• commentary
  • SATURDAY DECEMBER 16 2006 9:00 PM

US Applauds New Palestinian Election

The recent factional strife in Gaza as a result of botched assassination attempts and the murder of the three children of a Fatah leader could be an indicator that the Hamas-led government there is losing some of its internal support. That at least is probably the hope of US and other Western officials, who are pleased by Mahmoud Abbas's call for early elections to try and stabilize the country. The only problem is that the current government is supposed to be in place until 2010, and early elections may not be constitutional.

Mr Abbas' call for presidential and parliamentary polls to be held at the "earliest opportunity" was also welcomed by Britain and Spain.

However the Islamic group Hamas, which won the latest Palestinian elections, rejected the move as a "coup attempt".
[...]
The US administration praised the announcement.

"While the elections are an internal matter, we hope this helps bring the violence to an end," White House spokeswoman Jeanie Mamo said.

Meanwhile UK Prime Minister Tony Blair - who is in Cairo on a Middle East tour - urged the international community to back Mr Abbas' effort to break the deadlock.

The Spanish government, for its part, said it "fully supported" the call for early Palestinian elections.

It is not clear when or how they would be held, says the BBC's Nick Thorpe in Ramallah.


Of course, the Western support is likely to hinge on the results of the election. That's the real problem with democracy, the results don't always turn out the way you want them too (a fact that American Democrats have had to deal with for the past six years) but once it's over, you're stuck with whoever was elected even if they weren't your pick. Such was the case with Hamas, who dominated elections last year, precipitating a stoppage of all economic aid from Western Europe that has put a significant strain on the functioning of the Palestinian government.

Some Palestinians aren't happy about Abbas's idea though, claiming that he and Fatah are trying to undermine the legitimacy of the Hamas government.

It will be up to the Central Election Commission to try to find a legal way of carrying out Mr Abbas' orders, our correspondent says.

The Hamas government reacted angrily to Mr Abbas' speech, calling it "a coup against Palestinian legitimacy and the will of the Palestinian people".

Mr Abbas concluded his speech by saying fresh elections were needed.

Ahmed Yousef, an adviser to Palestinian Prime Minister Ismail Haniya, said the call for elections was a recipe for violence.

"I think this will lead to bloodshed because this is something against the constitution."


Maybe it will. But how would that be any different from what's currently going on in Palestine? Still, elections that deviate from prescribed constitutional procedures can be a dangerous, double-edged sword. Just because they could help Fatah this time around and hurt Hamas's chance of keeping control of the government doesn't mean that a swing in popularity back towards Hamas couldn't do the exact same thing to Fatah a year from now.

 
Comments
ASSH0LE

ASSH0LE

Las Vegas, NV
June 2003

DEC 16, 2006 09:13 PM

I find it almost stupifying that they'd set it up in their constitution to only have elections once a decade.

Of course, that's likely Fatah's own fuckup. If I were to make an undereducated guess, they figured they'd be a natural win the first time around, and why risk losing any time soon? So they set it to once every tenth year and well, you know what that led to. A government that did as it felt, grafted what it wanted to and left its people dissatisfied.

And ten years later, they lost to Hamas.

As far as OUR positon in this goes, I kind of wish the U.S. gov't would shut the fuck up about other country's elections. Bush intimating that an Ortega victory in Nicaragua would be a bad thing, etc. These tend to belie our supposed support for democracy and can serve to make it harder for those we'd prefer to win.

At least we're not doing what we did in the fifties to seventies, where we'd overthrow and/or kill democratically elected leaders of other countries.

ASSH0LE

ASSH0LE

Las Vegas, NV
June 2003

DEC 16, 2006 09:32 PM

Ack, I don't know where I got the ten years thing from. Could have swore I head that said at one point. Disregard that. blackeyed

wottan

wottan

Vancouver, BC
July 2004

DEC 16, 2006 10:04 PM

Man I cant even imagine have 3 of your kids killed like that. Itd be hard for me to do anything but sit and cry for about a year.