• feature
  • WEDNESDAY JUNE 14 2006 9:00 AM

Broken Jaws: From Ben Roethlisberger to Kevin Aviance

Every city likes to think that their loyalty to their hometown teams is without peer, but the bond between the city of Pittsburgh and the Steelers transcends loyalty to the point that the town without the team is simply unimaginable. That the Steelers came to dominance as their namesake industry was on the wane, dragging down civic pride and salaries alike, is one of the reasons that through good seasons and bad, it has been nearly impossible to get a ticket to the stadium or pass a TV on Sundays not tuned to the game for 30 years. From the time I was a kid, the only thing that eased the dread of returning to school on Monday was the simple pleasure of watching the game with my dad. At one point, he signed us up for the season ticket waiting list, then something like 15 years long. More often than not, we'd watch at home, or over a burger at a selection of dive bars only inhabitable by normal folk on Steeler Sundays. From time to time, he would get 50-yard-line seats through his work with Nike, or the college where he was Director of Athletics, his office just a few blocks from the field. Maybe once a year we would drive down to the stadium and he would buy scalped tickets at absurd markups. No matter where the seats were located, we would always make our way to the 600 level at the very top of Three Rivers Stadium. My dad always said that you could see more from up there, and he was right, but that wasn't the best reason to give up field-level for the nosebleed section. While the box seats were full of doctors and lawyers entertaining clients or showing off to their friends, 600 was where real Pittsburghers sat and cheered for the Steelers.

Through winning seasons and losing, talented teams and scrubs, Pittsburgh has stood by the Black and Gold. With the glory days of Super Bowls over and some of the players on those teams aging and even dying before their time, the 2004 season saw unheralded rookie Ben Roethlisberger go undefeated after taking over the starting job, leading the team to the AFC championship game. During that off-season, Roethlisberger, who won the fans' love in record time, tangled with Steelers coach Bill Cowher over the QB's penchant for riding his motorcycle sans helmet:

Ben Roethlisberger was lectured by Steelers coach Bill Cowher on the dangers of riding a motorcycle without a helmet -- as Roethlisberger has been spotted doing recently -- but the quarterback isn't ready to get off his $20,000 cycle.
[...]
"I'll just continue to be careful. I told him we don't ever ride alone, we always ride in a group of people, and I think it makes it even more safe."
[...]
"Obviously Pennsylvania doesn't think people need to (wear a helmet)," he said. "There's a law you've got to wear it in football."
[...]
"I certainly don't condone that," Cowher said. "It (playing pro football) is a very small time in your life and you've got to be very careful -- you can see it documented with Kellen Winslow in Cleveland. There are choices and consequences ... not just in riding motorcycles, but where you go and who you associate with. You have control over them but once you make your decision, they control you."



Soon after that, the 2005 season started, and Roethlisberger fought through potential season-ending injuries to lead the Steelers to their first Super Bowl win in 25 years. Big Ben turned into Saint Ben, and did as he pleased. >Until:

Pittsburgh Steelers quarterback Ben Roethlisberger is undergoing surgery after a motorcycle accident on Monday morning, doctors at Mercy Hospital said.
Roethlisberger is in serious but stable condition, according to Dr. Larry Jones.
[...]
According to a police source, Roethlisberger suffered a broken jaw, broke his left sinus cavity, suffered a 9-inch laceration to the back of his head, lost many teeth and has severe injuries to his knees from hitting the pavement.



Needless to say, Roethlisberger was not wearing a helmet, was riding alone not with a group of people, and wasn't being careful. Sandra Ford, a witness said:

"I kept waiting for the motorcyclist to slow down," she said. "He never stopped and just plowed into the car."
[...]
Ford said she believes Roethlisberger, who wasn't speeding, but going at a pretty good clip, never saw the car. "He had to be looking somewhere else, he just sailed across the intersection."



Pennsylvania used to have a strict helmet law before the NASCAR-ification of the commonwealth reached a point in 2003 that allowed repeal of the law for riders with two years on a bike or who managed to pass a safety class. Since the law's repeal, motorcycle deaths have increased by more than 30%. Though Roethlisberger was no doubt fully insured, (sparing PA taxpayers from footing the bill) 24% of motor vehicle injury medical costs are covered by government health insurance programs, and those that aren't raise insurance rates for everyone else. Incalculable are the costs to the Steelers organization - and the City of Pittsburgh - if Roethlisberger is, as speculated, unable to play again.

Despite my lifelong allegiance to the Steelers, and my gratitude to Ben Roethlisberger for bringing home the Lombardi Trophy, I feel nothing for him today. On Monday, I received texts, calls, emails and IMs with minute-by-minute updates from friends and family both in Pittsburgh and elsewhere. My sister said she felt sick. Others were in shock as Roethlisberger's condition oscillated from lying in a pool of blood to stable to serious to surgery to whatever it is now. I didn't and don't feel sick or sorry for him. I'm angry. Angry at someone who was given the opportunity to lead a professional football team as a rookie. Angry at someone who earned $4.5 million in endorsements, more than $9 million in bonus money, $230,000 in salary and $2.3 million in incentives in his first year ignoring his coach and his predecessor Terry Bradshaw's advice not to risk his career by riding without a helmet. Angry at someone who valued his little hobby over the hard work his teammates put into protecting him on the field. Angry at someone who accepted the love of his fans and then pissed on their dreams because he wanted to be a rebel.

