BLOG VIEW  |  HEADLINE VIEW
SUBMIT NEWS  |  RSS FEED  |  SEARCH

Video Games: Not Bad For You

FRIDAY NOVEMBER 23 2007 9:00 AM

Submitted by johnnyfu. Edited By erin_broadley.

TAGS: video games, violence



This is a sad day for self-righteous politicians, religious tight-asses and conservative cultural monitors. A new study calls bullshit on the connection between video game violence and real violence. Christopher Ferguson, a professor in the Department of Behavioral, Applied Sciences and Criminal Justice at Texas A&M International University, looked at 22 years of clinical studies on the effects of video games and found them seriously flawed.

"It is not hard to 'link' video game playing with violent acts if one wishes to do so, as one video game playing prevalence study indicated that 98.7 percent of adolescents play video games to some degree," [Ferguson] writes, "However, is it possible that a behavior with such a high base rate (i.e., video game playing) is useful in explaining a behavior with a very low base rate (i.e., school shootings)? Put another way, can an almost universal behavior truly predict a rare behavior?"



The reasoning is so obvious it’s almost dumb. Gaming is a 30-year-old, multi-billion dollar industry, and has survived for so long and accumulated so much money because video games are so popular that they're ubiquitous. Yeah, a couple of school shooters played video games. They probably watched television and ate at McDonald’s too.

The supposed proof that video games cause violence is sourced in a year 2000 study by Iowa State University researchers Karen Dill and Craig Anderson. It was the first behavioral study of the correlation between video games — Anderson referenced it as a cornerstone in the 2007 study that seems to now be the Bible for anti-video game crusaders.

The study was strikingly weird. Two hundred or so college-age students, who either identified themselves as veteran violent game players or not, were split into two groups,. One played the snooze fest, puzzle game Myst while the other group played the ancient, first person shooter Castle Wolfenstein. Afterwards, members of the two groups competed in a timed contest where the winner could hit the opponent with “noise blasts.”

The Wolfenstein crowd rocked the noise blasts longer and louder, and the researchers concluded that they were therefore more prone to violence, ignoring how, violence aside, the games require vastly different modes of thinking. Myst requires players to think carefully and analytically. A fast, first person shooter game like Wolfenstein requires much quicker, more reactive thinking.

Anyway, Ferguson says, the whole noise blast thing didn’t prove anything about video games leading to violence.

Ferguson says that the Anderson and Dill study when inspected closely actually supports the exact opposite of the publicized findings that video games don’t correlate to aggressive behaviors in players.

Four measures of aggression were used the Anderson and Dill study, provided by a “noise blast” program that wasn’t standardized. According to Ferguson, the fact that the study authors only found correspondence to one of the measures and the confidence measures around the effect size for the findings actually crosses zero and can’t be considered proof of a positive finding.

A similar study by Ferguson et al using a standardized version of the “noise blast” program found no relationship between violent games and aggression.



In an "Alfred Hitchcock Presents"-worthy twist for the family values crowd, families themselves were found more likely to cause violence than video games.

What was found from these study reviews was that once predication of family violence was eliminated by players of violent video games, there is no correlation between the two.

In other words, gamers who play violent video games are more likely to be aggressive due to family violence than by playing video games.



Despite the study, video games are likely to continue getting blamed for youth violence. This week Douglas Gentile, an Iowa state researcher who’s worked extensively with Craig Anderson, released a study that asserts a correlation between video games and violence.

But more importantly, video games are a deliciously easy target. There’s no NRA for Halo players — actually, a truly valuable study of video gamers would investigate whether or not they vote. But it’s unlikely that a gamer bloc could put numbers that match old people, the demographic most and large scared of technology and young people.

Currently, Washington politicians are riled up about the ESRB rating system. The video game rating system, Democratic and Republican legislators say, is too vague to protect our nation’s innocent little children. Not to be too much of a wise ass, but there’s still a massively unpopular, costly war going on, right?

The uproar revolves around Manhunt 2, a game that features gruesome decapitations, rape, dismemberment, and encourages violent homophobia and fratricide.

Oh, no, wait, sorry. It doesn’t. The first three things in that list are from a Shakespeare play. The last two were from the Bible.


 

Previous

PAGE: 

1 | 2 | 3

Next

StopSnitchin

StopSnitchin

Hudson, NH
February 2004

NOV 23, 2007 09:19 AM

yea...I wish I were God of War mad

Ferretbite

Ferretbite

Mexico
September 2006

NOV 23, 2007 09:43 AM

No shit, next they're gonna find out listening to metal doesn't set you up for gruesome horrible murder and the ritual sacrifice of babies any more than playing the GTA series makes you go on a car theft rampage and killing spree through a major city.

harshgrimcon

harshgrimcon

Glen Ellyn, IL
August 2007

NOV 23, 2007 10:17 AM

So, we're talking about a disagreement between the Iowa State Cyclones and the Texas A&M Aggies? I had a close friend go to Iowa State, so I recuse myself from that sort of comment.


But I would be interested to hear if, historically or presently, there was every any activity which was not violent which was an accurate predictor or cause of violent behavior.

