• commentary
  • THURSDAY NOVEMBER 17 2011 12:19 AM

Occupy Wall Street: The Cleansing of Zuccotti Park


[Above: OWS protestors hold the line and refuse to move.]

It’s likely no coincidence that Mayor Bloomberg and the NYPD took undeniably brutal action against #OccupyWallStreet protesters at Zuccotti Park just two days before the encampment will celebrate its two month anniversary. The cowardly raid, no doubt designed to intimidate (but ultimately resolve-strengthening), started around 1.30 AM EST on the morning of Tuesday, November 15, long after news crews had knocked off for the evening, under the cover of night as protesters slept in their tents. Photographer, videographer, journalist, and friend of SuicideGirls, Zach D. Roberts was on the scene to report. - Nicole Powers, Ed




[Above: Police move protestors with extreme brute force.]

The Cleansing of Zuccotti Park by Zach D. Roberts

Fuck. My lens is busted - a goddamn cop hit it with a night stick. Then he hit me. Then he shoved me backwards - I nearly fell backward into the crowd, tripping over the edge of the sidewalk. I would have been trampled.

That's when it got a bit scary.

He was yelling, "GET BACK!!! GET BACK!!!"

There was the road and moving traffic behind us, but he didn't seem to care - so the choice was keep walking backward and filming, possibly backing into moving traffic or dart between the taxis - I made the decision to turn and dart, keeping my camera facing back just shooting wide and point in the cops general direction.

Some kids got plastered into and over the cab, which luckily at this point had stopped. Others fell, and while trying to get up were whacked with night sticks, "MOVE, MOVE!"

The fact that they were on the ground, on their back getting hit and held down didn't really matter to the NYPD. Eventually the cops allowed other protestors to drag the kids away and out of the street.

This night wasn't about making arrests, it was about beating heads and making a point. The 17th was only 48 hours away and the police wanted to make sure that everyone knew they were the law (to be read in a Judge Dredd voice)


[Above: Police push back protestors away from Zucotti Square, pushing one woman to the ground.]

Ok, so here's what happened in Lower Manhattan early Tuesday morning.

Fuck. That's what happened.

Free speech, the right to assemble peacefully, and some well meaning kids were pissed upon by a 3-term mayor who is also a billionaire and owner of a media empire.


[Above: Police arrest protestor for jaywalking.]

I'm sorry for the expletives, but if you were there you'd know they were needed. I haven't seen this sort of police madness since the years of the Bush admin when dirty hippies and the press were fair game. Also watching a kid get slammed repeatedly in the face with a police shield has it's effect on your bias. I'll admit it here - I'm with the kids, the protestors, with the occupiers. If we have any hope for this nation it will be from the ones at the business end of a baton - not the one swinging it.

After the initial confrontation with the NYPD, protestors were bottle necked and then split up so their numbers would be too small to take on the masses of over-timed police that were standing, waiting with pepper spray, helmets, shields and batons. I saw all of the aforementioned used as weapons that night in a way that you knew that their supervisors weren't watching.

NOTE: This was the first time the uniformed NYPD (the blue shirts) were not directly supervised by the white shirts (Leuitenants and up in rank).



Word got around that everyone was reconvening at Union Square to figure out what exactly to do. Foley square was also mentioned, but the group that I decided to go with was going with Union. The group started out with about a dozen then attached itself to a larger contingent of about 50, this metastasizing went on for a while until we were in the East Village (about 15 blocks from Zuccotti) and our numbers were 150-200.

Unfortunately these numbers included a contingent of what might be called black bloc. These are the people you see on the news - the only ones that the mainstream cameras usually go with. Garbage cans being thrown in the street make for much sexier footage than a protestor explaining the intricacies of why they are marching. I understand why they do. Personally I'll take the shots and let my editors decide. Luckily I usually work for smart editors - I don't work for The Post.

Somehow we lose the police. I can't tell if it's because they gave up chasing us (your average protestor is in better shape than your average cop, it's a fact - I'm sorry) or if our quick and flowing changes in direction made them lose us. Either way, there's 150 protestors running down the middle of Broadway with only 5 members of the press (counting me) to cover it. This. Is. Awesome.

Full disclosure, I used to be a protestor, a community organizer (gasp!) but then I got sick and tired of losing and not getting anything covered by the news so I decided to switch allegiances and start covering the events.


[Above: Protestors make it up to Houston St. - many blocks from Zucotti Park - on their way to Union Square.]

Ah shit. Lights, and they're coming up quick. Holy shit they're coming up quick. Really quick. People are yelling, "Watch out! Watch out!" I grab one of my friends, another freelance shooter out of the way from a cop car flying by. That was close, waayyy too close. The cop drives the car into the crowd of protestors up ahead nearly hitting about 10 that couldn't jump out of the way quick enough. He's immediately out of the car, baton ready, and grabs the first kid he sees and slams him face down into the hood of the car.

