• feature
  • SATURDAY APRIL 21 2007 12:00 PM

Brad Warner's Hardcore Zen: Sharp Angle

In his book Zen Mind, Beginner’s Mind, Zen teacher Shunryu Suzuki says that in most religions practitioners become like a sharp angle pointing away from themselves, while in Zen the angle points towards ourselves. The events Monday at Virginia Tech showed clearly what can happen when someone keeps sharpening and sharpening that angle pointing away from himself. We can say that the worthless piece of garbage who committed those murders was a nut case, schizophrenic or whatever multi-syllable word they finally settle on to describe him, and maybe it’s true. But he wasn’t the least bit different from the rest of us.

We all strengthen and enlarge our egos by constantly raging against things outside ourselves that we say make us upset — exactly like that dirtbag did. Maybe in our case it's different stuff we blame for our troubles and maybe we don't deal with it the same way. But we are absolutely convinced, just as he was, that the source of our problems is out there somewhere, not inside our own hearts, minds and bodies. That sharp angle points ever and always utterly away from the real source of trouble.

Thankfully most of us don’t take things to the kind of extremes we saw on Monday. We’re more likely to simmer and stew in our own misery occasionally pausing to rail at a world we never asked to be born into, but mostly just feeling sad and sorry for ourselves. Trust me, friends and neighbors, I know all about this. I was the sharpest angle pointing away from himself you could ever want to meet. My unhappiness was everybody’s fault but mine. There was never any lack of evidence of this, so nobody could ever convince me I was wrong. Not that most people I knew ever tried very hard. Cuz if my troubles weren’t out there then neither were theirs. And that’s not an easy thing to own up to. I was lucky enough to meet one person who had admitted to himself where the real source of his problems were and who helped me to see the real source of mine. I later discovered there was a long tradition of people who did this. But it’s always been a tiny, tiny minority.

It is the hardest thing in the world to admit that you are the real source of your own problems and your own pain. Harder than anything you can possibly imagine. We’ll commit any kind of atrocity, endure any kind of agony, slaughter our families, friends and neighbors, terrorize each other, do pretty much anything horrible, wrong, deceitful and stupid all just to get away from putting the blame for our troubles where it really belongs. Not out there in those bad people. Not out there in those terrible circumstances. But right in here. It’s you. It’s always been you and it always will be you.

Pretending the trouble is out there is a great way to avoid doing the real work that actually needs to be done. You can never really do anything about your problems as long as they’re out there. It’s hopeless to try and change the whole wide world into something more to your liking. You can write blogs or letters to the editor or scream and shout on street corners. You can shoot up your whole campus or post office or blow up a few major buildings. Or you can just do the little things we all usually do, act like jerks, insist on our own way, cut in line, litter, pardy hardy and wake up our lousy neighbors. But no matter what you do to all those people out there who’ve made you so upset it’s never, ever, ever going to solve your real problem. September 11th didn’t convert the world to the Muslim faith. McVey didn’t topple the United States government. That asswipe in Virginia didn’t teach the rich and the debauched a damn thing. And nothing you do against all those people and things out there you think caused all the shit in your life will ever make a bit of difference either. But when you change your attitude and change your focus, point that sharp angle back at yourself then — presto! — everything changes completely.

Does this mean you never do anything to put the outside world right cuz everything's, like, groovy now and you're all enlightened? Not a chance. You’ll be working at it every second of every day for the rest of your life. Because the most important thing you can do to put the outside world right is to get yourself together. And that's a job that never ends.

This is a very serious matter. The idea that our problems are all out there beyond ourselves is the cause of all human misery — every crime, every suicide, every act of terrorism, every war. Even your common garden-variety complaints can always be traced back to the deeper underlying idea that our problems are somewhere out there.

If you really want to do something to make sure other tragedies like this don’t occur anymore, you can. There’s a lot of work to be done, and it’s going to take time. But it’s work you can do right here and right now. More than that, it's the work you really want to do. It's what you were born for. It takes real courage to do this work because what you’re going to see is that the crazed killer isn’t out there in Virginia or out there in the hills of Afghanistan or out there in the White House. He’s you. But the good news is that once you see that, then you can take real, useful action. And it doesn’t start by watching that idiot’s dumbass manifesto over and over and over on YouTube or whatever. Or watching the folks at NBC lie to us that their motivation for releasing the tape was anything other than irresponsible greed. Or even with reading what I or Shunryu Suzuki or anyone else has to say about it. It starts with you being very quiet and seeing who you really are.

This won't fix everything today or tomorrow or by the end of next year or in the next decade. But slowly the effect will spread. It's all up to you.

