BLOG VIEW  |  HEADLINE VIEW
SUBMIT NEWS  |  RSS FEED  |  SEARCH

Students With Concealed Weapons: Worst Idea Ever

FRIDAY APRIL 25 2008 4:00 PM

Submitted by coyotemike. Edited By crispy.

TAGS: Guns, concealed weapons, gun bills

There is the possibility of a frightening new trend on the horizon for college campuses around the country. I'm not talking about a new hazing ritual, worsening cafeteria conditions, or making students scrub the toilets in their dorms. This is much, much worse.

Ever since the terrible shootings just over a year ago at Virginia Tech, some students and parents have been calling on schools to allow students to carry concealed weapons on campuses.

Fox News . . . (not that I recommend watching Fox News)


This has to be one of the worst ideas in history, for a number of reasons:

1. To get a concealed carry permit in any state, the person has to be 21. Which, coincidentally, is the same as the legal drinking age. It has been my experience as a student, an instructor, and as someone who lives within three blocks of every college bar in town, that most students have a tendency to hit the sauce a bit hard when they first become legal. This is not the ideal conditions for allowing someone access to firearms.

2. College students often show dramatic lapses in judgment. Not all students, obviously, but enough that even one student who decides to do something stupid could have deadly results

3. The purpose of the movement is to provide some form of defense against a hypothetical attacker. I’m sorry, but I simply cannot see students being able to react in a manner that is safe to the innocents in a situation and providing actual deterrent to an attacker. If they didn’t manage to shoot themselves in the foot, they would very likely panic and fire blindly in the general direction of an attacker, which could be very deadly to any bystanders who might be in the same general area.

The day after the Virginia Tech attack, I was listening to the local morning conservative talk radio idiots, and the sheer number of calls coming in from parents was frightening. There were several different versions, but they all said about the same thing, dramatically paraphrased here:

“My son (never daughter) woulda shot that sum-bitch dead, and I knows cuz I taught him to shoot tin cans.”

To make matters worse, one of the people that sold the guns to the Virginia Tech shooter is trying to defend his actions in a visit to that campus. (Turns out this online gun seller also supplied some extras to the nut who shot people in Northern Illinois University)

There are plenty of sane things students, faculty, and campuses can do to protect students. They could replace the windows in classroom doors with “bulletproof” glass; they can practice drills like they do with fires and tornadoes; they can set up a campus-wide alert system; they can even set up a lock system so that, if someone pushes a panic button or types in a code, all doors would lock until the all-clear had been given. Yes, they are expensive measures, but they could easily be paid for by the tuitions of the students who weren’t shot.

If a gun kept at home is more likely to end up hurting a family member than an intruder, how much more likely is a gun on a college campus going to be used incorrectly than to stop an attacker in an emergency.

Campuses do not need armed wannabe cowboys with delusions of heroism and grandeur. They need trained security, workable safety plans, working communications, and good screenings of potential students instead of the business-like “we’ll take anyone with money” attitude that so many schools have.

Coyotemike is a part-time college professor, and will resign the day his campus allows students to carry concealed weapons.

 

Previous

PAGE: 

1 ... 

4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8

 ... 37

Next

J24U

J24U

Danvers, MA
February 2006

APR 26, 2008 10:14 AM

Ultraloveninja said:

Wow, so I defend the right to bear arms a bit and I'm a gun nut, wow....CLAP....CLAP....CLAP.....nice going there. I guess I can call you a Liberal so-and-so and we can just start the dance of idiocy everyone wants us to do, or actually we COULD talk about the issues.



Defending the right to bear arms, and talking about the issue at hand is one thing; what you brought to the table was a linked page full of anti-government conspiracy bullshit, directly contrary to eye-witness and video accounts.
Arguments like that only hurt the situation more; taking the blame away from two emotionally disturbed kids who had firearms they had no business getting their hands on. I have enough real world experience to know that two teenagers are more than capable of this atrocity, you can keep your "OMG the ATF operatives are killing the children!!!" links to yourself.

If you want to talk about the issue, or defend the right to bear arms, don't cite sources that take credibility away from whatever you intend to say.

animush

animush

Australia
April 2008

APR 26, 2008 10:14 AM

Hey America, here's an idea, don't give anyone a fucking gun. Makes a lot of sense when you think about it.

