• commentary
  • SUNDAY JULY 1 2007 10:00 PM

You Kids Get Off My Lawn

Tags: feminism



Y'all should read Jennifer Fox's good essay, "I Was Not a Feminist." She really gets at a truth that applies even to those of us who were feminists growing up, the young woman's determination not to let her sex affect her life:

As far as I was concerned, it didn't matter what happened to me along the way. Gender was not going to come in and ruin my life. When a teacher sexually abused me at 13, I was sure that it was personal, not political. When at 15, I was dragged from the street to a vacant lot and nearly raped -- but for a sudden car passing that made the rapist flee -- I never stopped to think it had anything to do with being a girl. And when at 17, I was beaten up on the street by a man I refused to sleep with, with people walking by who never stopped to help, I still thought it had nothing to do with gender. Somehow it was all an accident -- it could have happened to anyone male or female.


I remember thinking that way, although thankfully I've never been molested, raped, or abused. Thinking that women who complained about being discriminated against as women were pitiable, in both senses of the word: yes, they deserved compassion, but underneath that compassion was a teensy bit of contempt--it was on some level their own fault that they "chose" to give up their careers to raise kids, or to quit their jobs to follow their husband's careers, or to date jerks, or whatever. Unlike Fox, I didn't think my freedom from feminism was going to keep me from this stuff; I thought that *because* I was a feminist, I knew better.

Then I got older and learned a few things. Like that no matter what choices you make in life, you're still constrained (or advantaged) by the world around you. What are you going to do, if you have a career and a kid? How many men are really willing to quit and stay home? So you end up putting the kid in daycare, but when it gets sick, someone has to leave work and pick it up. Maybe you're willing to fight with your husband over whose turn it is, and maybe your husband is a genuinely good guy who wants to be fair--but his boss doesn't get it and he probably makes more money than you do and the kid needs to be picked up by one of you. So chances are it's going to be you, more often than it's going to be him.

Little stuff like this adds up. I had a husband who was willing to quit his career and follow me to a new job and stay home with the kid--which was awesome, and completely great of him. But of course then we had to deal with his family, and my colleagues, being "concerned" that he wasn't working, and the fact that I earned about a third of what he could. His choices are "sacrifices" and heroism--when he was working, he was "supporting me," and now that he wasn't, he was still, somehow, "supporting me." That kind of shit puts a lot of pressure on a couple, and no matter how determined you are to make your own decisions, there's doubt and spats and tension.

So whether you will or no, sexism affects your life. Your choices end up being a balancing act between the things you believe are right and the things you know will make your life a little easier. What compromises can you live with? What sacrifices do you have to make out of mercy to yourself and your partner? What shitty realities are you going to just agree to deal with, and which ones are you going to continue to fight?

Guys obviously have to deal with gender bullshit as well--obviously having his family "worry" that he wasn't working was annoying to my man, too. But the big difference between men and women is that the roles men are "supposed" to play are ones that give them economic power, and the ones women are supposed to play take it away.

Believe me or don't. Believe Jennifer Fox or don't. But keep in mind that believing a thing doesn't make it so. And that there's something to be said for experience.

Bitch_PhD thinks most Americans overrate the power of individualism.

 

Previous

PAGE: 

1 | 2 | 3 | 4

Next

Comments
Twelve

Twelve

Bay City, MI
April 2007

JUL 01, 2007 10:15 PM

John Lennon wrote that song.

Roethke

Roethke

SUICIDEGIRL

California, USA

JUL 01, 2007 10:32 PM

Great article!

Bitch_PhD

Bitch_PhD

I'm lost
February 2007

JUL 01, 2007 10:57 PM

Thank you!

choster

choster

I'm lost
January 2007

JUL 01, 2007 10:59 PM

It does chap a bit that I never once heard any of our elders whisper "when is she gonna get a job?" while I was supporting my wife through school... now that our roles are reversed I feel the brunt of those quiet comments... you just want to scream sometimes... "I'll get a job when I'm done with school you idiots!!!" What were they expecting? That I'd drop out (again) and go back to work as a peon in the tech industry at 1/5 my wife's salary? Do they think I'm slow?

While there is certainly some pressure that anyone feels when they are fulfilling a non-traditional role in their society... I feel like I've grown immensely as a person having had this opportunity. I have so much respect for full time parents and even more for single parents now, and I think I probably would have missed out on this perspective had I just continued working when our son was born. I'm certain that the gents I worked with would not have done anything to dissuade me from the generic societal opinion of stay-at-home-moms. Truth is, I sometimes catch a little flak from my wife (like she thinks I'm home eating bon-bons all day, haha)... but it doesn't bother me cause I know both sides of the story.

Phantasy

Phantasy

Australia
October 2005

JUL 01, 2007 11:05 PM

So much of that rang true for me. Please, more articles like this!

