• commentary
  • MONDAY SEPTEMBER 10 2007 4:00 PM

Facebook: Feeding Babies is Obscene



Facebook has made a bad mistake. Apparently they've been deleting pictures of breastfeeding mamas and babies, and in some cases even deleting the accounts of said mamas. This, apparently, because they (1) consider breasts obscene, and (2) can't differentiate between a titty shot and a picture of someone feeding a baby.

"Photos containing an exposed breast do violate our Terms and are removed," she said.

It's not clear what constitutes an "exposed breast", which has the lactivists baffled.

Facebook did not respond to emails requesting further clarification but several group members have reported that their images were removed despite the fact they contained no nipple.


As anyone who's ever had a baby knows, you Do Not Fuck With Breastfeeding Mamas, who are one of the most easily organized groups on the internet. After all, websurfing is one of the few things you can do easily while nursing a baby. And mamas who breastfeed are pretty damn militant (rightly so), since it takes a certain amount of chutzpah just to overcome the "omg, titties!" thing and decide to nurse in the first place.

I predict that Facebook's going to change their mind about this policy within a week. So if you're on Facebook and agree that they should learn the difference between porn and breastfeeding, you'd better hurry up and join the Hey, Facebook, breastfeeding is not obscene! group; since the original article linked at the top of this story appeared three days ago, the group's gotten almost 10,000 members, who've posted over 600 breastfeeding photos.

Bitch_PhD breastfed her kid for two and a half years.

 

Previous

PAGE: 

1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6

 ... 11

Next

Comments
Alz

Alz

Lincoln, NE
February 2007

SEP 10, 2007 04:56 PM

They already went over this on livejournal. Facebook is clearly behind the times.

meta

meta

Saint Paul, MN
March 2005

SEP 10, 2007 04:57 PM

people shouldn't breastfeed in public and should instead wait to let their babies EAT when they are alone in a dark corner and can expose their shameful breasts? good Christ. you'd rather have babies screaming on the bus and wherever else than let them eat in peace?

breastmilk is food for babies. if you're grossed out by breastfeeding, you should be grossed out by watching full-grown humans eat.

anyway, Facebook is a bunch of Big Brotherish crap and I can't believe people are still getting outraged by the shit it gets away with. worse, I can't believe people still willingly sign up to be part of it.

sickboyedd

sickboyedd

United Kingdom
January 2004

SEP 10, 2007 04:57 PM

I think it's pretty laughable to kick people off for showing something natural and not obscene and yet at the same time drag their heals cleaning up groups that promote hate.

meta

meta

Saint Paul, MN
March 2005

SEP 10, 2007 04:59 PM

Lyte88 said:
If you want to breast feed go ahead, if you want to take pictures do it... but when you put them on facebook... common... no1 wants to see that. facebook is for networking you put pictures of your face, friends, parties etc... but when it gets to the point that people put pics like that up something needs to be changed... i say make facebook only available for college/uni students again and keep the breast feeding out of it!!



some college students are mothers.

and guzzling breastmilk is more reprehensible than guzzling booze?

I am at a loss.

LostLucy

LostLucy

USA
December 2006

SEP 10, 2007 05:02 PM

Somehow in my post i forgot to note that i was surprised that people (ok women) were posting these pics.

but I have to say, when your breasts become huge and you can produce milk, they don't always seem to be your breast, so much as large & alien squirting objects

so maybe there's this disconnect...

Some states have laws permitting women to be topless for this purpose.. it really is not a salacious event.

Cigarette

Cigarette

Cleveland, OH
April 2004

SEP 10, 2007 05:05 PM

RileyStClair said:
eh, i don't get why they'd really want to post breastfeeding pics either,



Why post anything?

RileyStClair

RileyStClair

Los Angeles, CA
September 2006

SEP 10, 2007 05:08 PM

Cigarette said:

RileyStClair said:
eh, i don't get why they'd really want to post breastfeeding pics either,



Why post anything?



well, what i meant was there are some pictures i am cool with people seeing and some i'm not and at this point i would personally put "my boobs" in the "not cool" category. but i can see how moms might feel otherwise.

lefthandright

lefthandright

New Zealand
September 2006

SEP 10, 2007 05:08 PM

the fact is face book own the site...they can or unmake rules as much as they like. They can ban pics of red clothes...they can ban pics of ppl with brown hair...if you wanna show yourself breastfeeding bubs to a friend, then just email it. I have read similiar cases of where sites banned breastfeeding pics for the reason that they found the pics were getting large amount of hits each day. They feared the pics in question were perhaps being used by some ppl for unmoral reasons without the owner of the pics consent...it made sense to me...in the uk you can't take your cell phone into a public pool..for the reason that you cant use a phone under water, but also they found a certain element of strangers were picing young children in their bathers or snapping infants who had been left to run undressed...they banned to keep the sick element down to a minimum..again made sense...if face book for whatever reason wants to ban breastfeeding...it is their site,..they can do what they want...if you don't like,..go create your own version of similiar site...seems so simple...don't like the rules...don't go there.

Cigarette

Cigarette

Cleveland, OH
April 2004

SEP 10, 2007 05:08 PM

Lyte88 said:
no1 wants to see that.



No1 on sg wants 2 see pix of u makin out wit ur b.f. either.

RileyStClair

RileyStClair

Los Angeles, CA
September 2006

SEP 10, 2007 05:11 PM

no one's arguing whether facebook has the authority to delete the pictures, the argument is that it's silly.

mamet

mamet

Charleston, SC
March 2005

SEP 10, 2007 05:13 PM

Cigarette said:

Lyte88 said:
no1 wants to see that.



No1 on sg wants 2 see pix of u makin out wit ur b.f. either.



Oh, Cigarette, let's make babies and then breastfeed them in public.

Tallboy66

Tallboy66

Chicago, IL
January 2005

SEP 10, 2007 05:16 PM

People are freaking out, again.

It reminds of a story a few years back about the photo developer at some drug store that turned in a guy and his roll of film of his naked daughter playing in the tub as kiddie porn.

apesamongus

apesamongus

Atlanta, GA
July 2002

SEP 10, 2007 05:20 PM

Vidalia said:
Okay, agreed, but I think mamas should definitely still have the right to!


I can't even begin to count the number of time someone has said on SG that "we have a right to say..." and then a dozen people come out of the rafters to point out that a website is not a personal forum. And the same applies to facebook as applies to SG. The owners of facebook can decide who and what to allow on their site. The end. And then anyone can protest and try to change things, but ultimately, they (fb) get to decide.

MrStitches

MrStitches

Brooklyn, NY
November 2003

SEP 10, 2007 05:21 PM

apesamongus said:

Vidalia said:
Okay, agreed, but I think mamas should definitely still have the right to!


I can't even begin to count the number of time someone has said on SG that "we have a right to say..." and then a dozen people come out of the rafters to point out that a website is not a personal forum. And the same applies to facebook as applies to SG. The owners of facebook can decide who and what to allow on their site. The end. And then anyone can protest and try to change things, but ultimately, they (fb) get to decide.


It doesn't make it any less stupid.

OhSoOrdinary

OhSoOrdinary

New York, NY
July 2006

SEP 10, 2007 05:26 PM

Breastfeeding is awesome. Yay for feeding from breasts.

But why do people do it for so long? I mean, until age three?

I don't know. I don't have kids.

Previous

PAGE: 

1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6

 ... 11

Next