• commentary
  • MONDAY SEPTEMBER 10 2007 4:00 PM

Facebook: Feeding Babies is Obscene



Facebook has made a bad mistake. Apparently they've been deleting pictures of breastfeeding mamas and babies, and in some cases even deleting the accounts of said mamas. This, apparently, because they (1) consider breasts obscene, and (2) can't differentiate between a titty shot and a picture of someone feeding a baby.

"Photos containing an exposed breast do violate our Terms and are removed," she said.

It's not clear what constitutes an "exposed breast", which has the lactivists baffled.

Facebook did not respond to emails requesting further clarification but several group members have reported that their images were removed despite the fact they contained no nipple.


As anyone who's ever had a baby knows, you Do Not Fuck With Breastfeeding Mamas, who are one of the most easily organized groups on the internet. After all, websurfing is one of the few things you can do easily while nursing a baby. And mamas who breastfeed are pretty damn militant (rightly so), since it takes a certain amount of chutzpah just to overcome the "omg, titties!" thing and decide to nurse in the first place.

I predict that Facebook's going to change their mind about this policy within a week. So if you're on Facebook and agree that they should learn the difference between porn and breastfeeding, you'd better hurry up and join the Hey, Facebook, breastfeeding is not obscene! group; since the original article linked at the top of this story appeared three days ago, the group's gotten almost 10,000 members, who've posted over 600 breastfeeding photos.

Bitch_PhD breastfed her kid for two and a half years.

 

Previous

PAGE: 

1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6

 ... 11

Next

Comments
makebelieve

makebelieve

Winston Salem, NC
February 2007

SEP 10, 2007 04:06 PM

I have no kids. So I have never breastfed a baby. I plan on doing so whenever I am lucky enough to have them. But WHY (and i am legitimately asking this question) would you put pictures of your baby breastfeeding on your Facebook account? Myspace, oh definitely. But Facebook?

I guess this is just a beauty I cannot appreciate until I go through it myself. Oh well.

oh and to edit I am not saying it isn't a beautiful thing at all. Don't want to be attacked by the Breastfeeding Mamas. Just don't know why you feel the need to share that moment with the world.

McKenneth

McKenneth

Macedon, NY
August 2005

SEP 10, 2007 04:14 PM

superkrzyamos said:
I have no kids. So I have never breastfed a baby. I plan on doing so whenever I am lucky enough to have them. But WHY (and i am legitimately asking this question) would you put pictures of your baby breastfeeding on your Facebook account? Myspace, oh definitely. But Facebook?

I guess this is just a beauty I cannot appreciate until I go through it myself. Oh well.

oh and to edit I am not saying it isn't a beautiful thing at all. Don't want to be attacked by the Breastfeeding Mamas. Just don't know why you feel the need to share that moment with the world.



+1

mamet

mamet

Charleston, SC
March 2005

SEP 10, 2007 04:22 PM

I joined the group, and I agree with the message. But the term "lactivist" is really, really stupid.

BigWobbles

BigWobbles

Philadelphia, PA
June 2004

SEP 10, 2007 04:22 PM

Well i guess.....forget it no matter what I have to say Ill get shit for it.

Vidalia

Vidalia

SUICIDEGIRL

USA

SEP 10, 2007 04:24 PM

superkrzyamos said:
I have no kids. So I have never breastfed a baby. I plan on doing so whenever I am lucky enough to have them. But WHY (and i am legitimately asking this question) would you put pictures of your baby breastfeeding on your Facebook account? Myspace, oh definitely. But Facebook?

I guess this is just a beauty I cannot appreciate until I go through it myself. Oh well.

oh and to edit I am not saying it isn't a beautiful thing at all. Don't want to be attacked by the Breastfeeding Mamas. Just don't know why you feel the need to share that moment with the world.



Okay, agreed, but I think mamas should definitely still have the right to!

