• news
  • SUNDAY MARCH 26 2006 11:58 AM

Over Half a Million People Protest HR4437

To follow up on Friday's story about nationwide protests against pending legislation H.R.4437, on Saturday, March 25th, over 500,000 people raised their voices in the streets of downtown Los Angeles. Suicidegirls.com member Margot_Dent lives smack in the middle of the protest area, so I asked her to run outside with her trusty Polaroid camera and take as many pictures as she could. The protest pictures are available on Flickr.

Margot_Dent writes:

Jesus, that was such an amazing thing to be a part of. In all my life living in Southern California have I ever wished to had taken Spanish instead of French in high school more. The only thing I really understood was the frequent cry of "Viva!" It was an intense experience seeing so many people gathered for a single cause. In my two hours or so walking with them and down the streets, I never saw anyone fighting or getting out of hand. When I spoke to a few cops, they said that everything had gone rather smoothly. Officer Randomguy** said that yes, there had been "minor things" (who knows what) as there always are when thousands of people gather in one spot, but that you just have to remember "to be careful, and that the actions of a few people don't represent a whole group." Though the officers I spoke to were hesitant to say much, they were mostly friendly and calm like Officer Randomguy.

protest001: No one else quite stood out like this. These guys were the only people I saw with more than face paint, tshirts, or flags. Not quite sure what their sign said because I was being hurried by the crowd, but they were the only ones that I saw that would stop and pose every time anyone wanted to take a picture.

protest002: On Broadway between 3rd and 4th, the girl in the sweatshirt blew the whistle around her neck and held up her "Who's the illegal alien, Pilgrim?" sign and was met with screams and cheers that lasted a good minute and a half. The protest had thousands of voices but many times, honestly, it really sounded like there was just one incredibly strong and loud one. Both girls were with M.E.CH.A, the Chicano Resistance. They were very nice to me and answered a lot of the questions I had. Apparently they were chanting (but in Spanish) "When the people are united they cannot be stopped."

protest003: One thing that struck me the most about the protest was the huge number of children. It really reminded you why the people were out there: because they have families. There were hundreds of kids, from infants in strollers to middle schoolers, with American flags painted on their cheeks and Mexican flags draped around their shoulders. As one my favorite signs I saw said: "I am a mother. I am a worker. I am an immigrant. I am an American too."

protest004: There were lots of Jesus-on-crucifix/Virgin Mary statues and posters. That thing looked pretty heavy.

protest005: I could've crowd surfed better than at Coachella. Standing in the middle of that mass of people made it feel at least 10 degrees hotter than it was outside. I smell bad. That's City Hall in the background, at Temple and Broadway. I turned up 1st because I felt that if I kept on down Broadway towards the building I'd never be able to turn around and shove my way home.

protest006: This guy's shirt said "We are not criminals." I hope he didn't end up falling down, he was perched pretty precariously (alliteration not intended, I promise).

protest007: These people were singing "Mexico Lindo", or "Beautiful Mexico". The guy had his guitar plugged into a little portable amp that was under his son's stroller. Everyone within half a block was singing along to every word. I got really choked up, it was beautiful.

protest009: Just a crowd shot from standing on a planter in from of Grand Central Market on Broadway, between 3rd and 4th.

protest010: In front of my building. There were Mexican and American flags on everyone and every thing, even the people selling cotton candy. I don't know if I know anyone as patriotic as the people that were marching today.

I know there was a lot that I wanted to say, but I really can't think of it now. It was stunning to witness and be a part of. Now it's time to shower and nap.

**Editor's Note: I assume "Randomguy" was not actually the LAPD officer's last name, but rather that Margot didn't catch his real name...



One thing Margot mentioned to me on the phone shortly after the protest was that everyone she talked to knew exactly what the legislation was trying to do and knew exactly why there were there. She was pleasantly surprised that even the angry high school students present were well-versed in the legislation.

Despite the huge numbers of people and high levels of emotion involved, the protests stayed completely peaceful.

President Bush has worked very hard to appeal to the Latino community in the United States and is in favor of a "guest worker" program rather than further criminalization of undocumented workers. If this bill passes Congress, will Bush use his very first veto?

 

Previous

PAGE: 

1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6

Next

Comments
Lotusmonger

Lotusmonger

Chicago, IL
May 2004

MAR 26, 2006 12:23 PM

Subrosa

Subrosa

San Francisco, CA
July 2004

MAR 26, 2006 12:24 PM

Great shots, Margot.

She's fucking amazing with that polaroid.

Margot_Dent

Margot_Dent

Los Angeles, CA
February 2004

MAR 26, 2006 12:25 PM

Subrosa said:
Great shots, Margot.

She's fucking amazing with that polaroid.



blush thank you

it's an expensive hobby to practice, but i rather like it.

Subrosa

Subrosa

San Francisco, CA
July 2004

MAR 26, 2006 12:32 PM

Shalome said:
Officer Randomguy said...


That guy must have the hardest time getting people to believe his last name.

"No, really! It's German!"

LiquidYogi

LiquidYogi

Claremont, CA
September 2003

MAR 26, 2006 12:33 PM

I must be confused. I don't understand how people can think its unfair to make something like not having citizenship illegal. I can understand the whole idea of how we do need these people to keep our infustructure running. But haven't we reached the point where we've got all we can handle? So we should I guess start enforcing the laws now. How is that unfair.

