BLOG VIEW  |  HEADLINE VIEW
SUBMIT NEWS  |  RSS FEED  |  SEARCH

Students With Concealed Weapons: Worst Idea Ever

FRIDAY APRIL 25 2008 4:00 PM

Submitted by coyotemike. Edited By crispy.

TAGS: Guns, concealed weapons, gun bills

There is the possibility of a frightening new trend on the horizon for college campuses around the country. I'm not talking about a new hazing ritual, worsening cafeteria conditions, or making students scrub the toilets in their dorms. This is much, much worse.

Ever since the terrible shootings just over a year ago at Virginia Tech, some students and parents have been calling on schools to allow students to carry concealed weapons on campuses.

Fox News . . . (not that I recommend watching Fox News)


This has to be one of the worst ideas in history, for a number of reasons:

1. To get a concealed carry permit in any state, the person has to be 21. Which, coincidentally, is the same as the legal drinking age. It has been my experience as a student, an instructor, and as someone who lives within three blocks of every college bar in town, that most students have a tendency to hit the sauce a bit hard when they first become legal. This is not the ideal conditions for allowing someone access to firearms.

2. College students often show dramatic lapses in judgment. Not all students, obviously, but enough that even one student who decides to do something stupid could have deadly results

3. The purpose of the movement is to provide some form of defense against a hypothetical attacker. I’m sorry, but I simply cannot see students being able to react in a manner that is safe to the innocents in a situation and providing actual deterrent to an attacker. If they didn’t manage to shoot themselves in the foot, they would very likely panic and fire blindly in the general direction of an attacker, which could be very deadly to any bystanders who might be in the same general area.

The day after the Virginia Tech attack, I was listening to the local morning conservative talk radio idiots, and the sheer number of calls coming in from parents was frightening. There were several different versions, but they all said about the same thing, dramatically paraphrased here:

“My son (never daughter) woulda shot that sum-bitch dead, and I knows cuz I taught him to shoot tin cans.”

To make matters worse, one of the people that sold the guns to the Virginia Tech shooter is trying to defend his actions in a visit to that campus. (Turns out this online gun seller also supplied some extras to the nut who shot people in Northern Illinois University)

There are plenty of sane things students, faculty, and campuses can do to protect students. They could replace the windows in classroom doors with “bulletproof” glass; they can practice drills like they do with fires and tornadoes; they can set up a campus-wide alert system; they can even set up a lock system so that, if someone pushes a panic button or types in a code, all doors would lock until the all-clear had been given. Yes, they are expensive measures, but they could easily be paid for by the tuitions of the students who weren’t shot.

If a gun kept at home is more likely to end up hurting a family member than an intruder, how much more likely is a gun on a college campus going to be used incorrectly than to stop an attacker in an emergency.

Campuses do not need armed wannabe cowboys with delusions of heroism and grandeur. They need trained security, workable safety plans, working communications, and good screenings of potential students instead of the business-like “we’ll take anyone with money” attitude that so many schools have.

Coyotemike is a part-time college professor, and will resign the day his campus allows students to carry concealed weapons.

 

Previous

PAGE: 

1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6

 ... 37

Next

DevilsReject

DevilsReject

Cleveland, OH
February 2007

APR 25, 2008 05:14 PM

coyotemike said:
"My son (never daughter) woulda shot that sum-bitch dead, and I knows cuz I taught him to shoot tin cans."



This scares the shit out of me just about any time i hear it. People present examples like hunting and skeet shooting and compare it to tactical shooting and they just aren't the same.

The skeet, tin cans and deer aren't carrying semi-automatic weapons and are not trying to kill you. When doing those things, you have time to prepare your stance, aim, exhale and fire.

When your tactically shooting, you rarely ever are presented with the opportunity to do anything but maybe get one shot "relatively close" to your intended target while you're taking fire. There is no stance, you're panting like a female dog in heat, you're palms are sweating and your brain is running just short of Mach 9.

Before i actually trained, i was naive enough to believe that my hobbyist shooting was enough experience to carry me through a live fire event. It's not, and it never will be. Live fire and situations of that sort change everything about being able to shoot successfully.

There are plenty of sane things students, faculty, and campuses can do to protect students. They could replace the windows in classroom doors with "bulletproof" glass; they can practice drills like they do with fires and tornadoes; they can set up a campus-wide alert system; they can even set up a lock system so that, if someone pushes a panic button or types in a code, all doors would lock until the all-clear had been given. Yes, they are expensive measures, but they could easily be paid for by the tuitions of the students who weren't shot.



While i like this idea over the idea of permitting college students to carry guns. I'd still like to see the problem fixed at it's source, rather than create more expenses to band-aid a problem.