Fucking brilliant! AP shooter John Minchillo and I are the first ones there. The kids are sprinting ahead now, while others stay behind chanting "SHAME! SHAME! SHAME!" One gets hauled away in the cop car.



We’re off again, this time back towards Zuccotti - or at least I think so. The cops are very outnumbered, so they stay behind and let us retake Broadway and then Houston. Some of the black bloc protestors run up the front of taxis waiting at the stop light to the surprise of the tourists inside. The driver actually looks somewhat bored.


[Above: Protestors take the street in the East Village.]

Stand off at Zuccotti.

Five hours later and probably about five miles of cat and mouse games with the police we're back at where this all started - standing near the closest entrance to Wall St. Well not on the street; My best friend since grade school, CS Muncy (another brilliant shooter), is standing with me on top of a police car. We're exhausted. CS was sleeping comfortably when I called him screaming, "They're clearing the fucking park!" He lucked out and made it in the Zuccotti Park to shoot the actual cleanup while I was stuck on the outside. He jumped the police barricades and ignored the cops yells to stop, getting some front page shots before being thrown out. Press were not allowed. No photos for the history books - except for the ones that he got. That's what he does.



It's 6am. There is now a general feeling of victory in the air. People are playing music and dancing. A couple makes out for a solid 15 mins on top of a phone booth. Half for the pleasure, half for the photographers. This is their moment in the sun, their 15mins - what better way of spending it than making out with your girlfriend. I've got my injured camera.

Black bloc starts letting the air out of the tires of the police cars that we are currently occupying.



I'm wondering though as the police start pushing forward to clear this part of the street, to push us again away from Zuccotti, is this the crest of the wave? Will this be remembered 20 years from now by anyone other than a handful of protestors and journo's as they reminisce over beers? Will I write about this like Hunter Thompson wrote about the middle ‘60s?

To steal a better ending than I could write I'll use Hunter's words.

There was madness in any direction, at any hour. If not across the Hudson, then up the Brooklyn Bridge or down Broadway to Zuccotti. . . . You could strike sparks anywhere. There was a fantastic universal sense that whatever we were doing was right, that we were winning. . . .

And that, I think, was the handle — that sense of inevitable victory over the forces of Old and Evil. Not in any mean or military sense; we didn’t need that. Our energy would simply prevail. There was no point in fighting — on our side or theirs. We had all the momentum; we were riding the crest of a high and beautiful wave. . . .





[Above: NYPD in front of the new World Trade Center building near Zucotti Park]
[Below: Zucotti Park being sanitized.]






***

Zach D. Roberts is a photo/video journalist who’s work has been seen in the Observer, The Guardian Online, TheNation.com, The Minnesota Independent, among others. For the past 5 years he’s been working as a researcher/producer for Greg Palast. He produced several DVD’s and news pieces for the BBC’s Newsnight show. Zach edited Palast and RFK Jr’s Steal Back Your Vote comic - which had nearly 100,000 downloads and print copies distributed throughout the world). Currently he works regularly as a video producer for Jamie Kilstein and Allison Kilkenny’s CitizenRadio.

Zach has been detained in New Orleans by Exxon Mobil security, threatened with arrest over three dozen times but has never been arrested. In 2010 he met Sarah Palin while working on his soon to be released first feature length documentary ‘The Rogue Candidate: Sarah Palin’s Real Alaska.’ While in Alaska he broke several stories via TheMudflats.net. For more visit his website, Facebook, and Twitter.

 

Previous

PAGE: 

1 | 2

Next

Comments
Sparkl

Sparkl

USA
January 2011

NOV 17, 2011 09:42 PM

This is an amazing contribution! Thank you for sharing your experience and documenting it for generations to come. This is history and what we have left of democracy in action it seems. I appreciate you sharing and documenting. Power to the 99% as well!

Noro

Noro

Lafayette, CA
June 2011

NOV 17, 2011 09:49 PM

This story is all to similar to my experiences at Occupy Oakland. The night I went, police closed down Bart, the public transportation, saying that protesters were boarding trains without paying. The press is almost worse than the cops; they only focus on one broken window and one drug deal gone wrong that just happened to be right next to the protest (its oakland for christ sakes if the police did their job and focused on crime we wouldnt have this problem!!) A lot of people I know think that because I went to occupy oakland that I condone window smashing because that is all they know about what happened at Oakland because that is all the press will show.
Also, i had a friend who was arrested at occupy cal at berkeley. he was charged with assaulting a police officer. while i dont know the extent of what he did, i do know he is not the person who would do that and the video evidence shows him on the ground with 5 cops beating him with night sticks. his bail was set at 15k but luckily his case caught the eye of a public defender with sympathies towards the occupy movement and he no longer has to pay- the courts found the cops to be in the wrong (shocker).
bottom line is im sick of our government protecting the wants of corporations before protecting the rights of the people. Im sorry to hear about your camera. Thanks for this article! good to hear from our fellow protestors on the east coast.

