• news
  • FRIDAY MAY 26 2006 1:00 PM

ExtremeTech Reviews Music Recommendation Services

If you're sick to death of the same old crap they play on radio (and even satellite radio is starting to suck, now, as program directors move from terrerstrial crapfests to XM and Sirius) but don't know where to turn for new music, the Internets may just be able to help.

In addition to streaming online stations, like those from Soma, there are an increasing number of music recommendation services out there, which keep track of what you like and don't like, and then use different methods to suggest things to you that you may like.

ExtremeTech has taken a look at eight of the most popular services, scoring them based on factors like the quality of the interface and quality and quantity of the library, in addition to the obvious "did the recommendations suck or not" metric. To make this a truly useful test, they really challenged the services.

In this selection, we cross through several genres and time periods, and mix the mainstream with the more indie, unknown, or underground artists. If we wanted to find the next "American Idol," we can turn on the TV or tune into Top 40 radio. For this roundup, we want artists we don't already know about, and if a site does not have strong search results for our selected artists, they'll likely be running thin on recommending new and interesting music.

The goal, remember, is to discover new music, either from nearly-mainstream artists that you may have missed, or completely undiscovered artists that you'll like, based upon your ratings. (For example, using Pandora, I discovered The Legends and Consonant, based upon my ratings of The Shins, the Rosebuds, and The Anniversary.)

Determining what music sucks and what music rules is a very personal issue, inspiring passionate arguments (try mentioning Coldplay or Linkin Park, if you'd like to see what I mean) and these services aren't going to tell you what's good and what isn't. But they will help you cut out the signal from the noise, and make it easier for you to discover new music that you may have missed.The eight services examined are:

* MusicStrands
* Liveplasma
* UpTo11.net
* Audiri
* Pandora
* Mercora
* Yahoo LAUNCHcast Radio
* Last.fm

It's a very comprehensive look at all of them, and at the end of each one page review, you get a concise list of pros, cons, and a 1-10 rating. Most of these services rate a seven or above, with the notable exception of Yahoo's LAUNCHcast Radio which gets a dismal five, while LastFM gets a 9, and earns the ExtremeTech Approved .gif of approval.

It's interesting to note that the service with the most money and branding behind it is also earns the lowest rating, relative to all the others; could this reflect a paradigm shift in music? Are we going to see a wave of artists opting out of big labels with huge promotion budgets in favor of smaller, more passionate outfits? Is that where the audience is headed, as well?

In the Heat of the Moment, I could say yes, but Only Time Will Tell.

 
Comments
ZPO

ZPO

Roy, WA
July 2004

MAY 26, 2006 01:28 PM

My pun detector just went into overload.

crispy

crispy

NEWSWIRE

Philadelphia, PA

MAY 26, 2006 01:34 PM

I loved Asia.

But for real, that's quite informative. I refused to get satellite radio (sorry, Howard) and only listen to terrestrial radio in the car. I would love to find an internet stream that catered to what I want to hear without all the crap that I don't.

I'm going to have to check this out.
After I find and listen to my Asia CD, though. Damn you, Wil!!

malkav11

malkav11

Saint Paul, MN
July 2003

MAY 26, 2006 01:43 PM

Have to say, Pandora's where it's at as far as I'm concerned. I tried last.fm, but they played mostly the stuff I own, not new things, and their streaming and interface were not the best.

spamtwo

spamtwo

United Kingdom
April 2006

MAY 26, 2006 01:48 PM

Pandora,although it does throw up the odd choice such as Cher wtf??

WilWheaton

WilWheaton

Los Angeles, CA
June 2005

MAY 26, 2006 02:14 PM

A WWdN reader pointed out to me that I didn't link to the ExtremeTech article when this was first posted. That was a stupid mistake on my part, and has since been corrected.

bean

bean

STAFF

Los Angeles, CA

MAY 26, 2006 02:32 PM

I <3 Last.fm.

I haven't used it enough for it to give me enough recommendations to be really useful, but man it's easy, and the recommendations it has given me have been, for the most part, bands I already know I like but don't have in iTunes, and I can see the recommendations getting better as I use it.

aegies

aegies

Oakland, CA
June 2004

MAY 26, 2006 03:16 PM

i'm sold on pandora. it's one of the greatest web based applications for anyone who likes music i've ever seen. i've been using it for a few weeks, and i've already bought a few cds that i'd never even heard of.