• commentary
  • SUNDAY FEBRUARY 26 2012 9:05 PM

Got Problems? Sex, Love and Relationship Advice From SuicideGirls’ Team Agony

by SG's Team Agony feat. Dalila

Let us answer life's questions - because great advice is even better when it comes from SuicideGirls.


[Dalila in Psycho Holidays]

Q. I am in a relationship with a woman whom I love dearly and generally we are very happy. My only complaint is that she has a secret social life. For instance, she doesn't work on Tuesday, but she will be gone all day and come home after I get home. If I ask what she’s doing, she says I am out of line, even if I am just trying to make conversation. She has a group of friends that she does happy hour with and I am not allowed to meet them and I know nothing about them – not even their names. Asking about them has caused a couple of fights so I have let it go. I am also not allowed to know where they meet for happy hour.

Normally I just get a text after work that says, "Going out be home late." She has other friends that I am allowed to join for happy hour. I know these friends well and get invited, or rather told I am going to those happy hours. In contrast, when I go out I always invite her and she almost always comes with me. If she doesn't, I am okay with that, and she always asks me about who I was with, if we had a good time, what we talked about, and so on.

These are the same questions that make her very upset when I have asked them. I am not concerned that she might be cheating on me. I trust her. What really bothers me is that she feels like she needs to keep secrets from me. I really do not have any secrets and, except when she asks about my time in Iraq, I will tell her anything. I think people that keep secrets have something to hide. What do you think?


A: I don’t think that a person who keeps secrets necessarily has something to hide. People can decide to tell or not to tell, and sometimes they choose not to because they simply prefer to keep stuff to themselves. And there’s no clear evidence of seediness here.

Just think: what happened last time you had a relationship and you and your significant other had common friends? Usually, when couples split, friends are split too. There are the ones who stay with the girl, others who stick with the boy: but the original gang is often, sadly, no more. Your girlfriend might have experienced this kind of thing before, and, as a result, prefers to keep her closest slice of friends strictly to herself. Then again, she lets you join her and other mates, so perhaps she just wants to be herself with one particular set of friends. Maybe she wants to vent a bit in a safe space, with friends she really trusts. I’m sure there are things you’d prefer not to tell your parents, or you workmates, or your mates, even your girlfriend. Think about those. You wouldn’t go for sex advice to your grandma, would you?

It’s also true that sharing every single moment of the day brings most relationships to an end, so you should cherish the fact that your girlfriend is not the super sticky type. It’s actually a healthy sign that she has her own friends and interests; you’ve gotten yourself a woman, congrats! And a little mystery can be a good thing. Not sharing every little, tiny, weenie thingy is the best way to keep your companion awake and interested. Don’t sweat, it’s a good sign!

Cheers,

Dalila

***

Got Problems? Let SuicideGirls’ team of Agony Aunts provide solutions. Email questions to: gotproblems@suicidegirls.com

 

Previous

PAGE: 

1 | 2

Next

Comments
SnakePlissken

SnakePlissken

Corvallis, OR
December 2002

FEB 27, 2012 11:10 AM

Not sharing every single thing is totally ok, but being evasive and avoidant in concert with a habit of routinely scheduled unavailability is really suspicious. An ex of mine attempted to isolate me from her social circle once. Turned out it was because they know more about her than I did, and not in a good way. Learned a lot from them after the end.

mingol

mingol

Singapore
July 2005

FEB 27, 2012 12:49 PM

It's a healthy thing if she wants to keep some part of her life to herself, but this...

She has a group of friends that she does happy hour with and I am not allowed to meet them and I know nothing about them – not even their names.


... is super dodgy. Compartmentalizing your life that obsessively means that you really do have something to hide.

Invisible_Man

Invisible_Man

I'm lost
May 2009

FEB 27, 2012 01:30 PM

She's obviously in a terrorist cell. Contact Homeland Security immediately.

mwalsh

mwalsh

Houston, TX
February 2008

FEB 27, 2012 01:36 PM

Sorry Team Agony, but I am a little more wary..like Red Flag, Red Flag, Red Flag, Red Flag... Having separate areas and interests in life can be very healthy and supportive in a relationship, but...having secrets, and one member of the relationship holding the other member to standards that they do not live up to themselves, spells PROBLEMS. Can't see it any other way.

mwalsh

mwalsh

Houston, TX
February 2008

FEB 27, 2012 01:48 PM

As Rick Perry would say: oops...

CreamyGoodness

CreamyGoodness

United Kingdom
December 2002

FEB 27, 2012 02:02 PM

Yeah, chalk me up as another person who couldn't disagree with this advice more if I tried. There's nothing wrong with having parts of your life be seperate, but to get that angry and defensive at even the most innocent questions about it? Wicked dodgy and a big red flag.

TheFuckOffKid

TheFuckOffKid

NEWSWIRE

Australia

FEB 27, 2012 03:40 PM

My girlfriend and I have separate interests and friends. She's notorious among the SG Australia crew for being a mystery entity rather than a tangible person.

But we don't keep big secrets about who we're seeing or what we're doing. That would be ... odd.

cpkz

cpkz

Portland, OR
September 2006

FEB 27, 2012 05:07 PM

I have been in an extremely controlling relationship before, and have since felt like I had to compartmentalize a part of my life away from my significant other.

Even with that though, I never had a "Secret social life." Okay, so my S.O. wasn't allowed to join, and I never introduced her to the people I was hanging out with...but I could talk about it. My S.O. knew it was important to me that these people were something I wanted to myself. I trusted her not to betray that trust by interjecting herself into that part of my life, and as such I trusted her by letting her know what I was doing and who with.

Saying the questioner isn't actually annoying about it (why does he need to know where they are spending happy hour?), I can't see myself not being willing to at least share first names of the people I'm hanging out with and what I'm doing. I feel either the writer is being a little more possessive than he thinks he is, or she's hiding something... either way, trust issues abound.

Clidna

Clidna

Canada
January 2005

FEB 27, 2012 05:38 PM

Yeah, not into this advice. Also feel like if the genders were reversed, the advice would be completely different.

LaceyK

LaceyK

Tarrytown, NY
October 2005

FEB 27, 2012 06:13 PM

whateverwhateverwhateverwhatever
We need a WTF Face.

Dalila

Dalila

SUICIDEGIRL

Italy

FEB 28, 2012 12:54 AM

Advice is advice, can be taken up or left out. Those are my thoughts, i tried to be as positive as possible, as I am.

More than happy to hear your thoughts, anyways!

Clio

Clio

SUICIDEGIRL

Netherlands

FEB 28, 2012 03:50 AM

This definitely sounds sketchy to me. If she's that weird about it and gets upset/defensive when you ask her about her day I would be suspicious too.

PointBlank

PointBlank

New York, NY
November 2004

FEB 28, 2012 06:05 AM

I guess someone has never heard of prostiTuesday.

Metaverse

Metaverse

USA
March 2005

FEB 28, 2012 07:45 AM

Bad advice is bad.

Mr_Matt_

Mr_Matt_

Pompano Beach, FL
July 2005

FEB 28, 2012 08:03 AM

Metaverse said:
Bad advice is bad.



Only if taken. If left, bad advice is left.

Previous

PAGE: 

1 | 2

Next