wonders who ordered the authors to keep their mouths shut?

 

Previous

PAGE: 

1 | 2 | 3 | 4

Next

geasavenger

geasavenger

Milwaukee, WI
May 2005

FEB 02, 2007 09:13 PM

I agreed it should be mentioned that Clear Channel specificlly owns the vast majority of billboard across the country as well. Further showing there domination of the public medium both in active i.e. radio/TV as well as passive media.

Where is Theodore Roosevelt now...

clawed

clawed

Altamonte Springs, FL
October 2006

FEB 02, 2007 09:51 PM

Beware of democrats , always pointing at one thing to get something else accomplished ... talk radio has exposed democrats unlike democrat dominated tv and hollywood . talk radio is the light that deomocrats wish to blow-out.

Grimjack

Grimjack

Philadelphia, PA
January 2004

FEB 02, 2007 10:05 PM

this is just a nitpick, but Infinity Radio hasnt exsisted in over a year. It became CBS-Radio after Viacom split into two companies, CBS and Viacom Properties. The above link that that held the data for the 25 percent ownership of Radio stations has info in it that's 4 years old at best.

Not that I dont agree with a majority of what the writer stated in the article, but citing old and/or erroneous information isn't the best way to sway a readers opinion.

Vestril

Vestril

Coronado, CA
February 2003

FEB 02, 2007 10:05 PM

clawed said:
Beware of democrats , always pointing at one thing to get something else accomplished ... talk radio has exposed democrats unlike democrat dominated tv and hollywood . talk radio is the light that deomocrats wish to blow-out.



Yeah...this is clearly all about taking away freedom of the airwaves as opposed to expanding it. Your statement makes perfect sense. Did someone talk about hanging Rush Limbaugh or something? Like what the fuck?

PunkRockElvis

PunkRockElvis

Bayport, NY
January 2006

FEB 02, 2007 10:18 PM

As someone who as worked in radio in a major market for over 3 years now I can tell you that Clear Channel and to a lesser extent the company formerly known as Infinity are complete and utter evil. Not to mention even without owning a radio station Clear Channel still holds power over the smaller ones since they own the vast majority of concert venues in any given area which forces the smaller companies to give in to clear channels demands and style in order to get concert tickets to give away on the air. Not to mention they'll always throw their money around to steal sponsors and to block certain types of promotions from happening. Why do you think NYC only as one rock station, Q104? Which sucks to begin with and absolutely no modern rock station. If it wasn't for Radio X on Long Island (which I don't work for) there would be no way for new music to be heard outside the internet and satelitte radio. And for all those people who say modern rock doesn't sell, take a look at KROQ in Cali, they do just fine. It's not like all the rock shows in NY don't sell out or there is no music scene here.

CorporateSPY

CorporateSPY

Chandler, AZ
July 2005

FEB 02, 2007 10:26 PM

Ya know, I was going to try to be constructive here... and take the high road. But I just finished writing a 15,000 word technical document on standards and I don't know that I have the energy to be diplomatic.

First let me point out that I'm pretty middle of the road, perhaps a bit conservative on some topics. I'm not a Democrat, and not a Republican. I have no party affiliation in this country(My political party is German). So from a completely unbiased political standpoint, I have to ask. What in the HELL are you smoking clawed? Not to mention what color is the sky in this Vivid fantasy world?

Hollywood may lean democratic, I'll admit that. But TV? Unless you've been exclusively watching The Daily Show, I think you'd be hard pressed to say news has a democratic bias. They ultimately pander to the common denominator, and do what is most fiscally beneficial for themselves. Since Bush has taken office, there has been no real journalism for fear of being censured. I'm sure Nixon is spinning in his grave currently at the double standards. I've mourned Journalistic integrity lately.

What exactly has talk radio exposed on Democrats? That they're lucky to not count imbeciles with bloated self-worth and hypocritical viewpoints like Rush Limbaugh's on their side?

Not to mention what has happened to Habeas Corpus, Amendment rights, privacy, personal Liberties and freedoms in general. I come from a family with a long and proud military tradition, and that crap spits on the graves of every one of them. Jurisprudence under this administration is a frightening joke. But we won't get started on THAT topic as I'm sure there is a word limit here.

Dix

Dix

Hastings, MN
September 2006

FEB 02, 2007 10:26 PM

iTunes+ iPod. Done. And there's always NPR.