But I'm most angry because Roethlisberger sustained his injuries, including a broken jaw, by choice. But he will be the recipient of tens of thousands of cards, millions of prayers and a massive amount of supportive press, things another man who sustained a broken jaw just days earlier will not.



Back in the early 90s, I used to travel the east coast with my friends in search of the club/rave scene that had yet to mature in Pittsburgh. Weekend trips to New York, Baltimore, and Washington D.C were commonplace, and on more than a few occasions, the nights featured performances or were hosted by vocalist Kevin Aviance. Now diva house and drag shows aren't at the top of my entertainment list, but Aviance's star power was undeniable, and his sterling reputation in his scene is certainly well-deserved. Four New York men apparently didn't get the memo. They beat Aviance almost to death, shattering his jaw in a vicious hate crime. "Hate crime" doesn't even begin to cover it:

They yelled "kill the faggot" and other epithets during the beating, said Len Evans, Aviance's publicist.



The reason that Aviance was attacked is one of the reasons that a Google news search for "Kevin Aviance" yields 368 results after 3 days, while one for "Ben Roethlisberger" yields more than 2,000 after just a few hours. Of course Roethlisberger has achieved a much higher level of fame than Aviance, but the fact remains that one man ignored his safety and all good advice, risked his career and his team's success, and willingly put his life in danger, while the other was attacked and nearly killed for nothing more than his sexual preference.

While the majority of Pittsburghers everywhere will be praying for Roethlisberger, this relocated Pittsburgher will be rooting for Aviance to recover in time for his scheduled performance at New York's Gay Pride Parade.

 

Previous

PAGE: 

1 | 2

Next

Comments
PointBlank

PointBlank

New York, NY
November 2004

JUN 14, 2006 09:29 AM


Despite my lifelong allegiance to the Steelers, and my gratitude to Ben Roethlisberger for bringing home the Lombardi Trophy, I feel nothing for him today.



"Thanks for all the great sports memories, but now that you're hurt--Fuck off!!"

Yup, the Steelers fans are the greatest in the world!

Margot_Dent

Margot_Dent

Los Angeles, CA
February 2004

JUN 14, 2006 09:36 AM

though i'm not into sports, that was a great article. good work.

FridgeMagnet

FridgeMagnet

Chicago, IL
November 2004

JUN 14, 2006 09:50 AM

PointBlank said:

Despite my lifelong allegiance to the Steelers, and my gratitude to Ben Roethlisberger for bringing home the Lombardi Trophy, I feel nothing for him today.



"Thanks for all the great sports memories, but now that you're hurt--Fuck off!!"

Yup, the Steelers fans are the greatest in the world!



Dude....

FridgeMagnet

FridgeMagnet

Chicago, IL
November 2004

JUN 14, 2006 09:51 AM

And M_D's right, that was a fantastic piece. Well done.

thefaintjoy

thefaintjoy

Tampa, FL
May 2006

JUN 14, 2006 09:53 AM

i understand your point and i agree. these discussions/comparisons are easy to misconstrue and write off which is a problem.

for a less serious comparison, it's is the equivalent of explaining to a friend that Green Day's new album is shit, even though its platinum.

the usual rhetoric is always that "you" are jealous, or have a hidden agenda. yes, if you are going to compare the two incidences, one would be inclined to feel less remorse for Roethlisberger. though i doubt he meant to do it intentionally, he was in control of his situation (if you don't agree, see where the other driver was not ticketed for the accident). truth be told, people will still assume you're jealous because you are writing him off based of his monetary status and popularity.

the discussion on this could be insightful, but most likely will be unjustifiable rhetoric. good luck.

PointBlank

PointBlank

New York, NY
November 2004

JUN 14, 2006 10:13 AM

FridgeMagnet said:

PointBlank said:

Despite my lifelong allegiance to the Steelers, and my gratitude to Ben Roethlisberger for bringing home the Lombardi Trophy, I feel nothing for him today.



"Thanks for all the great sports memories, but now that you're hurt--Fuck off!!"

Yup, the Steelers fans are the greatest in the world!



Dude....



Just a bit of Steeler taunting...

I do think it's sort of shitty to claim you "feel nothing" for a guy who has been seriously hurt. No matter who he is.

