• commentary
  • THURSDAY SEPTEMBER 28 2006 7:00 PM

A Statement of Conscience

My government is supposed to represent me, and as an American citizen, I must accept responsibility for the things my country does in my name. It is with that responsibility in mind that I feel compelled to write the following, not for Congress who have already ignored my calls and letters, but for my own conscience, and for my children, should they one day ask me, "What happened then? Why didn't anyone try to do anything?"

As I write this, the United States Senate is engaged in a bit of political theater, while they pretend to debate whether or not they will make torture an American value. They are pretending to debate whether or not to give one person -- in this case the president -- the ability remove rights that we've all taken for granted under our Constitution for over two centuries from anyone he (or she, someday) identifies, without any accountability or oversight. They are pretending to debate whether our Democracy even matters, any more.

The legislation before the Senate today would ban torture, but let Bush define it; would allow the president to imprison indefinitely anyone he decides falls under a wide-ranging new definition of unlawful combatant; would suspend the Great Writ of habeas corpus; would immunize retroactively those who may have engaged in torture. And that's just for starters. . . .

Today's vote will show more clearly than ever before that, when push comes to shove, the Republicans who control Congress are in lock step behind the president, and the Democrats -- who could block him, if they chose to do so -- are too afraid to put up a real fight.



This is far too much power for one person to have, and is antithetical to everything America and freedom and Democracy stand for. In fact, this is the sort of power that someone like, say, Saddam Hussein had. Or Stalin. Or Pinochet.

Though I've become entirely disgusted with what used to be my government and I don't have a whole lot of faith in the congress or the president to listen to me (actually, I don't have a lot of faith in the president listening to anyone who doesn't tell him exactly what he wants to hear,) I still believe in the underlying principles of Democracy. I still believe that it is the responsibility of every American, whether they feel adequately represented by the current congress or not, to stand up for their beliefs, even when they speak them to deaf ears in the halls of power. Even -- no, especially -- when those beliefs are unpopular.

What the House did yesterday, the Senate looks to do today, and the President will surely enact as soon as possible, is a direct assault on American values, and contrary to everything our country stands for. Though cynically and cowardly enacted as a purely political tool during an election, those who supported this bill do not speak for me, do not act in my name, and do not reflect my values.

Torture is not an American value. Torture is a totalitarian, sadistic value. Suspending access to courts and the right to face your accuser is not what Americans do. It is what tyrannical dictators and despots do, not a democratic republic like the one I was brought up in and love. Time and again, torture has proved unreliable to prevent or solve crimes, and it reduces our country to the level of the very terrorists we are supposedly fighting.

I believe in the right to a speedy and fair trial for everyone, even the most repugnant of defendants. No, especially for the most repugnant of defendants, because if we, as a society, can't guarantee the most hideously accused among us that right, what is it worth to the rest of us?

George Bush and his enablers in the congress -- Democrat and Republican -- has done more damage to our country, and our once impeccable moral standing in the world than all the terrorists combined. President Bush and his Republican allies in congress like to say that "they hate us for our freedom," but President Bush and his Republican allies in congress have spent the last five years working very hard to take that freedom away from the people they supposedly work for, and vest that power in something they call the Unitary Executive. If the Democrats won't stand up to stop torture, what will they stand up for? If Congress won't do its constitutional duty now, then when?

I am disgusted with, and ashamed of my government.

Shame on President Bush. Shame on his Republican allies in congress, and shame on the spineless, cowardly Democrats who did not stand up to them. Shame on them all, and shame on all of us if we do not turn out by the millions in the next election to put men and women into congress who will have the courage to do their constitutional duty, and defend the Republic from all enemies, foreign and domestic.

 

Previous

PAGE: 

1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5

Next

Comments
attn_ho

attn_ho

Brooklyn, NY
February 2004

SEP 28, 2006 11:11 PM

'tristero' on 'digby's blog had some depressing words on this today.


The truth is that the United States government is presently holding, torturing, and even murdering countless numbers of people who have no chance in hell of obtaining a lawyer, let alone anything resembling a trial. The government is doing this under the direct orders of George W. Bush. There is no law, no bill, and no legislature who can stop him. If Congress were to pass a law unequivocably banning torture and send it to him, he'd use it for toilet paper. If the Supreme Court were to rule against Bush in the harshest and bluntest language, he'd yawn.

The truth is that there is a rogue presidency and there has been, since January, 2001 (earlier, if you count the stolen election). Certainly, everyone in Washington knows it, but no one dares to admit it. The bill legalizing torture merely enables Congress to pretend they still have some influence over an executive that from day one was governing, not as if they had a mandate, but as if Bush were a dictator. If, for some miracle, the bill didn't pass, every congress-critter knows Bush would keep on torturing.