DamienH

DamienH

United Kingdom
September 2003

NOV 23, 2007 10:20 AM

That last sentance made me laugh good and proper... I've been playing Call of Duty 4 so now I'm going to join the army and kill some terrorists, wait, that's what the government wants me to do... bugger.

Rapid_Fire

Rapid_Fire

Saskatoon, SK
July 2007

NOV 23, 2007 10:26 AM

DamienH said:
That last sentance made me laugh good and proper... I've been playing Call of Duty 4 so now I'm going to join the army and kill some terrorists, wait, that's what the government wants me to do... bugger.



*cough* *cough* *cough*

DamienH

DamienH

United Kingdom
September 2003

NOV 23, 2007 10:27 AM

I forgot to mention that Hitler killed about 6 million Jews and never played computer games, neither did a few others come to think of, I doubt Genghis Khan, Lenin, Mao Zedong or Pol Pot came home from school or work and played a few hours of violent games.

coyotemike

coyotemike

USA
May 2006

NOV 23, 2007 10:29 AM

Then how can I explain the rampage I went on after playing Pac-man?

Svephestia

Svephestia

Orlando, FL
October 2007

NOV 23, 2007 10:36 AM

Seriously, let's put an end to all these ignorant assertions. I'm so skeptical of studies; so many of them have critical flaws that make their findings questionable, but the findings are still released. Though, we can't ignore the ignorance of people, the world would be a better place if people listened a little more and actually did their research.

Soyjuice

Soyjuice

Menlo Park, CA
August 2005

NOV 23, 2007 10:49 AM

they should do a study about the influence of high school and how going to high school drives kids to violence

Darke

Darke

Trego, WI
June 2005

NOV 23, 2007 11:10 AM

johnnyfu said:
Oh, no, wait, sorry. It doesn't. The first three things in that list are from a Shakespeare play. The last two were from the Bible.



You can find em all in the Bible, actually. Let's outlaw Christianity. whatever

ardour

ardour

Ottawa, ON
March 2006

NOV 23, 2007 11:30 AM

Currently, Washington politicians are riled up about the ESRB rating system. The video game rating system, Democratic and Republican legislators say, is too vague to protect our nation’s innocent little children.



Like this even matters. Most parents are rather ignorant to it. Or at least they were when I was younger. The ESRB, I do believe, has the same amount of ratings as the MPAA does anyway, as well as descriptions of the type of gameplay that can be expected.

People do this to everything. It's downright hillarious that people once thought comic books were destroying our youth when you go back and look at the majority of those books that were effected.

OstrichDeity

OstrichDeity

New Albany, IN
February 2007

NOV 23, 2007 11:57 AM

johnnyfu said:
The uproar revolves around Manhunt 2, a game that features gruesome decapitations, rape, dismemberment, and encourages violent homophobia and fratricide.

Oh, no, wait, sorry. It doesn't. The first three things in that list are from a Shakespeare play. The last two were from the Bible.



Ownage.

Gillionaire

Gillionaire

Manchester, NH
February 2007

NOV 23, 2007 12:28 PM

I'm glad this news has been discovered. Sadly, it'll go completely ignored by the anti-gaming crowd, just like most facts.

passiveAggresive

passiveAggresive

San Francisco, CA
April 2004

NOV 23, 2007 01:59 PM

That was a great article about Titus Andronicus that you linked. The comparison to Pulp Fiction was gratifying. Nice!

ThatTalentedHack

ThatTalentedHack

San Antonio, TX
July 2007

NOV 23, 2007 02:17 PM

I hate to play the role of grammar-nazi, therefore,
I won't point out the flaws in the article... but many of the stories over the past few weeks have been almost unreadable. This article is just yet another example of why you should proof read before you post. IMO this sort of muddy text ruins perfectly good stories

SPOILERS! (Click to view)

AS A PAYING CUSTOMER, I EXPECT HIGHER QUALITY WRITING ON NEWS POSTS... PLEASE ADDRESS THIS



P.S. aside from my complaints, it was a fascinating article.

Previous

PAGE: 

1 | 2 | 3

Next

PETA: Creeping Me Out More

Last Comment 1 HR by Mantis

PETA: Creeping Me Out More

Last Comment 1 HR

I misunderstood, sorry More ...

GOP Prepares For Anal Rape

Last Comment 2 HR

I don't know. In case of Mike Huckabee, it just seems to be a weird allegiance to his anti-government... More ...

Terrible Woman's MySpace Alias Leads to Teen's Suicide.

Last Comment 3 HR

Good. I hope they can either make the charges stick or at least draw it out long enough for her to lose... More ...

You Fuck My Wife?

Last Comment 4 HR by otaku

You Fuck My Wife?

Last Comment 4 HR

(video) More ...

Now It's Weird

Last Comment 8 HR by RudieCantFail

Now It's Weird

Last Comment 8 HR

Really? Because I also moved here from the North a few years ago, and I don't find it to be any better... More ...

SuicideGirls Interview: Al Jourgensen of Ministry
SuicideGirls Interview: David Mamet
SuicideGirls Interview: Marty Krofft