• commentary
  • THURSDAY OCTOBER 4 2007 8:00 PM

"Desperate Housewives," Guilty of Nothing But Sucking



Is it possible for someone to make a joke or maybe even actually insult someone without being accused of racism. It seems the answer is "no."

The Philippine government is to seek an apology from the producers of the hit US television series "Desperate Housewives" for a racial slur against Filipino medics, the Philippine Daily Inquirer said on its web site Wednesday.

The officials cited a recent episode where actress Teri Hatcher, who plays Susan Mayer, asked whether the person attending to her during a medical consultation "can I check those diplomas because I want to make sure that they're not from some med school in the Philippines."


The most insulting revelation in that story is that "Desperate Housewives" thinks it's in a position to mock something. They try to write jokes on that show? Holy shit, you really do learn something new every day. I am honestly offended by this.

After I recovered from that piece of information, eventually... way, way later... I looked at the story. As much as I'd want to side with an Asian country over a shitty soap opera, I don't think I can.

Isn't the show (or anyone) allowed to make jokes at the expense of people, places and things? I mean, it's a joke. Laugh or don't but I don't see this as being a racist comment. You're telling me the honor and reputation of the Filipino people rests in the hands of a third-rate actress who once made a living kissing Dean Cain?

Or, putting aside the joke aspect, isn't the "character" uttering the line, allowed to be a racist? A subtle one, perhaps, but isn't that part of who she is? Is it wrong to portray a Nazi character as hating Jews? It's fiction, not some thinly-veiled propaganda.

Thirdly, making a crack about a certain country perhaps having less than perfect medical conditions may be ignorant (or not, in some cases) but it is not automatically racism. Some countries have better facilities than others This is a fact. Her criteria might be something other than just an assumption that all Filipinos are butchers. (As in, crude doctors, not the "Sam the butcher" type guys.) Maybe she's actually basing it on something tangible. I'm not saying this is the case, as I doubt the DH writers go that far, but we can't just assume it's a racist statement.

Then this happened.

ABC, owned by The Walt Disney Co., responded with a statement Wednesday. ABC said it was considering editing the episode.

"The producers of 'Desperate Housewives' and ABC Studios offer our sincere apologies for any offense caused by the brief reference in the season premiere. There was no intent to disparage the integrity of any aspect of the medical community in the Philippines," the statement said.

"As leaders in broadcast diversity, we are committed to presenting sensitive and respectful images of all communities featured in our programs," it concluded.


What a bunch of sissies. I don't understand, did you mean to imply that, for real, Filipino medical schools were inferior, or was it a joke? Then why apologise? Other than the fact that you pass yourselves off as a comedy show, you shouldn't be apologising for anything. People are allowed to offend people. Or they used to be, anyway.

Man, if I ever visit the Phillipines I better be able to eat off those fucking hospital floors.



TheCoolerKing continues to be a huge supporter of Filipino icon and "Destroyer," Manny Pacquiao.

 

Previous

PAGE: 

1 | 2

Next

Comments
Formus

Formus

Milwaukee, WI
May 2007

OCT 04, 2007 08:11 PM

It's Disney. Of course they'll edit it. The same company is automatically giving any movie with smoking an R rating. Let's just not pay attention to them.

shapeshifter23

shapeshifter23

San Francisco, CA
September 2005

OCT 04, 2007 08:56 PM

You're telling me the honor and reputation of the Filipino people rests in the hands of a third-rate actress who once made a living kissing Dean Cain?



Exactly. What happened to a time when official 'dignitaries' of government paid more attention to matters of genuine import and the phrase 'beneath contempt' had some operative validity? I mean, these are fuckin' sitcom writers, not public policymakers whose alleged racism [snort] might have any adverse impact on the rights and treatment of people of color [double snort].

Goes to show you that censorship in a society (and I'm not just talking TV sitcoms) is not strictly the policy of fascist and communist governments. What happens more often than not, nowadays, is self-censorship. I mean, how many times have I thought of saying something in a daily situation (often a joke or snide remark), and curbed my tongue voluntarily for fear of my words being misinterpreted as racism or sexual harassment?