Skywisdom

Skywisdom

Portland, OR
December 2005

JUL 02, 2007 12:34 AM

Dear BitchPHD,
This article was my favorite thing you have ever written, and I've read pretty much every article you've written on here, and many of the ones you've put on your website/blog.
I guess that's all.

abracadabra

abracadabra

Seattle, WA
April 2004

JUL 02, 2007 12:56 AM

I agree..lets level the playing field and tell everyone to fuck off and mind their own business..Women should be paid exactly the same as men no matter what field they are in..Good insight!

Lode_Runner

Lode_Runner

Australia
December 2004

JUL 02, 2007 02:24 AM

Well said Bitch_PhD.

Flawedhero

Flawedhero

Suwanee, GA
October 2006

JUL 02, 2007 02:29 AM

abracadabra said:
I agree..lets level the playing field and tell everyone to fuck off and mind their own business..Women should be paid exactly the same as men no matter what field they are in..Good insight!



Though I often don't agree with Bitch's ways of going about things, I agree with this one.

Fuck just pay, everything should be as equal possible.

Ridley

Ridley

SUICIDEGIRL

California, USA

JUL 02, 2007 02:31 AM

This article was well written and not as combative as most of your articles. It was actually insightful and interesting to read and think about. Instead of automatically fighting what you were talking about (because face it usually you are writing to pick a fight with someone) I was interested. Thank you for writing a great article.

Jennifer_

Jennifer_

Venezuela
November 2006

JUL 02, 2007 04:25 AM

That article was interesting, but I think the main problem women face now is internalising the sexist stereotypes that surround them. It's maybe not that they always come across barriers in the workplace; is it possible that alot of women just don't try for certain goals because it's not 'the norm', and that becomes a self-perpetuating cycle?

Still, I don't understand why women are the invisible gender. There are as many women as there are men, so why are women such an incredibly small minority, in every career from politicians to comedians to snowboarders and CEOs?

A friend who works for HSBC told me about a recent conference they went to, where there were a couple of hundred men but only two women there. A speaker at the conference, who was female, found out the names of the two women at the conference and started her talk by saying (instead of 'hello, ladies and gentlemen'), 'hello gentlemen, and Anna and Monica'.

I think the main problem is that women are socially conditioned to feel they only 'belong' in certain careers, such as teachers, nurses, artists or the lower, entry-level positions in male dominated industries.

The other part of me wonders if feminism is just acting as a 'timebomb' - in the next 10 or 20 years, the women who were educated in the more egalitarian 80s and 90s will start going after the 'top jobs' and redress the gender balance.

Charybdus

Charybdus

Lafayette, LA
July 2006

JUL 02, 2007 06:30 AM

I agree. One of the primary keys to gender equality is equality in pay. Jenny has a good point concerning internalizing gender roles too, though. I don't know any bulemic/anorexic men, although I assume they exist, and I don't think "bigism" really compares (or body dismorphia or whatever). I think though at least to a small extent that our society is changing in regard to classifying women who are unnaturally thin as uber-sexy. I personally feel to limit beauty to any build is a disservice to the concept. Hopefully one day, but probably not for a very long time, economic equality will broaden to true equality. Not in my lifetime, though.

SouGei

SouGei

Blackwood, NJ
January 2007

JUL 02, 2007 07:27 AM

TwelveTone said:
John Lennon wrote that song.




Are you being intentionally ironic by giving John full credit?

RileyStClair

RileyStClair

Los Angeles, CA
September 2006

JUL 02, 2007 09:12 AM

Jenni said:
The other part of me wonders if feminism is just acting as a 'timebomb' - in the next 10 or 20 years, the women who were educated in the more egalitarian 80s and 90s will start going after the 'top jobs' and redress the gender balance.



that's what a lot of people thought, too--that it was just a "pipeline" problem and now that all these girls raised to believe they can do anything they set their minds to are going to come busting through the gates and take the fuck over.

but now that my generation (educated in the 80s/90s) is in the workforce, i realize the problem is that the same inequalities that fundamentally affect women are still in place. employers assume women are going to get married and switch to part time (or quit entirely) once they have kids and are thus less likely to put women in the "top jobs" in the first place, thinking that women don't prioritize work. very few men ever take paternity leave, and the ones who do may be thought of by their colleagues as lazy.

the workplace is still organized around men, which itself drives women out. when women face the same hurdles they have been and try to walk that famous family-career balance and find it too difficult, they're opting out, leaving the men in the "top jobs" (the kind that demand availability to work 24/7), so nothing is really changing.

Twelve

Twelve

Bay City, MI
April 2007

JUL 02, 2007 09:42 AM

jimHAK said:
Are you being intentionally ironic by giving John full credit?



Hah, I actually forgot that was from when he was with Yoko. What can I say; it was late.

Previous

PAGE: 

1 | 2 | 3 | 4

Next