- feature
- SUNDAY FEBRUARY 3 2008 6:00 AM
Bad Idea: Hitler Parade Float
Submitted by TheCoolerKing
Edited by erin_broadley
Everyone loves a parade! Well, everyone except me when I'm trying to drive across a road currently occupied by a parade... or me, when I'm watching a parade... or anytime, really. As far as antiquated, small town American entertainment goes, a parade aint no fireworks.
But, as the saying goes, everyone loves a parade. Apparently, even hate-monger nazi-lovers!
A judge issued an order Thursday prohibiting a Rio samba group from parading during carnival with a float depicting naked bodies of Holocaust victims.
Judge Juliana Kalichszteim issued the injunction in response to a lawsuit by the Jewish Federation of Rio de Janeiro, which asked for the float be removed from this city's famed carnival parade next week, said Lara Voges, a spokeswoman for the judge.
The judge said the float could be used in the parade, but that organizers of the Viradouro samba group must remove mannequins meant to represent dead bodies from the Holocaust.
That seems more than reasonable, on the part of the judge. That's pretty much the definition of "fair." Making a statement along the lines of "Look, I'm not saying you can't be in the parade, I'm not even saying you can't use the float in the parade, just lose the part with the dead bodies representing Holocaust victims. Okay?"
An example of "unreasonable"?
Viradouro spokeswoman Eliane Lorca said the group had not yet seen the judge's order and that the president of the group would only comment after they had seen the "supposed decision."
Ahh, an uptight Nazi. The reporter wasn't lying to you lady, no need to be snippy.
The Jewish Federation praised the judge's decision.
"It's inadmissible that they could have a parade float depicting dead Jews and a live Hitler on top of them," said federation spokesman Jose Roitberg.
I like the subtle emphasis, on "live Hitler." As if to imply,"Now, if you wanna give us a dead Hitler with some live Jews kicking him in the head or something... then we might have something."
Reports in the media have said that Viradouro had planned to feature at least one dancer dressed as Adolf Hitler in the parade, using the theme: "It Gives you Goose Bumps."
Viradouro would neither confirm nor deny those plans.
"At least one." Wouldn't that just get confusing? I guess you could have him at different ages. Kid Hitler, Angry-Teen Hitler, Baby Hitler... But, really, wasn't The Producers enough? Too much, actually.
According to Kalichszteim's decision, the group would face fines of $113,000 if it ignores her order by parading without removing the mannequins and $28,000 for each dancer dressed as Hitler.
Sure, that's one way to go. Another would be to actually stop them from using the float, since, after all, a judge has already made a decision. Isn't that what a judge's ruling usually means?
Another report presents a slightly more cooperative Viradouro.
Viradouro insisted its Holocaust float is not meant to offend anyone.
"The float is extremely respectful, it's a warning, it's something shocking that we don't want to happen ever again," said Paulo Barros, Viradouro's artistic director.
I think Paulo's error here is greatly overestimating the size lesson that can be learned from watching a parade float. Which is to say, he thinks it's possible to learn a lesson from watching a parade float.
I guess we can maybe rule out these people being actual card-carrying Nazis. But then why the float?
Are they being sincere? Are they really naive enough to believe they could educate people about the dangers of racism using a pink sequin-covered swastika?
Were they trying to be funny? Funny would be having Hitler sodomized by one of those parade classic "costumed stilt men." Or having him slapped around by forest animals. Or smashing the "Death Mobile" from Animal House through the float, catapulting a dead Hitler through the air and into the open bedroom window of an aspiring Nazi... Funny, doesn't seem to be the goal of what they did.
Was it all for shock value? Seems like a long way to go, just for that reason. Especially considering they must've known it'd get shut down before debuting.
TheCoolerKing is curious about how this all actually plays out. And by the time you read, we should know how it went.




Comments
tareva
Yuba City, CA
July 2004
FEB 03, 2008 06:26 AM
Gayballs
Seattle, WA
July 2005
FEB 03, 2008 06:30 AM
defaultx
I'm lost
February 2006
FEB 03, 2008 07:54 AM
Drake
SUICIDEGIRL
I'm lost
FEB 03, 2008 09:22 AM
sitar
Philadelphia, PA
June 2004
FEB 03, 2008 10:09 AM
goodpoltergeist
Douglasville, GA
January 2007
FEB 03, 2008 10:10 AM
lefthandright
New Zealand
September 2006
FEB 03, 2008 03:45 PM
Quirky
Birmingham, AL
October 2005
FEB 03, 2008 03:57 PM
Tiger_Fodder
Braintree, MA
June 2007
FEB 04, 2008 05:07 AM
Mockingbird
Chicago, IL
January 2006
FEB 04, 2008 08:27 AM
Ferretbite
Mexico
September 2006
FEB 07, 2008 02:47 PM