Society continuously looks past people that are crying out for help. I'd like to see people get they help they need prior to toting a gun to a crowded area and opening fire. But that seems to be a naive and rather Utopian dream.

Being that i am back in college, at 33. It's kind of a 50/50 shot in the dark whether a college kid carrying a gun is a good idea. I am in a class that ranges from former military to people that have been seriously beaten with the stupid stick. I know when i was at that age, gun safety wasn't the first thing on my mind.

They would need to dramatically fix the permit to conceal process and overhaul it prior to ever even giving thought to letting this happen. I know too many people that have the permits that in my mind, clearly shouldn't.

wow this got long, good story, well written, you're getting good at this. I should start writing articles again.

_kungfoo_

_kungfoo_

Omaha, NE
April 2005

APR 25, 2008 05:19 PM

Guns on campus? Unnecessary. The gun-boner crowd is right about one thing; people with carry permits are usually pretty well trained proficient and are not likely to be criminals. But can somebody explain why we need a arms race on campus?

*Edited for clarification.

coyotemike

coyotemike

Tuvalu
May 2006

APR 25, 2008 05:20 PM

abbazappa said:

But they would already have the hand gun in the dorm (although I believe being 21 in a dorm is getting a bit old on average). This isn't a debate about the legal age to own a gun or to have a concealed weapon. This only has to do with if people that already own a gun and have the concealed weapon permit can have that gun in a class room where they won't be intoxicated and hopefully should have a focus head any ways and hopefully never have to use it. Also I would think it would be a safe bet that it's only a handful of students that would want to own and carry a pistol.



Except that nearly all campuses do not allow any sort of firearm on the grounds. And 21 isn't so old for the dorms, particularly if someone is in the Greek system or is from out of state.


I still think it would be a better idea if it was the teachers that took the training courses and had the concealed weapons on the campuses over the students. Or that if the students carried a pistol they would have to first register with the administration and campus police office and only carry "non-lethal" rounds for their pistols.



I live in the middle of a state with one of the highest gun ownership percentages in the country. There are three departments in my building. I am one of two faculty members between the English, Philosophy, and Modern Languages Depts who owns any sort of firearms, and the other is retireing this year to go back to being a pastor. College professors are not generally the type who would want to have anything to do with guns on any level.

coyotemike

coyotemike

Tuvalu
May 2006

APR 25, 2008 05:26 PM

KUNGFOO said:
Guns on campus? Unnecessary. The gun-boner crowd is right about one thing; people with carry permits are usually pretty well trained and are not likely to be criminals. But can somebody explain why we need a arms race on campus?



For a Nebraska concealed carry permit, a person needs to take a short class (something like 6 weeks of one-night-per-week/one-hour-per-class) on gun safety and target shooting. This is not enough training for combat/reaction shooting.

I've been shooting since I was about 4 years old, was trained by my father who was a gun/hunting safety instructor, and I wouldn't feel comfortable carrying a weapon to combat a possible attacker. I'd more than likely freeze up, miss and hit a bystander, or my hands would be shaking so much I would drop the damn gun.

abbazappa

abbazappa

Los Osos, CA
June 2006

APR 25, 2008 05:28 PM


I live in the middle of a state with one of the highest gun ownership percentages in the country. There are three departments in my building. I am one of two faculty members between the English, Philosophy, and Modern Languages Depts who owns any sort of firearms, and the other is retireing this year to go back to being a pastor. College professors are not generally the type who would want to have anything to do with guns on any level.


And hopefully people that carry concealed weapons would never have to use them. The schools do have a right to not allow weapons on campuses since it is private property but the students do have a right to be angry and try to take action when they think it would help their safety. I am sure a compromise will eventually happen of either having workers in class rooms carry a weapon or doing their own screening to allow maybe ex-military, and level headed students that are responsible enough also be allowed instead of just any one.

Shiny_metal_ass

Shiny_metal_ass

I'm lost
October 2006

APR 25, 2008 05:29 PM

Lemme see if I can understand guntard math. Guns + more guns = less gun violence.

I feel safer already!

surreal

robot

_kungfoo_

_kungfoo_

Omaha, NE
April 2005

APR 25, 2008 05:31 PM

coyotemike said:

KUNGFOO said:
Guns on campus? Unnecessary. The gun-boner crowd is right about one thing; people with carry permits are usually pretty well trained and are not likely to be criminals. But can somebody explain why we need a arms race on campus?



For a Nebraska concealed carry permit, a person needs to take a short class (something like 6 weeks of one-night-per-week/one-hour-per-class) on gun safety and target shooting. This is not enough training for combat/reaction shooting.