(I haven't studied this that much, soo I really don't know...I just have a bunch of questions)

Calypso

Calypso

SUICIDEGIRL

California, USA

MAR 26, 2006 12:39 PM

LiquidYogi said:
I must be confused. I don't understand how people can think its unfair to make something like not having citizenship illegal. I can understand the whole idea of how we do need these people to keep our infustructure running. But haven't we reached the point where we've got all we can handle? So we should I guess start enforcing the laws now. How is that unfair.

(I haven't studied this that much, soo I really don't know...I just have a bunch of questions)



Agreed.

Ells

Ells

Modesto, CA
July 2003

MAR 26, 2006 12:46 PM

If mexicans want to come into this country, live here and work here then they need to do it the same way people from the rest of the world have to, Legaly. If they can't do it legaly then the laws of our nation need to be enforced. It is simple black and white. Nothing else.

cspeedball

cspeedball

I'm lost
July 2003

MAR 26, 2006 12:46 PM

I dont want to sound like a redneck prick but if they think mexico is so beautiful why didn't they stay there? Just a thought.

Margot_Dent

Margot_Dent

Los Angeles, CA
February 2004

MAR 26, 2006 12:47 PM

cspeedball said:
I dont want to sound like a redneck prick but if they think mexico is so beautiful why didn't they stay there? Just a thought.



sooo you *don't* want to sound like a redneck prick? confused

Shal

Shal

Los Angeles, CA
October 2002

MAR 26, 2006 12:48 PM

Sularma said:
If mexicans want to come into this country, live here and work here then they need to do it the same way people from the rest of the world have to, Legaly. If they can't do it legaly then the laws of our nation need to be enforced. It is simple black and white. Nothing else.



I know of at least two Suicidegirls from foreign countries who were in the U.S. illegally and working here for long periods of time (addendum: both have since completely resolved their legal issues).

Feel the same about them?

[Edited on Mar 26, 2006 2:28PM]

jake_lex

jake_lex

Lexington, KY
February 2003

MAR 26, 2006 12:49 PM

cspeedball said:
I dont want to sound like a redneck prick but if they think mexico is so beautiful why didn't they stay there? Just a thought.



For the same reason that my grandfather moved to Detroit for about 5 years from Eastern Kentucky, which he always loved and cherished as long as he lived, when World War II broke out. He knew that working the plants there that time would make him enough money to go back to Eastern Kentucky to live with a nice nest egg for the rest of his life.

Why is it when brown people do the same thing, it's something we gotta crack down on?

LiquidYogi

LiquidYogi

Claremont, CA
September 2003

MAR 26, 2006 12:50 PM

cspeedball said:
I dont want to sound like a redneck prick but if they think mexico is so beautiful why didn't they stay there? Just a thought.



Well you Certainly acheived that goal.

however you do have some of a point of very proud Mexicans who talk about how horrible the US is and how GREAT Mexico is. Its great that you love your country but you're in the US for a reason...maybe at least respecting it a bit would be good.

Dead_Ringer

Dead_Ringer

I'm lost
September 2004

MAR 26, 2006 12:50 PM

LiquidYogi said:
I must be confused. I don't understand how people can think its unfair to make something like not having citizenship illegal.


That's not what HR 4437 seeks to do. It seeks to criminalize unlawful presence in the U.S. At this point, presence in the U.S. absent inspection or documentation is merely an administrative offense. The interesting thing here is that if this resolution passes (which it will not), unlawful presence in the U.S. will now, for the first time in out histroy, be subject to full 5th amendment due process, as a "crime" would be implicated.

In any event, for the most part, I support the president's proposal, as do most immigration lawyers, employers, and law enforcement. This proposal will never make it out of committee, OR it will be attached to something unpopular so that less than 2/3 of the Senate will not have to vote for it - thereby either (a) keeping from passing entirely, or (b) giving the president a chance to veto it - which I believe he would if it landed on his desk.

palegge

palegge

Collierville, TN
September 2005

MAR 26, 2006 12:51 PM

cspeedball said:
I dont want to sound like a redneck prick but if they think mexico is so beautiful why didn't they stay there? Just a thought.



From what I understand the Mexican government encourages it's citizens to cross into the US. Their military also helps them make it across since the money that they bring back helps support their government not to mention the drug, extortion and child prostitution that goes on down there.

LiquidYogi

LiquidYogi

Claremont, CA
September 2003

MAR 26, 2006 12:52 PM

jake_lex said:

cspeedball said:
I dont want to sound like a redneck prick but if they think mexico is so beautiful why didn't they stay there? Just a thought.



For the same reason that my grandfather moved to Detroit for about 5 years from Eastern Kentucky, which he always loved and cherished as long as he lived, when World War II broke out. He knew that working the plants there that time would make him enough money to go back to Eastern Kentucky to live with a nice nest egg for the rest of his life.

Why is it when brown people do the same thing, it's something we gotta crack down on?




Ya I'll bet there is some racism involved. But isn't it much different now than it was then. There are like 11 million illegals aren't there? I agree that theres definitely some racism, I doubt thats the only reason though.

Previous

PAGE: 

1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6

Next