The argument might be that if someone wants to kill people, they'll find a gun either way. Thats true in any country, but with every other idiot buying a gun to defend themselves, they are gonna find it pretty fucking easy to get their hands on one.

Its better to prevent violence than react to it.

coyotemike

coyotemike

Tuvalu
May 2006

APR 26, 2008 10:44 AM

animush said:
Hey America, here's an idea, don't give anyone a fucking gun. Makes a lot of sense when you think about it.

The argument might be that if someone wants to kill people, they'll find a gun either way. Thats true in any country, but with every other idiot buying a gun to defend themselves, they are gonna find it pretty fucking easy to get their hands on one.

Its better to prevent violence than react to it.



unfortunatly, that simply isn't a practical idea. There are too many millions of guns in America, and too many people who would be unwilling to turn theirs in to get rid of them all. If we tried, the two groups who really shouldn't have guns (criminals and gun "nuts") would still have them.

DevilsReject

DevilsReject

Cleveland, OH
February 2007

APR 26, 2008 10:50 AM

animush said:
Hey America, here's an idea, don't give anyone a fucking gun. Makes a lot of sense when you think about it.



Hey Australian Guy. You do realize qualified individuals in Australia still have guns, right?

Here's an idea. Don't make rash generalizations about every person, specifically gun owners in the United States. and last time i fucking checked, the United States government has yet to "give me a gun". Did i miss free gun day at the local DMV? So since you believe that "the government gives us a gun" your statement actually makes no sense at fucking all.

since we're all about rash generalizations, shouldn't you be out chasing Kangaroos?

DevilsReject

DevilsReject

Cleveland, OH
February 2007

APR 26, 2008 10:56 AM

PointBlank said:
Wow, the Columbine conspiracy theorists make the other internet conspiracy theorists seem like geniuses. Awesome reading there.

EDIT- ooo, they tie it in to the Denver Airport conspiracy. I love the internet so so much sometimes.



Awesome source. From the same people that brought you "9/11 was an inside job"

If you scroll all the way down, there is a really good article on how to make a well-fitting tinfoil hat.

RudieCantFail

RudieCantFail

Baton Rouge, LA
January 2006

APR 26, 2008 11:06 AM

DevilsReject said:
since we're all about rash generalizations, shouldn't you be out chasing Kangaroos?



It's the national sport, FYI.

GrayRains

GrayRains

El Paso, TX
January 2008

APR 26, 2008 11:21 AM

animush said:
Hey America, here's an idea, don't give anyone a fucking gun. Makes a lot of sense when you think about it.

The argument might be that if someone wants to kill people, they'll find a gun either way. Thats true in any country, but with every other idiot buying a gun to defend themselves, they are gonna find it pretty fucking easy to get their hands on one.

Its better to prevent violence than react to it.



Whatever, and then the "Knife Culture" like in London may well take hold. Banning guns solves nothing, especially when there already is a huge amount just floating around out there.

animush

animush

Australia
April 2008

APR 26, 2008 11:48 AM

DevilsReject said:

animush said:
Hey America, here's an idea, don't give anyone a fucking gun. Makes a lot of sense when you think about it.



Hey Australian Guy. You do realize qualified individuals in Australia still have guns, right?

Here's an idea. Don't make rash generalizations about every person, specifically gun owners in the United States. and last time i fucking checked, the United States government has yet to "give me a gun". Did i miss free gun day at the local DMV? So since you believe that "the government gives us a gun" your statement actually makes no sense at fucking all.

since we're all about rash generalizations, shouldn't you be out chasing Kangaroos?



Sorry.. i missed the part where I said that the government gives out guns. Could you find it for me? I only implied the law will let almost any idiot buy one.

I do realise that qualified individuals in Australia are allowed to possess guns, however you actually need a reason to own a firearm. Self defence doesn't cut it. There are very few people in Australia who actually own guns. Not saying they aren't out there. And i didn't say that before either.

Jumping to conclusions and not reading posts properly only makes you look like an idiot.

Cash

Cash

I'm lost
OLD SKOOL

APR 26, 2008 11:52 AM

Your average college student can't handle alcohol...and they want us to let them carry fucking GUNS?! Sorry, skippy....duck & cover next time a shooting breaks out. It doesn't make you less of a man.

animush

animush

Australia
April 2008

APR 26, 2008 11:55 AM

GrayRains said:

animush said:
Hey America, here's an idea, don't give anyone a fucking gun. Makes a lot of sense when you think about it.