I've been shooting since I was about 4 years old, was trained by my father who was a gun/hunting safety instructor, and I wouldn't feel comfortable carrying a weapon to combat a possible attacker. I'd more than likely freeze up, miss and hit a bystander, or my hands would be shaking so much I would drop the damn gun.



Good point. It wasn't my intention to say that permitted owners are well trained to take down crazed gun-men (In fact, I highly disagree with that idea). I was just agreeing with the gun-nut viewpoint that permitted carriers aren't usually criminals, since that seems to be some sort of contention from the pro-gun side.

coyotemike

coyotemike

Tuvalu
May 2006

APR 25, 2008 05:32 PM

abbazappa said:


I live in the middle of a state with one of the highest gun ownership percentages in the country. There are three departments in my building. I am one of two faculty members between the English, Philosophy, and Modern Languages Depts who owns any sort of firearms, and the other is retireing this year to go back to being a pastor. College professors are not generally the type who would want to have anything to do with guns on any level.


And hopefully people that carry concealed weapons would never have to use them. The schools do have a right to not allow weapons on campuses since it is private property but the students do have a right to be angry and try to take action when they think it would help their safety. I am sure a compromise will eventually happen of either having workers in class rooms carry a weapon or doing their own screening to allow maybe ex-military, and level headed students that are responsible enough also be allowed instead of just any one.



Do you mean the maintainance staff? No, thank you. Most of the ones I've met are very nice people, but they aren't up to combat. I wouldn't mind having the campus police being armed, but only if they are an actual police force with full training, and not rent-a-cops who are mostly concerned with parking tickets.

coyotemike

coyotemike

Tuvalu
May 2006

APR 25, 2008 05:33 PM

KUNGFOO said:

coyotemike said:

KUNGFOO said:
Guns on campus? Unnecessary. The gun-boner crowd is right about one thing; people with carry permits are usually pretty well trained and are not likely to be criminals. But can somebody explain why we need a arms race on campus?



For a Nebraska concealed carry permit, a person needs to take a short class (something like 6 weeks of one-night-per-week/one-hour-per-class) on gun safety and target shooting. This is not enough training for combat/reaction shooting.

I've been shooting since I was about 4 years old, was trained by my father who was a gun/hunting safety instructor, and I wouldn't feel comfortable carrying a weapon to combat a possible attacker. I'd more than likely freeze up, miss and hit a bystander, or my hands would be shaking so much I would drop the damn gun.



Good point. It wasn't my intention to say that permitted owners are well trained to take down crazed gun-men. I was just agreeing with the gun-nut viewpoint that permitted carriers aren't usually criminals.



I'll conceed that. At least the background checks that exist are able to weed out people with felony convictions.

DevilsReject

DevilsReject

Cleveland, OH
February 2007

APR 25, 2008 05:40 PM

coyotemike said:

KUNGFOO said:
Guns on campus? Unnecessary. The gun-boner crowd is right about one thing; people with carry permits are usually pretty well trained and are not likely to be criminals. But can somebody explain why we need a arms race on campus?



For a Nebraska concealed carry permit, a person needs to take a short class (something like 6 weeks of one-night-per-week/one-hour-per-class) on gun safety and target shooting. This is not enough training for combat/reaction shooting.



Ohio you're done in one weekend, it's not even a state-performed training course. The course is prepared to NRA standards and left in the hands of private organizations.

When i took my C&C permit, there was people that couldn't even follow simple safety instructions, like always keeping a loaded weapon pointed down range. The fun part was our instructor was a former military D.I., and even though you paid to be there, he ran it very militaristic. Watching stupid people get yelled at is fun. Watching stupid people get permits is not fun.

Fixer

Fixer

Los Angeles, CA
October 2002

APR 25, 2008 05:42 PM

coyotemike said:
I've been shooting since I was about 4 years old, was trained by my father who was a gun/hunting safety instructor, and I wouldn't feel comfortable carrying a weapon to combat a possible attacker. I'd more than likely freeze up, miss and hit a bystander, or my hands would be shaking so much I would drop the damn gun.



so, if it's not right for you, it's not right for anybody?

abbazappa

abbazappa

Los Osos, CA
June 2006

APR 25, 2008 05:42 PM

Shiny_Metal_Ass said:
Lemme see if I can understand guntard math. Guns + more guns = less gun violence.

I feel safer already!

surreal

robot


No, it's more that criminals would rather try to rob some one that isn't home or doesn't have a gun, or thinks long and hard before taking a gun to a public area that they know people have guns.