Ainur

Ainur

I'm lost
May 2005

SEP 10, 2007 04:24 PM

I remember I went to YouTube not too long ago, a month or so, and in the "What People Are Watching" area there was clearly a giant nipple. Now, I was mighty perplexed by this, because it was YouTube, and they don't do nipples. So, being the curious sort, I clicked on it. Turns out it was some sort of breastfeeding documentary. The doc was only slightly interesting as I'm a guy and find babies to be completely and totally creapy. But the comments were WAY entertaining. There are some scary people out there. That has nothing to do with this story really. I just had too much coffee today.

_Tryst_

_Tryst_

I'm lost
July 2007

SEP 10, 2007 04:26 PM

I get the whole thing about posting pics on Facebook, well tthat site anyway.
WHO THE FUCK ARE those people on facebook to think they can judge aesthetics-PERIOD. We've gotten so far off from who we are and what our nature is that they feel like it must be deleted to to 'Obscene' Nature!?! good GOD folks!

xazapdmytinu

xazapdmytinu

Fort Collins, CO
July 2007

SEP 10, 2007 04:31 PM

While I think it absolutely silly to chuck people off a social networking site for having pictures of them being responsible parents I'm wondering why people have pictures of them breast feeding in the first place? Surely you could have found a more adorable image of your snuggly baby than the one your husband or wacky friend snapped of you while you we have brunch at church?

Also, if an exposed nipple is considered obscene I'd like to ask that facebook remove the pictures of 15 year olds trying to look tough with their shirts off in front of their dad's boat sucking their baby fat in.

LostLucy

LostLucy

USA
December 2006

SEP 10, 2007 04:32 PM

I have kids. I breastfed all of them. I breastfed them until age 3. I breastfed them when they and I felt like it, regardless of where we were. Like other breastfeeding mothers I encountered a breadth of responses and never took any shit.

Despite putting some pretty crazy pics in the INTAnet, and breastfeeding when and where-ever, I agree with superkrzyamos that I would not jump to post it on some pseudo preppyass internet group site..

but i sure as F*ck defend to death their right to do so wink

gcash056

gcash056

Orlando, FL
October 2004

SEP 10, 2007 04:33 PM

Hey, breastfeeding is natural.

So is taking a shit.

Doesn't mean I want to SEE someone doing either in public, thankyouverymuch.

DownNeck

DownNeck

Jersey City, NJ
March 2006

SEP 10, 2007 04:40 PM

gcash056 said:
Hey, breastfeeding is natural.

So is taking a shit.

Doesn't mean I want to SEE someone doing either in public, thankyouverymuch.



I staunchly support every woman's right to expose one or both of her breasts in my presence whenever and however she sees fit.

RedAss

RedAss

Boston, MA
December 2004

SEP 10, 2007 04:42 PM

Of course you should have the right to post pictures of your kids breast feeding, but that doesn't make it a good idea.

RileyStClair

RileyStClair

Los Angeles, CA
September 2006

SEP 10, 2007 04:44 PM

eh, i don't get why they'd really want to post breastfeeding pics either, but i don't have kids so i fully admit "not getting it."

the point is that breastfeeding is natural, it's not sexual and women should be able to post these pictures if they want.

Crissis

Crissis

Ecuador
January 2007

SEP 10, 2007 04:45 PM

I am sorry but since I had never had babies I really dont like to watch other women breast feed! I respect it but PLEASE don't do it on the street or on the seat next to me on the bus! blush

Lyte88

Lyte88

Kitchener, ON
May 2007

SEP 10, 2007 04:54 PM

If you want to breast feed go ahead, if you want to take pictures do it... but when you put them on facebook... common... no1 wants to see that. facebook is for networking you put pictures of your face, friends, parties etc... but when it gets to the point that people put pics like that up something needs to be changed... i say make facebook only available for college/uni students again and keep the breast feeding out of it!!

Previous

PAGE: 

1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6

 ... 11

Next