Better to vote to pass and preserve the appearance of a working American government, the thinking goes. For the very thought that the US government is seriously broken - that the Executive is beyond the control of anyone and everyone in the world - is such a truly awesome and terrifying thought that it can never be publicly acknowledged. If ever it is, if the American crisis gets outed and Congress and the Supremes openly assert that the Executive has run completely amok and is beyond control, the world consequences are staggering. It is the stuff of doomsday novels.



it gets more hopeful and rabble rousing after that, but i think he nails congress' motives. fucking scary. its time to throw all the bums out. source.

and im not trying to take away from wil's powerful sentiment. but id like to understand how this bill got such support.

MrCrisp

MrCrisp

I'm lost
August 2004

SEP 28, 2006 11:20 PM

+1 to wil.

and jesus, attn_ho. that one hit me hard.

joker_

joker_

Minneapolis, MN
October 2005

SEP 29, 2006 01:07 AM

Wil, very well said.

MschfMayhemSoap

MschfMayhemSoap

Phoenix, AZ
April 2006

SEP 29, 2006 01:17 AM

attn_ho said:

SPOILERS! (Click to view)
'tristero' on 'digby's blog had some depressing words on this today.


The truth is that the United States government is presently holding, torturing, and even murdering countless numbers of people who have no chance in hell of obtaining a lawyer, let alone anything resembling a trial. The government is doing this under the direct orders of George W. Bush. There is no law, no bill, and no legislature who can stop him. If Congress were to pass a law unequivocably banning torture and send it to him, he'd use it for toilet paper. If the Supreme Court were to rule against Bush in the harshest and bluntest language, he'd yawn.

The truth is that there is a rogue presidency and there has been, since January, 2001 (earlier, if you count the stolen election). Certainly, everyone in Washington knows it, but no one dares to admit it. The bill legalizing torture merely enables Congress to pretend they still have some influence over an executive that from day one was governing, not as if they had a mandate, but as if Bush were a dictator. If, for some miracle, the bill didn't pass, every congress-critter knows Bush would keep on torturing.

Better to vote to pass and preserve the appearance of a working American government, the thinking goes. For the very thought that the US government is seriously broken - that the Executive is beyond the control of anyone and everyone in the world - is such a truly awesome and terrifying thought that it can never be publicly acknowledged. If ever it is, if the American crisis gets outed and Congress and the Supremes openly assert that the Executive has run completely amok and is beyond control, the world consequences are staggering. It is the stuff of doomsday novels.



it gets more hopeful and rabble rousing after that, but i think he nails congress' motives. fucking scary. its time to throw all the bums out. source.

and im not trying to take away from wil's powerful sentiment. but id like to understand how this bill got such support.



This make me wanna think about buy some land up in Canada and starting a commune, calling it "Refugees from America", if the Repubs keep the House and Senate this Fall. Who's with me?

orbro

orbro

New York, NY
July 2004

SEP 29, 2006 02:32 AM

thanks wil. the democrats (11 voted for this) have proven themselves to be the wimps the right wing says they are. i am beside myself and beside my country. where the fuck am i?

bean

bean

STAFF

Los Angeles, CA

SEP 29, 2006 02:50 AM

orbro said:
thanks wil. the democrats (11 voted for this) have proven themselves to be the wimps the right wing says they are. i am beside myself and beside my country. where the fuck am i?



Eleven democrats, out of 44. That's 1/4 of the Democratic Senators. 75% of the Senate Democrats (and one Republican) voted Nay. The day I sit by and let people get away with asserting that 25% is proof of a generalization when 75% contradict that generalization is the day I give up arguing anything with anyone.

By the way, both of your Senators voted Nay. You're in a sane state; that's where you are.

filmjedi

filmjedi

Brighton, MA
June 2004

SEP 29, 2006 04:56 AM

its days like this i wish i was an ensign on a star cruiser...in a universe that put science and wonder ahead of this bs...at this rate, the vulcans won't ever want to help us out.

darwinsjoke

darwinsjoke

Virginia Beach, VA
July 2003

SEP 29, 2006 08:22 AM

bean said:

orbro said:
thanks wil. the democrats (11 voted for this) have proven themselves to be the wimps the right wing says they are. i am beside myself and beside my country. where the fuck am i?



Eleven democrats, out of 44. That's 1/4 of the Democratic Senators. 75% of the Senate Democrats (and one Republican) voted Nay. The day I sit by and let people get away with asserting that 25% is proof of a generalization when 75% contradict that generalization is the day I give up arguing anything with anyone.

By the way, both of your Senators voted Nay. You're in a sane state; that's where you are.


Unfortunately both of my senators voted for this travesty and one of the is a democrat who's crushing his opponent right now. You are correct to point out that 75% voted against, but I would point out that I believe that we had a failure of leadership in opposing this bill. We heard almost no democrats speaking out when the bill was first proposed. The only voices we heard until the bill was introduced were Mccain, Graham, and Warner. The fact that Reid failed to muster any shred of a defense was pathetic.