Dru_Id

Dru_Id

Florence, SC
October 2006

FEB 02, 2007 10:37 PM

bout fing time we lost or only alt station in Philly 2 years ago to make way for another rap station (we know have 4) all owned by the same company

the fcc should worry less about nipple slips and more about what there turning our children in to (see ideocracy for a rough idea)

rosarandall

rosarandall

USA
March 2006

FEB 02, 2007 10:48 PM

Clear Channel pisses me off.

ruins any chance to get a job in radio around here anymore.

Signon

Signon

Austin, TX
June 2005

FEB 02, 2007 10:57 PM

clawed said:
Beware of democrats , always pointing at one thing to get something else accomplished ... talk radio has exposed democrats unlike democrat dominated tv and hollywood . talk radio is the light that deomocrats wish to blow-out.



After all, the Democrats were pushing so hard to keep the Republicans down for the last decade.

MrStitches

MrStitches

Sag Harbor, NY
November 2003

FEB 02, 2007 10:58 PM

PunkRockElvis said:
If it wasn't for Radio X on Long Island (which I don't work for) there would be no way for new music to be heard outside the internet and satelitte radio.



God damn it. I was just looking at their website, and they sound good. The east end gets totally boned radio station wise.

legionnaire

legionnaire

United Kingdom
November 2003

FEB 02, 2007 11:02 PM

Grimjack said:
this is just a nitpick, but Infinity Radio hasnt exsisted in over a year. It became CBS-Radio after Viacom split into two companies, CBS and Viacom Properties. The above link that that held the data for the 25 percent ownership of Radio stations has info in it that's 4 years old at best.

Not that I dont agree with a majority of what the writer stated in the article, but citing old and/or erroneous information isn't the best way to sway a readers opinion.



Thanks for the heads up, I'll fix the links in the original story. It's funny, a lot of the more current links that I read still referred to Infinity broadcasting as a current company; they must have based their writing on outdated data as well. Anyway, I'll update it to more accurately reflect the current situation.

barbarian

barbarian

San Diego, CA
July 2006

FEB 02, 2007 11:08 PM

If our so-called representatives have any guts they'll quit pretending to do something and go after the FCC itself --that agency is a corrupt club and that's the actual problem. More regulations are not the answer. The licensing and regulatory fees are so expensive that passing a fluffy "diversity bill" will accomplish nothing. On a side note: Keep in mind that it was Tipper Gore (wife of Al Gore) who headed up the nazi-house wife panel called the PMRC to put warning labels on music. I'm not thrilled with Dems getting involved in MY MUSIC yet again.


bean

bean

STAFF

Los Angeles, CA

FEB 02, 2007 11:08 PM

PunkRockElvis said:
And for all those people who say modern rock doesn't sell, take a look at KROQ in Cali, they do just fine.


I agree with your point, but KROQ is a bad example. It was bought by Infinity sometime in the mid-90s, and overnight started being an example of the same homogenized playlist-driven corporate stations as everywhere else. It's truly a shame, because KROQ used to be really, really good, and played a key role in the careers of many alternative acts throughout the 80s. But hey, at least now we have Indie 103.1.

bean

bean

STAFF

Los Angeles, CA

FEB 02, 2007 11:11 PM

Dix said:
iTunes+ iPod. Done. And there's always NPR.



It's sad that that's the best solution. I got turned on to a lot of good new music that wasn't getting airplay across most of the rest of the country before corporate radio bludgeoned the market.

Previous

PAGE: 

1 | 2 | 3 | 4

Next

Brett Ratner Considers Ruining Guitar Hero

Last Comment 1 HR

Easy for you Americans to say. The rest of us (British 360 owners aside) are still waiting for a Rock... More ...

"Knight Rider" Movie to Go on Without The Hoff?

Last Comment 5 HR

...and its all because of this: (video) hahaha More ...

McCain Picks A Vagina

Last Comment 5 HR

How is it that every time I read a story about this woman, she comes across as more and more of a petty... More ...

Crybaby Town

Last Comment 7 HR by boombands

Crybaby Town

Last Comment 7 HR

While you would still be spouting bullshit people would perhaps take you a little more seriously if you... More ...

EA's "Dead Space" Goes Viral

Last Comment 16 HR by Gnos

EA's "Dead Space" Goes Viral

Last Comment 16 HR

this game looks sick as hell, I like how they're doing all these sideline projects along with it the animated... More ...

SuicideGirls Interview: Tura Satana
SuicideGirls Interview: Frank Black
SuicideGirls Interview: Bootsy Collins