ExAddict

ExAddict

Canada
October 2011

NOV 18, 2011 08:48 AM

I'm still trying to understand the Unified message other than being a modern version of Depression-era soup kitchens. If that's the case, to provide food and shelter for those without, than I can support the movement but violence for the sake of violence is stomach-turning.

I do understand the point that concentrated wealth is held in the hands of the few, but that has always been the case. As for that concerning Occupy, the tools of societal change are in the hands of anybody and everybody who wants them. I suppose that's what Canadian and original source of the OWS movement Kalle Lasn has really proved with all of this...But without real leadership isn't this all just a media-driven flash in the pan?

I'd be willing to bet that during the onset of the first depression, many of the soup kitchens and similar attempts to provide food and voice to those without met with hostility in the streets.

mydogfarted

mydogfarted

Oakland, NJ
June 2003

NOV 18, 2011 09:29 AM

minimalism

minimalism

Argentina
OLD SKOOL

NOV 18, 2011 10:07 AM

I heard directly from someone who was arrested that night that once they were released and their possessions were returned any and all footage on cameras and cell phones was deleted. How convenient? And that people who showed up with Police issued press passes were denied access to the site as things were happening.

Some days I'm so disappointed with this country and then seeing the numbers swell at yesterday's rallies to bigger than ever makes me think we really do have hope. And with over 30,000 people (NYPD estimate) protesting in the streets of NYC there were very few arrests or accounts of police brutality. So, it's obvious they chose the time and place they plan on doing it to keep the coverage lower.

Heigai

Heigai

Columbus, OH
May 2004

NOV 19, 2011 02:08 AM

ExAddict said:
I'm still trying to understand the Unified message other than being a modern version of Depression-era soup kitchens. If that's the case, to provide food and shelter for those without, than I can support the movement but violence for the sake of violence is stomach-turning.

I do understand the point that concentrated wealth is held in the hands of the few, but that has always been the case. As for that concerning Occupy, the tools of societal change are in the hands of anybody and everybody who wants them. I suppose that's what Canadian and original source of the OWS movement Kalle Lasn has really proved with all of this...But without real leadership isn't this all just a media-driven flash in the pan?

I'd be willing to bet that during the onset of the first depression, many of the soup kitchens and similar attempts to provide food and voice to those without met with hostility in the streets.



Heeeeeeeeeeeeeey, look at you, over here in a different forum section, making the exact same ignorant comments and ignoring the exact same facts as over in CE.

Way to go! kiss

Psyche

Psyche

SUICIDEGIRL

California, USA

NOV 19, 2011 04:39 AM

So far I've been pretty lucky attending Occupy LA and Long Beach; the cops just seem to let be. It seems there hasn't been many reported events of police brutality or excessive force in those areas, although it appears Oakland and New York have been pretty awful from the very beginning. shocked

I'm really glad somebody covered this story for SG news.

ExAddict said:
I'm still trying to understand the Unified message other than being a modern version of Depression-era soup kitchens. If that's the case, to provide food and shelter for those without, than I can support the movement but violence for the sake of violence is stomach-turning.

I do understand the point that concentrated wealth is held in the hands of the few, but that has always been the case. As for that concerning Occupy, the tools of societal change are in the hands of anybody and everybody who wants them. I suppose that's what Canadian and original source of the OWS movement Kalle Lasn has really proved with all of this...But without real leadership isn't this all just a media-driven flash in the pan?

I'd be willing to bet that during the onset of the first depression, many of the soup kitchens and similar attempts to provide food and voice to those without met with hostility in the streets.



This might help you... It's the Occupy "creed" you could say...

1.PASS HR 1489 REINSTATING GLASS-STEAGALL. – A depression era safeguard that separated the commercial lending and investment banking portions of banks. Its repeal in 1999 is considered the major cause of the global financial meltdown of 20...08-2009.

2. REPEAL BUSH TAX CUTS FOR THE WEALTHY

3. FULLY INVESTIGATE AND PROSECUTE THE WALL STREET CRIMINALS who clearly broke the law and helped cause the 2008 financial crisis.

4.OVERTURN CITIZENS UNITED v. US. – A 2010 Supreme Court Decision which ruled that money is speech. Corporations, as legal persons, are now allowed to contribute unlimited amounts of money to campaigns in the exercise of free “speech.”

