• commentary
  • SUNDAY JUNE 18 2006 1:00 PM

Politicians On Layaway, Laws On Standby

As if the banking industry didn't get enough of a gift with last year's corrosive Bankruptcy Abuse Prevention and Consumer Protection Act, they are back this year for more. And just as that bill offered no consumer protections, (on the contrary, it punishes consumers while allowing corporations to continue to break contracts and shed pensions via Chapter 11) their new pet legislation seeks to limit individuals' ability to protect themselves from identity theft. The name of the bill, the Financial Data Protection Act of 2006, is of course completely misleading. While 18 states have provisions for any consumer to "freeze" or limit access to their credit reports, the new "protection" would restrict freezes to those who have already had their identity stolen. And worse, the bill:

...would also weaken state laws requiring disclosure of security breaches. In California, businesses must notify people if their personal info "was, or is reasonably believed to have been, acquired by an unauthorized person."

Under the proposed federal legislation, such disclosure would have to be made only if a company determines that a security breach "is reasonably likely to result in harm or inconvenience" to individual consumers.



With identity theft rampant, and security breaches on the rise - including several examples of lapses by the federal government to go along with countless private sector breakdowns - why is it that consumer protections need to be weakened? The poor bankers say it's just too hard to follow state laws:

"In light of the continuing wave of legislation in the states creating a patchwork of standards with which our companies must comply, the need for comprehensive federal legislation in this area is vital."



It must be tremendously difficult for Bank of America to keep track of all of this on their lone 18th century abacus, but other factors are at work. Disclosing security breaches results in bad press, and it's cheaper to buy a few politicians (of both parties) than to do a better job of protecting consumer data. And more importantly credit freezes cut down on impulse purchases like cars, washer/dryers, and furniture.

When it comes to easy credit, a few bucks in legalized bribery is a small price to pay when the reward is the ability to sell goods with "NO MONEY DOWN / NO PAYMENTS 'TIL 2009!"

 
Comments
slow_grafitti

slow_grafitti

Downey, CA
June 2006

JUN 18, 2006 01:24 PM

soo has this been passed by congress oink? by the senate?

politicalsuicide

politicalsuicide

I'm lost
May 2006

JUN 18, 2006 01:29 PM

passed by the house. it will probably come before the senate this week.

slow_grafitti

slow_grafitti

Downey, CA
June 2006

JUN 18, 2006 01:36 PM

RedBstrd

RedBstrd

Riverside, CA
April 2004

JUN 18, 2006 02:43 PM

politicalsuicide said:
passed by the house. it will probably come before the senate this week.



Thank you for posting this. I wrote to both of Nevada's Senators.

Eiron

Eiron

Buffalo, NY
May 2006

JUN 18, 2006 03:30 PM


And more importantly credit freezes cut down on impulse purchases like cars, washer/dryers, and furniture.



I will frequently go on weekend binges, black-out, and wake up with a new dinette set.