Take for example that:


When sexual assaults started rising in Orlando, Fla., in 1986, police officers noticed women were arming themselves, so they launched a firearms safety course for them. Over the next 12 months, sexual assaults plummeted by 88 percent, burglaries fell by 25 percent and not one of the 2,500 women who took the course fired a gun in a confrontation.


source
So then by your logic;

Criminals with guns + people with out guns = less crimes

coyotemike

coyotemike

Tuvalu
May 2006

APR 25, 2008 05:43 PM

DevilsReject said:

coyotemike said:

KUNGFOO said:
Guns on campus? Unnecessary. The gun-boner crowd is right about one thing; people with carry permits are usually pretty well trained and are not likely to be criminals. But can somebody explain why we need a arms race on campus?



For a Nebraska concealed carry permit, a person needs to take a short class (something like 6 weeks of one-night-per-week/one-hour-per-class) on gun safety and target shooting. This is not enough training for combat/reaction shooting.



Ohio you're done in one weekend, it's not even a state-performed training course. The course is prepared to NRA standards and left in the hands of private organizations.

When i took my C&C permit, there was people that couldn't even follow simple safety instructions, like always keeping a loaded weapon pointed down range. The fun part was our instructor was a former military D.I., and even though you paid to be there, he ran it very militaristic. Watching stupid people get yelled at is fun. Watching stupid people get permits is not fun.



Yeah, they aren't state run here either. My uncle just went through one, and it was just a guy who passed a state test who opened up a "school."

It would be funny to watch some of those idiots, but only if you know that they will bomb out of the course and be denied a retake option.

coyotemike

coyotemike

Tuvalu
May 2006

APR 25, 2008 05:44 PM

Fixer said:

coyotemike said:
I've been shooting since I was about 4 years old, was trained by my father who was a gun/hunting safety instructor, and I wouldn't feel comfortable carrying a weapon to combat a possible attacker. I'd more than likely freeze up, miss and hit a bystander, or my hands would be shaking so much I would drop the damn gun.



so, if it's not right for you, it's not right for anybody?



No, and thank you for completely missing the point. I'm using a lifetime of experiance to try to prove that without extensive combat-shooting training, people would very likely make lethal errors.

Fixer

Fixer

Los Angeles, CA
October 2002

APR 25, 2008 05:55 PM

coyotemike said:

No, and thank you for completely missing the point. I'm using a lifetime of experiance to try to prove that without extensive combat-shooting training, people would very likely make lethal errors.



you use "likely" a lot. 21 yr old students are likely to be out of control drunks. Armed citizens are very likely to make lethal errors. Must be nice to be so conveniently sure of oneself and your ability to predict everyone else's behaviour.

The adrenaline rush that one gets when confronted with a dangerous situation has very different effects in everyone. There's no "likely" how someone is going to react. You say "likely" to help prove your own point, as if you were a likelihood expert. Just because you doubt your own ability to stay calm under a stressful situation does not make it more likely that everyone else will react the same way.

Previous

PAGE: 

1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6

 ... 37

Next

PreviousNext

Barack "Blunder" Obama

Comments 153 Comments - Last Comment 3 days ago

OMG APOCALYPSE 2012!!

Comments 113 Comments - Last Comment 1 day ago

Asshole Fuckface Roundup #55

Comments 104 Comments - Last Comment 16 hours ago

Right Wing WALL-E Meltdown

Comments 86 Comments - Last Comment 1 day ago

SuicideGirls Big in Japan

Comments 80 Comments - Last Comment 3 days ago

Comic Con 2008

Last Comment 1 HR by courtneyriot

Comic Con 2008

Last Comment 1 HR

(images only) More ...

Jimmy Fucking Carter

Last Comment 1 HR by RedBstrd

Jimmy Fucking Carter

Last Comment 1 HR

/shrug Well, you decided to participate in a thread that is about the role of Carter and Reagan in advocating/hindering... More ...

Jennifer Lopez: Everything That’s Wrong With Everything

Last Comment 3 HR

Shame on the site for publishing this barely readable column. FAIL. More ...

Life Is Ugly So Why Not Kill Yourself*

Last Comment 5 HR

I've always said, for the most part, if you want to kill yourself, go right ahead. If your life sucks... More ...

Scott Ian's Food Coma: Getcha’ Pull!

Last Comment 10 HR

nice! the part of the story i left out is that i wound up having 8 pints just to prove his perceptions... More ...

Plissken's Shit Food Review: JITB BBQ Bacon Sirloin Burger

Last Comment 13 HR

apparently maple syrup can also ruin bacon. i had french toast at brunch recently and a little bit of... More ...

SuicideGirls Interview: Marty Krofft
SuicideGirls Interview: Marilyn Manson
SuicideGirls Interview: Kinky Friedman