5. PASS THE BUFFET RULE ON FAIR TAXATION, CLOSE CORPORATE TAX LOOPHOLES, PROHIBIT HIDING FUNDS OFFSHORE.

6. GIVE THE SEC STRICTER REGULATORY POWER, STRENGTHEN THE CONSUMER PROTECTION BUREAU, AND PROVIDE ASSISTANCE FOR OWNERS OF FORECLOSED MORTGAGES WHO WERE VICTIMS OF PREDATORY LENDING.

7.TAKE STEPS TO LIMIT THE INFLUENCE OF LOBBYISTS AND ELIMINATE THE PRACTICE OF LOBBYISTS WRITING LEGISLATION.

8. ELIMINATE RIGHT OF FORMER GOVERNMENT REGULATORS TO WORK FOR CORPORATIONS OR INDUSTRIES THEY ONCE REGULATED.

9. ELIMINATE CORPORATE PERSONHOOD.

10. INSIST THE FEC STAND UP FOR THE PUBLIC INTEREST IN REGULATING PRIVATE USE OF PUBLIC AIRWAVES to help ensure that political candidates ARE GIVEN EQUAL TIME for free at reasonable intervals during campaign season.

11. REFORM CAMPAIGN FINANCE WITH THE PASSAGE OF THE FAIR ELECTIONS NOW ACT (S.750, H.R. 1404).

12. FORGIVE STUDENT DEBT – The same institutions that gave almost $2T in bailouts and then extended $16T of loans at little to no interest for banks can surely afford to forgive the $946B of student debt currently held. Not only does this favor the 99% over the 1%, it has the practical effect of more citizens spending money on actual goods, not paying down interest.


minimalism said:
I heard directly from someone who was arrested that night that once they were released and their possessions were returned any and all footage on cameras and cell phones was deleted. How convenient? And that people who showed up with Police issued press passes were denied access to the site as things were happening.



Wow. I would have taken out the memory chip and stuck it up my butt before going into jail lol. The best piece of contraband... tongue

TheFuckOffKid

TheFuckOffKid

NEWSWIRE

Australia

NOV 19, 2011 04:24 PM

ExAddict said:
I do understand the point that concentrated wealth is held in the hands of the few, but that has always been the case.



No, the point is that it has gotten worse.

PaulNikon

PaulNikon

Palm Bay, FL
February 2003

NOV 19, 2011 07:12 PM

zoom image

METOO

METOO

Chicago, IL
October 2011

NOV 19, 2011 08:07 PM

PaulNikon said:
zoom image



So that's what 4.6 Million will buy huh? eeek

METOO

METOO

Chicago, IL
October 2011

NOV 19, 2011 08:19 PM

GINGRICH: There is a strain of hostile people on the left organized across the country who believe in trashing things, believe in destroying things. Who do they think paid for the park they are sleeping in? Who do they thing paid for the bathroom they want to use? Who do they think paid for the food they’re eating? America wasn’t created by people who woke up every morning saying, ‘You owe me.’ America was created who woke up every morning and said ‘I’m going to go to work and I’m going to do something positive, and I’m going to contribute.’ I think we ought to confront them head on. [...]

There is no spoon

Hey Newt if people had jobs to go to they wouldn't be protesting.

Psyche

Psyche

SUICIDEGIRL

California, USA

NOV 20, 2011 03:20 AM

^^You don't think people on the left work and do positive things and contribute to society? Because plenty of hard-working people would gladly contribute to improve the social programs for those who are in dire need of them. I don't think that the purpose of the Occupy march was so the people marching could fatten their wallets with welfare checks. It's not about taking; it's actually about giving. To society.

TheFuckOffKid

TheFuckOffKid

NEWSWIRE

Australia

NOV 20, 2011 04:02 AM

Psyche said:
^^You don't think people on the left work and do positive things and contribute to society? Because plenty of hard-working people would gladly contribute to improve the social programs for those who are in dire need of them. I don't think that the purpose of the Occupy march was so the people marching could fatten their wallets with welfare checks. It's not about taking; it's actually about giving. To society.



Is this addressed to the poster above, or to Newt Gingrich, whose position he is putting and critiquing?

Waldo_Jeffers

Waldo_Jeffers

United Kingdom
OLD SKOOL

NOV 20, 2011 07:01 AM

TheFuckOffKid said:

ExAddict said:
I do understand the point that concentrated wealth is held in the hands of the few, but that has always been the case.



No, the point is that it has gotten worse.



+1

Nea

Nea

New York, NY
October 2006

NOV 20, 2011 08:21 AM

TheFuckOffKid said:

ExAddict said:
I do understand the point that concentrated wealth is held in the hands of the few, but that has always been the case.



No, the point is that it has gotten worse.



Exactly.

Previous

PAGE: 

1 | 2

Next