Chainlink

Chainlink

Key West, FL
August 2005

SEP 29, 2006 08:43 AM

Hopefully this will help clarify the situation and define the whos who.

Bush, the entire administration, and a large part of Congress and the Senate should now be legally defined in accordance with thier bill as Enemy Combatants and taken away to a secret prison as soon as possible.

yurei

yurei

USA
June 2006

SEP 29, 2006 09:19 AM

The rich, hemp-growing, beer drinking, slave-owning [forefathers] of this country didn't refer to the American public as "the great beast" for nothing. Those in leadership do fear those who built the thrones of power with blood, sweat, and tears. Many may call [me/us] ungrateful for living in "the best country in the world" and still bitch, whine, and complain (or even simply question anything our government does) but I refuse to be a sheep and just go along with whatever plans and ideas the government puts forth for approval. I refuse to sit back and nod in agreement as they torture, maim, beat, and kill fellow human beings who I know nothing about all in the name of freedom and democracy.

Thank you for Wil for this "statement of conscience."

stainedecho

stainedecho

Bloomington, IN
September 2005

SEP 29, 2006 09:43 AM

Well put, good sir!

Subrosa

Subrosa

San Francisco, CA
July 2004

SEP 29, 2006 09:59 AM

darwinsjoke said:

bean said:

orbro said:
thanks wil. the democrats (11 voted for this) have proven themselves to be the wimps the right wing says they are. i am beside myself and beside my country. where the fuck am i?



Eleven democrats, out of 44. That's 1/4 of the Democratic Senators. 75% of the Senate Democrats (and one Republican) voted Nay. The day I sit by and let people get away with asserting that 25% is proof of a generalization when 75% contradict that generalization is the day I give up arguing anything with anyone.

By the way, both of your Senators voted Nay. You're in a sane state; that's where you are.


Unfortunately both of my senators voted for this travesty and one of the is a democrat who's crushing his opponent right now. You are correct to point out that 75% voted against, but I would point out that I believe that we had a failure of leadership in opposing this bill. We heard almost no democrats speaking out when the bill was first proposed. The only voices we heard until the bill was introduced were Mccain, Graham, and Warner. The fact that Reid failed to muster any shred of a defense was pathetic.



You had me scared there for a second thinking that Feinstein and Boxer voted for this garbage.

Agreed on your assessment of Reid.

darwinsjoke

darwinsjoke

Virginia Beach, VA
July 2003

SEP 29, 2006 10:19 AM

Subrosa said:

darwinsjoke said:

bean said:

orbro said:
thanks wil. the democrats (11 voted for this) have proven themselves to be the wimps the right wing says they are. i am beside myself and beside my country. where the fuck am i?



Eleven democrats, out of 44. That's 1/4 of the Democratic Senators. 75% of the Senate Democrats (and one Republican) voted Nay. The day I sit by and let people get away with asserting that 25% is proof of a generalization when 75% contradict that generalization is the day I give up arguing anything with anyone.

By the way, both of your Senators voted Nay. You're in a sane state; that's where you are.


Unfortunately both of my senators voted for this travesty and one of the is a democrat who's crushing his opponent right now. You are correct to point out that 75% voted against, but I would point out that I believe that we had a failure of leadership in opposing this bill. We heard almost no democrats speaking out when the bill was first proposed. The only voices we heard until the bill was introduced were Mccain, Graham, and Warner. The fact that Reid failed to muster any shred of a defense was pathetic.



You had me scared there for a second thinking that Feinstein and Boxer voted for this garbage.

Agreed on your assessment of Reid.


I live in California but I'm a registered Florida resident/voter so my worthless senators are Mel Martinez and Bill Nelson. I just spoke with Sen. Nelson's office and his staffer said that the senator believes that this travesty IMPROVES OUR RELATIONS with the rest of the world and complies with the Geneva Conventions!? He has proven himself to be a clueless moron unfit to hold office (at least in my eyes).

MisterGone

MisterGone

Minneapolis, MN
March 2006

SEP 29, 2006 10:41 AM

What disgusts me is that McCain of all people isn't on hunger strike or chaining himself to the capital doors, he's trying to fine a "compromise" to torture. I can't tell you how happy I am to have dual citizenship with Ireland and the US, of course since I'm a "naturalized" citizen my rights have been severely threatened (read: become nothing more then lip service) since post 9/11.

SockPuppet

SockPuppet

I'm lost
July 2006

SEP 29, 2006 03:33 PM

I'm not American, so I can't speak to your dismay. But this is a betrayal, for everyone who believed that the huddled masses might still strive to be free.

Previous

PAGE: 

1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5

Next