• commentary
  • MONDAY OCTOBER 29 2007 4:00 AM

The Voluntary Human Extinction Movement Has Some Good Points



I’m pretty vocal about the fact that I don’t want to procreate. I’ve told everyone I know and almost everyone that I don’t know; I don’t want kids. Surprisingly, about half the people I know are turned off by my non-existent biological clock and more surprisingly, the other half have agreed with me a little too vehemently and told me to check out the Voluntary Human Extinction Movement.

I didn’t ever bother to check the website until I decided that maybe I’d write about it. The name turned me off and I thought it sounded stupid and almost violent. After all their mission statement is:

"May we live long and die out. Phasing out the human race by voluntarily ceasing to breed will allow Earth's biosphere to return to good health. Crowded conditions and resource shortages will improve as we become less dense. We're really vehement."





My decision to not have kids is mostly based on a really simple fact -- I don’t feel like it (and never have) and even if I did feel like it, can’t afford it. I mean, not even close, not even with cutting out Starbucks like so many self-made millionaires suggest doing.

But this website is giving me some good ideas on how to comeback against my future-mother-in-law who is already disappointed in me:

Why Breed?
Reasons given:
Want to give our parents grandchildren.
Real reasons:
Still seeking parental approval.
Suggested alternatives:
Live your own life and encourage your parents to do the same.



I’m an environmentalist (as much as a I can be) so it’s rather convenient that -- since I’m dead inside and don’t want to be a mother -- that actually my not making a little baby carbon footprint is sort of good for preserving the Earth. I’m told by many that my biological urge will one day override my power of thinking and reason and I’ll scramble to make a baby and silence that urge.

I’ve always thought that ridiculous. What does the urge feel like? Is it like being horny? That’s the closest I’ve gotten and some of those wacky extinction lovers put it this way:

Humans, like all creatures, have urges which lead to reproduction. Our biological urge is to have sex, not to make babies. Our "instinct to breed" is the same as a squirrel's instinct to plant trees: the urge is to store food, trees are a natural result. If sex is an urge to procreate, then hunger's an urge to defecate.



At my worst (usually when drunk) I can get self-righteous, getting mad at breeders who procreate even though their kids might not have a shot in hell at breathing clean air and I’m the selfish one according to them?

But the VHEMT website makes a good point and calms my self-righteous urges:

Complaints of mothers and fathers being disrespected by others who care about planet Earth aren't entirely imaginary. A kick-butt mentality dominates our society: identify the enemy and kick its butt. Because breeding is the heaviest impact we can have on Nature, some see parents as enemies of the planet. But, if we all hop around in circles trying to kick each other's butts, all we'll get is pratfalls.



My apologies to all the new parents I’ve alienated.

So contrary to what I believed before, this website or movement makes a lot of sense. Some of my friends are thinking about having their second kid so that their current child doesn’t grow up alone. I mean, do we really have that luxury anymore? We’re at our capacity. And I know the automobile and meat industries are highly responsible for global warming but it seems like it’s very taboo to talk about breeding and saving the Earth in the same breath.

For example, in terms of energy consumption, when a North American couple stops at two it's about the same as an average East Indian couple stopping at 60, or an Ethiopian couple stopping at more than 600. Two is better than four, and one is twice as good as two, but to purposely set out to create even one more of us today is the moral equivalent of selling berths on a sinking ship.



Although where the site started to lose me was their hope for an Earth that eventually has no human beings whatsoever. I can’t wrap my mind around giving a shit about that. I am not really passionate about wiping out the human race entirely so that the Earth can heal but more so just letting the people who are being born have something of a chance in Hell, like I did and do, at least for now.

More than any other time in history, mankind faces a crossroads. One path leads to despair and utter hopelessness. The other, to total extinction. Let us pray we have the wisdom to choose correctly - Woody Allen



 

Previous

PAGE: 

1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6

 ... 15

Next

Comments
RedBstrd

RedBstrd

Riverside, CA
April 2004

OCT 29, 2007 04:19 AM

You had me at "I don't want to procreate."

CherryCoke

CherryCoke

Derry, NH
May 2007

OCT 29, 2007 04:26 AM

I've never wanted kids for purely selfish reasons.
But I do believe that Humans have as much right to be here as any other animal or plant or whatever. We just need to be smarter about how we treat the world.