The argument might be that if someone wants to kill people, they'll find a gun either way. Thats true in any country, but with every other idiot buying a gun to defend themselves, they are gonna find it pretty fucking easy to get their hands on one.

Its better to prevent violence than react to it.



Whatever, and then the "Knife Culture" like in London may well take hold. Banning guns solves nothing, especially when there already is a huge amount just floating around out there.



If your attitude is 'take my gun away and i better find a knife' then i think the guns are really the least of your problems.

DevilsReject

DevilsReject

Cleveland, OH
February 2007

APR 26, 2008 12:04 PM

animush said:
Hey America, here's an idea, don't give anyone a fucking gun



Here i pointed it out for you. Does that help?

Jumping to conclusions and not reading posts properly only makes you look like an idiot.



No. Assuming what works in your country, will work in every fucking country makes you look like an idiot. I am not naive enough to believe that just because it works in the United States that it will work Australia, and i am damn sure what works in Australia won't necessarily work in the United States. Mostly because our national population, is what, almost 15 times greater than yours? Or maybe it's because our country is based on a different constitution?

What works for you doesn't work for everyone.

How's that national porn filter working out for you guys? Seems like you're dumping an awful lot of money into something to please a few people.

coyotemike

coyotemike

Tuvalu
May 2006

APR 26, 2008 12:04 PM

Cash said:
Your average college student can't handle alcohol...and they want us to let them carry fucking GUNS?! Sorry, skippy....duck & cover next time a shooting breaks out. It doesn't make you less of a man.



Just can't help myself . . .

DevilsReject

DevilsReject

Cleveland, OH
February 2007

APR 26, 2008 12:09 PM

animush said:

GrayRains said:

animush said:
Hey America, here's an idea, don't give anyone a fucking gun. Makes a lot of sense when you think about it.

The argument might be that if someone wants to kill people, they'll find a gun either way. Thats true in any country, but with every other idiot buying a gun to defend themselves, they are gonna find it pretty fucking easy to get their hands on one.

Its better to prevent violence than react to it.



Whatever, and then the "Knife Culture" like in London may well take hold. Banning guns solves nothing, especially when there already is a huge amount just floating around out there.



If your attitude is 'take my gun away and i better find a knife' then i think the guns are really the least of your problems.




HEY HEY HEY! He's catching on!. Everyone slow down the conversation so he can catch up!

I think we discussed that like three pages ago. Where ya know, we said "Let's fix the problem of people wanting to shoot other people, rather than strip everyone of a right"

But ya know, go ahead, read only what you want and ignore the rest of the conversation.

animush

animush

Australia
April 2008

APR 26, 2008 12:14 PM

DevilsReject said:

animush said:
Hey America, here's an idea, don't give anyone a fucking gun



Here i pointed it out for you. Does that help?

Jumping to conclusions and not reading posts properly only makes you look like an idiot.



No. Assuming what works in your country, will work in every fucking country makes you look like an idiot. I am not naive enough to believe that just because it works in the United States that it will work Australia, and i am damn sure what works in Australia won't necessarily work in the United States. Mostly because our national population, is what, almost 15 times greater than yours? Or maybe it's because our country is based on a different constitution?

What works for you doesn't work for everyone.

How's that national porn filter working out for you guys? Seems like you're dumping an awful lot of money into something to please a few people.



Again, doesn't say that the government is giving out free guns, it only states America as a country encourages gun ownership by making it so easy to posess a gun. If you chose to interpret it differently, so be it.

I don't see what other Australian legislation has to do with this, its an unrelated policy, and I don't agree with that policy either.

Your population might be alot bigger than ours, but our laws and political system aren't so different. I still believe that making guns available doesn't help anybody, no matter which country you live in or what its population is.

I'm not gonna argue with you, i've stated my opinion and im gonna leave it at that.

DevilsReject

DevilsReject

Cleveland, OH
February 2007

APR 26, 2008 12:50 PM

animush said:
Again, doesn't say that the government is giving out free guns, it only states America as a country encourages gun ownership by making it so easy to posess a gun. If you chose to interpret it differently, so be it.