OffBroadway

OffBroadway

Canada
September 2004

OCT 04, 2007 09:00 PM

This bugs me in the same way I'm bugged when someone quotes Shakespeare and doesn't put it in context with the character speaking the line.

One time, a patron at my live theatre complained to me that an actor in our 21st century drama had bad grammar. I said, "Perhaps that was the writer's intent." I kind of think her whole world was rocked.

Anyway, fuck ABC and Disney for not defending their artists.

SirLoins

sirloins

Huntington Beach, CA
October 2005

OCT 04, 2007 09:22 PM

I always thought the show should have been titled "Desperate Housechimps."

OnesandZeros

OnesandZeros

Cuyahoga Falls, OH
March 2004

OCT 04, 2007 09:28 PM

Fuck, I like that show, in fact that whole scene was genius.

Benzino

Benzino

Winnipeg, MB
November 2006

OCT 04, 2007 09:43 PM

Shouldn't television and film be an expression of reality? I hate the show, but I bet their are Americans, or Canadians who belive that the Phillipines have shitty med schools. This is just another example of the PC bullshit reeking havoc on society.

whitepuma

whitepuma

Australia
March 2004

OCT 04, 2007 10:07 PM

ahh the mind numbing and dumbing down of society due to media and the who PC crap I cant wait for the day that everything swings back and ppl begin shooting this wankers who are turning everyone in to brainless pussies.

Skywisdom

Skywisdom

Portland, OR
December 2005

OCT 04, 2007 10:13 PM

Personally, I can't wait for the day that people bashing PCness learn how to use punctuation and the correct usage of the term "There".

Cyanea

Cyanea

Seattle, WA
June 2006

OCT 04, 2007 10:33 PM

lol, I thought that was really funny. Either way, who cares?

photoline

photoline

Edmonton, AB
January 2005

OCT 04, 2007 10:40 PM

Is DH still on the air? I've never watched more than a few minutes of it since it began. Disney is good at taking the "tit" out of "titillation", despite all the hype that precedes each show.

DCruz

DCruz

Montreal-nord, QC
November 2006

OCT 04, 2007 10:46 PM

wait, you mean they *don't* have crappy med schools in the Philippines ? shocked

All jokes aside... it's true, what happened of the good days when we could make fun of anyone and have people actually understand it's a joke ? Or perhaps that never existed and we just pretended... either way, it's a tv show, who cares... it's not like it was some serious thing !

Johnny_Flapjacks

Johnny_Flapjacks

Williamsport, PA
September 2006

OCT 05, 2007 02:58 AM

I saw this on the news last night... I really thought the "joke" was more about people getting fake degrees from off shore schools that don't really exist. Either way, it wasn't funny.... not because it offended me, but because it just wasn't funny.

Mankarlen

Mankarlen

Columbia City, OR
June 2006

OCT 05, 2007 04:05 AM

I have been to the Phillippines enough said.

Domo_Kun

Domo_Kun

Rockford, IL
March 2005

OCT 05, 2007 10:07 AM

OffBroadway said:
This bugs me in the same way I'm bugged when someone quotes Shakespeare and doesn't put it in context with the character speaking the line.

One time, a patron at my live theatre complained to me that an actor in our 21st century drama had bad grammar. I said, "Perhaps that was the writer's intent." I kind of think her whole world was rocked.

Anyway, fuck ABC and Disney for not defending their artists.



You can call them many things, but "artists", even using the loosest definition of the word (which would define "Fiddy" as an artist), they are not.

xazapdmytinu

xazapdmytinu

Fort Collins, CO
July 2007

OCT 05, 2007 12:01 PM

wait...they didn't poke fun at Filipinos...they made a jab at their questionable medical degrees...that's a huge difference...furthermore, I thought Teri Hatcher was dead in the show (Or is this some sort of flashback and we get to find out that the reason she's dead is because some schmuck who couldn't get into American Med school went to the Philippines for his degree?)

Previous

PAGE: 

1 | 2

Next