PointBlank

PointBlank

New York, NY
November 2004

JUN 14, 2006 10:52 AM

I guess what I'm trying to say is that we shouldn't be surprised when young people do something stupid like this. And it doesn't mean that, simply because he did something dangerous and reckless, he is beneath a little bit of sympathy. Claiming that he "pissed on the dreams" of an entire city is a bit more than harsh, and pretty undeserved. Being a millionaire or an athlete does not make you immune from fucking up occasionally...especially when you're young and believe you're going to live forever. I think too much this sort of deification of athletes (putting the hopes and dreams of an entire city on them) leads to people forgetting that they are just people. And people make bad choices sometimes.


My first post was too flippant and I agree that the article was well-written. . .I just don't agree with the message.

AluminumOvercast

AluminumOvercast

Pittsburgh, PA
May 2006

JUN 14, 2006 12:47 PM

PointBlank said:

Despite my lifelong allegiance to the Steelers, and my gratitude to Ben Roethlisberger for bringing home the Lombardi Trophy, I feel nothing for him today.



"Thanks for all the great sports memories, but now that you're hurt--Fuck off!!"

Yup, the Steelers fans are the greatest in the world!



Piss off, buddy.

destijl01

destijl01

Kent, OH
January 2006

JUN 14, 2006 12:56 PM

um, you might want to read this:

http://sports.espn.go.com/nfl/columns/story?columnist=clayton_john&id=2482957

...i am from Pittsburgh too, so I very much appreciate this article. Before us angry Pittsburghers lose sight of all realities, read that article. He got lucky. He'll be fine.

MisterSatan

MisterSatan

Portland, OR
August 2002

JUN 14, 2006 01:02 PM

... but upon further review, the referees ruled that it was caused by the Seahawks, and they'll be assessed a 15 yard penalty.

FridgeMagnet

FridgeMagnet

Chicago, IL
November 2004

JUN 14, 2006 01:11 PM

PointBlank said:
I guess what I'm trying to say is that we shouldn't be surprised when young people do something stupid like this. And it doesn't mean that, simply because he did something dangerous and reckless, he is beneath a little bit of sympathy. Claiming that he "pissed on the dreams" of an entire city is a bit more than harsh, and pretty undeserved. Being a millionaire or an athlete does not make you immune from fucking up occasionally...especially when you're young and believe you're going to live forever. I think too much this sort of deification of athletes (putting the hopes and dreams of an entire city on them) leads to people forgetting that they are just people. And people make bad choices sometimes.


My first post was too flippant and I agree that the article was well-written. . .I just don't agree with the message.



Dude!

Definitely agree with you.

destijl01

destijl01

Kent, OH
January 2006

JUN 14, 2006 01:29 PM

MisterSatan said:
... but upon further review, the referees ruled that it was caused by the Seahawks, and they'll be assessed a 15 yard penalty.




...oh don't be upset that they were a two man team. they had no chance against anyone from the AFC

Jordan

Jordan

SUICIDEGIRL

New York, USA

JUN 14, 2006 02:27 PM

excellent point. i hope Aviance makes it through. its not so much his jaw, but the way he looked when he was wheeled out of the hospital, the look on his face, really truly heartbreaking.
thank you for writing this. its very well written. skull

joker_

joker_

Minneapolis, MN
October 2005

JUN 14, 2006 02:49 PM

I enjoyed this article a great deal. The hypocrisy of our culture is put into sharp focus by your article.
I do agree with point blank and fridge; just because he made a mistake and is an athlete on a pedestal; does not make him some how not deserving of basic human sympathy.
How much sympathy is arguable.

As for Aviance, he is deserving of both sympathy and justice in unlimited quantities. Unfortunately, this particular culture is predominantly anti-homosexual which is very irritating.

Stiles

Stiles

Oakland, CA
November 2002

JUN 14, 2006 07:12 PM

Roethlisberger is an adult and made his own decisions. I personally would never ride without a helmet, but it's his choice to make, no matter how dumb I think his choice might be.

As for the rest of the article, the OP has no idea if he was being careful or not, as a car turned in front of him and no mention is made of the details of the accident. From your cited article:

Police are still investigating Monday's accident and it is unclear whether charges will be filed.



Most car/bike accidents are the auto driver's fault, and having cars turn left in front of you is a common cause of car/bike accidents.
Study of motorcycle safety in the US
exerpted from summary:

1. Approximately three-fourths of these motorcycle accidents involved collision with another vehicle, which was most usually a passenger automobile.

6. In the multiple vehicle accidents, the driver of the other vehicle violated the motorcycle right-of-way and caused the accident in two-thirds of those accidents.




23`year olds in general and pro athletes in particular get lots of ego from being who they are, and it's hard to find a more macho mainstream sport than football.

You ever think that that might have something to do with the poor choices and bad behavior that affects many pro athletes? If people didn't turn him into "saint Ben" he might have been a little more sensible.

Also, Steelers management shares some of the blame here - the coach talked to BR about riding without a helmet, and riding in general, but they didn't put a clause in his contract to prohibit riding... even when BR said he was going to keep doing it, and without a helmet no less!

That is incredibly, unbelieveably stupid of them.

Previous

PAGE: 

1 | 2

Next