Vermin

Vermin

United Kingdom
July 2007

OCT 29, 2007 04:41 AM

I don't want kids - mainly because I can't stand them but also I NEVER want to do that to my body, some women bounce back but I know I'd end up with floppy spaniel ear boobs and a chuff like a wizard's sleeve so childbirth can fuck off. If I hit my mid-thirties and get broody I'll probably adopt, which, considering how many orphans and unwanted children there are in the world is the right thing to do. Why make a new one when there are so many already needing love?

But I haven't made that choice because I believe the human race has to die out, that's just a bit....creepy, to be honest. This planet is overpopulated and humans are outgrowing their resources, and adding to that overpopulation is a bad idea. But I'm quite happy being alive and having a species to be part of!

Priapos

priapos

San Angelo, TX
October 2005

OCT 29, 2007 05:00 AM

People get angry when I assert that I have never heard an unselfish reason for having kids. They can't come up with one, though.

Azadeth

Azadeth

Fairport, NY
August 2006

OCT 29, 2007 05:16 AM

This is a bad idea because stupid people breed like rats. Soon they'll outnumber us and then what do you think will happen to the planet? If we're going to have humans, let's at least try to keep the more highly evolved ones in the running.

cavalryguy

cavalryguy

Elizabethtown, KY
April 2006

OCT 29, 2007 05:42 AM

i want kids mostly cus at some point with all the time overseas my luck is gonna run out and i am gonna get hurt. you can only get blown up so many times before you don't get hurt. so i'd would like to continue on, in my opinion, my good name. but i do think that idiots should not be allowed to breed.

Darke

Darke

Columbia, MO
June 2005

OCT 29, 2007 05:58 AM

cavalryguy said:
i want kids mostly cus at some point with all the time overseas my luck is gonna run out and i am gonna get hurt. you can only get blown up so many times before you don't get hurt.

so i'd would like to continue on, in my opinion, my good name.

but i do think that idiots should not be allowed to breed.



I'm not sure what getting hurt has to do with whether you breed or not, and the "idiots" comment I will not even dignify with the tempting, almost obligatory, poking of fun.

I will merely point out that this foolish notion that one can somehow gain some sort of immortality by continuing their bloodline by foisting their brood upon the world is just a mixture of vanity and one's own fear of mortality.

derekdikdik

derekdikdik

Euless, TX
June 2006

OCT 29, 2007 06:11 AM

The movie Idiocracy kind of points out the whole "idiots shouldn't be allowed to breed" thing.

Chainlink

Chainlink

Key West, FL
August 2005

OCT 29, 2007 06:23 AM

cavalryguy said:
i want kids mostly cus at some point with all the time overseas my luck is gonna run out and i am gonna get hurt. you can only get blown up so many times before you don't get hurt. so i'd would like to continue on, in my opinion, my good name. but i do think that idiots should not be allowed to breed.



. . . idiots should not be allowed to breed.



So, I guess we've come full circle then ?

Omega_Blue

Omega_Blue

Antelope, CA
June 2007

OCT 29, 2007 06:44 AM

Azadeth said:
This is a bad idea because stupid people breed like rats. Soon they'll outnumber us and then what do you think will happen to the planet? If we're going to have humans, let's at least try to keep the more highly evolved ones in the running.



+1

wheezy_e

wheezy_e

Boulder City, NV
April 2004

OCT 29, 2007 06:50 AM

37, no kids. I just want a voucher for that so I don't have to smog my old car every year.

charlemagne

charlemagne

Battle Creek, MI
May 2005

OCT 29, 2007 07:25 AM

Read Tolstoy's "Kreutzer Sonata."

Alfaduetto

Alfaduetto

Greeneville, TN
May 2004

OCT 29, 2007 07:54 AM

This looks like a pretty good collection of' "shouldn't be allowed to breed" so far. A self-identifying group apparently.

PointBlank

PointBlank

New York, NY
November 2004

OCT 29, 2007 07:55 AM

Self righteous non-breeders are at least as annoying as self-righteous parents.

Zarth

zarth

Seattle, WA
December 2004

OCT 29, 2007 08:05 AM

PointBlank said:
Self righteous non-breeders are at least as annoying as self-righteous parents.


Experts agree.

Previous

PAGE: 

1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6

 ... 15

Next