"Hey America, don't give anyone a gun" is not to be construed as the America just handing out guns? "America" "give" "gun" ?????

Do you even know any of our policies? Do you know what it takes to get a gun in the United States?

I don't see what other Australian legislation has to do with this, its an unrelated policy, and I don't agree with that policy either.



The idea that that policy even got instated leads me to believe that your government and policies are much, much different than ours. Do you realize how ballistic our population would go if something like that were even talked about being instated?

Your population might be alot bigger than ours, but our laws and political system aren't so different. I still believe that making guns available doesn't help anybody, no matter which country you live in or what its population is.



You make it sound like we get guns with every third fill-up at the gas station. And that everyone in the United States has a gun. Just because as a nation we can purchase a firearm, doesn't mean everybody does. I firmly believe as a gun-owner, the process to purchase a gun is very weak. I thoroughly believe that more stringent and effective processes need put in place. I don't however believe that the rights of everyone should be stripped due to the actions of a few.

You also make it sound as if everyone that buys a gun has nothing but bad intentions with the gun. Most of my collection are relics, from wars, that i would be entirely scared to fire. The guns i do fire, i fire well within the legal responsibilities that i am acquired to. My guns never get fired outside of a range.

Just because people choose to do bad things with guns, don't assume that everyone is going to do bad things with guns, i have no intentions of going out and hurting anyone for no apparent reason, or because they called me a name. The problem isn't the gun, it's the person. The gun in itself would hurt no one, it needs a user. fix the problem of guns falling into the hands of the wrong users.

The problem is, we have two polar opposite sides that can never meet in the middle. One side wants to ban everything, and the other side wants every baby in America armed. We get idiotic weapons bans, that aren't really banning anything, we waste time and money putting them into place, and they aren't effective.

So we run into a Australian porn filter type policy. The Christians want porn banned on the internet, the government bans porn, now they have another part of the population unhappy. There was no compromise, outright bans do not fix anything, you're going to end up with a part of the population that is greatly displeased. (and i am pretty sure they don't work, since you're posting on an alt-porn site) I am sure there are people in your Country that are extremely upset that guns were banned and i am sure that there are presumably innocent people that do still have guns.

Our laws and political system by nature are the same. It about stops there. With our population being so large, we deal with more poverty, more crime and more of the bad crap you don't want to hear about. We deal with it at such a higher capacity, and a higher rate, that it's impossible to compare our countries, simply because the numbers are so vastly different.

We have cities in the United States with a population that is half the population of your entire country. When you group large amounts of people into small areas, everything changes.



Previous

PAGE: 

1 ... 

4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8

 ... 37

Next

PreviousNext

Barack "Blunder" Obama

Comments 153 Comments - Last Comment 4 days ago

OMG APOCALYPSE 2012!!

Comments 113 Comments - Last Comment 2 days ago

Asshole Fuckface Roundup #55

Comments 104 Comments - Last Comment 2 days ago

Right Wing WALL-E Meltdown

Comments 86 Comments - Last Comment 2 days ago

Jimmy Fucking Carter

Comments 82 Comments - Last Comment 37 minutes ago

US Secretly Funding Iranian Insurgency?

Last Comment 12 MIN

FYI - We already have Covert-Ops going on in Iran....and yes, this means "boots on the ground". More ...

Jimmy Fucking Carter

Last Comment 37 MIN by roubles

Jimmy Fucking Carter

Last Comment 37 MIN

The county I live in doesn't have 10% ethanol but some of the larger cities I have visited do and I've... More ...

Filthy Rich Socialism

Last Comment 2 HR by Sick

Filthy Rich Socialism

Last Comment 2 HR

Another reason not to nationalize Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae is that it would increase our total public... More ...

Comic Con 2008

Last Comment 5 HR by Dwam

Comic Con 2008

Last Comment 5 HR

Congrats !!!!!! More ...

Jennifer Lopez: Everything That’s Wrong With Everything

Last Comment 10 HR

I personally think that you should be able to spend your money on whatever you want. She made the money,... More ...

Scott Ian's Food Coma: Getcha’ Pull!

Last Comment 11 HR

I'm not a beer drinker, but now I am intrigued. More ...

SuicideGirls Interview: Marty Krofft
SuicideGirls Interview: Nikki Sixx
SuicideGirls Interview: Roger Corman