Brad Warner is the author of Hardcore Zen and the forthcoming Sit Down and Shut Up!. He maintains a blog about Buddhist stuff. If you're in Southern California and you want to try some Zazen for yourself, he has a group that meets every Saturday in Santa Monica.

 
Comments
Lumi

Lumi

SUICIDEGIRL

California, USA

APR 21, 2007 01:32 PM

exactly.

and in this article, i'm in love with you! biggrin

OctEgon

OctEgon

Tustin, CA
July 2005

APR 21, 2007 07:18 PM

Props

zef

zef

Fairborn, OH
July 2005

APR 21, 2007 08:25 PM

Thanks, I needed this reminder.

Phantasy

Phantasy

Australia
October 2005

APR 21, 2007 08:33 PM

You are so fucking right.

DickieV

DickieV

Henderson, NV
February 2003

APR 21, 2007 09:18 PM

Great column, thanks.

xani

xani

Charlottesville, VA
May 2006

APR 21, 2007 10:18 PM

interesting use of underscores... hmm i really dig the sharp angle shit. i catch myself saying, somebody made me feel bad about myself. I stop myself knowing that i am the decider.

droog81

droog81

Philadelphia, PA
February 2005

APR 21, 2007 11:43 PM

Right, except for when the problem really is "out there". Like when people, like this monster, "out there" do something terrible to us or try to remove meaning from what's "in here". The people "out there"... the ones who are very much a part of what's "in here", have an effect on the rest of the world, "out there" and "in here".

Im pretty sure that the families and friends of the victims are suffering right now because of that rotten man's actions, because of something that happened "out there" to the people they loved "out there" who gave their life meaning, and not because of a lack of ambivalence toward the outside world.

I disagree that the source of such an atrocity is that none of us are inward enough. Would the world be a better place if events like these didnt bother us? Should the acts of "garbage" really lead us to such relativity? That we are human and imperfect is obvious, but that "he wasn't the least bit different from the rest of us" is ridiculous, foolishly misanthropic, and intentionally blind.

solus

solus

Denver, CO
September 2006

APR 22, 2007 10:44 AM

Thank you!

luxmeaveritas

luxmeaveritas

Albuquerque, NM
December 2004

APR 22, 2007 01:11 PM

This is by far my favorite article of yours. Of course, I completely agree. This has been very illuminating. Thanks. :]

NewSpectre

NewSpectre

Baltimore, MD
March 2005

APR 22, 2007 04:54 PM

I never understood zen. I'm pretty happy, and it just seems so angsty.

Bobbz

Bobbz

I'm lost
December 2005

APR 22, 2007 05:11 PM

Thanks Brad! Spring is a time of renewal. Maybe we can look at all the pain and needless suffering this piece of shit has caused and see that we need to take a second and get to now those around us..

demoivre

demoivre

Santa Barbara, CA
January 2003

APR 22, 2007 05:52 PM

I couldn't agree more, Brad. Awesome article.

Dr_Lizardo

Dr_Lizardo

Indian Orchard, MA
February 2006

APR 22, 2007 10:04 PM

One thing that you might notice about being a human being is that you do not pop into existence out of a void with all the knowledge you need to lead to lead a compassionate and constructive life.

You pop out of the womb, splat. You're a blob, an you know nothing other than that you want, and you cry out in the hopes that someone will give you what you need. As you get older, you learn that there are conditions attached to getting what you need, as people dump all sorts of information into you about who you are and what you're expected to do. And you have to learn to communicate with others and to assert yourself in social heirarchies.

something you might notice about folks who get rather violent is that they are the ones who aren't any good at asserting themselves, and they are mentally and physically abused by the other children we like to think are "nice" and don't like to think are savagely competing for the social positions that they will more or less occupy for the rest of their lives. the columbine shooters where outcasts. Mcveigh got stuffed into his locker by bullies, cho had close to literally no voice, with his speech problem, and he was tormented by his peers. people like to blame "gun culture" or the media or other pet evil, but they refuse to understand that savagery and profound pain are the most ordinary day to day things that transact in the lives of schoolchildren everywhere.

as I said, people don't pop into existence out of a vacuum. they are beings shaped by the causes and conditions of their environments. it is more remarkable that anyone becomes able to look inward and make changes within himself than that people who get psychologically destroyed by the people they had to grow up with occasionally hit a point of critical mass where they lose it and start killing.

I see cho as having made a decision to walk into blackness the way he did, But I seem him as having had a great deal of help in becoming that exact person, to make that decision. "out there" is where the conditions of our being inevitably originate. we coalesced from out there and are made of it. if we are very lucky the "in here" can become something that can pick itself by its own bootstraps, toward whatever goal you think is appropriate, but to expect everyone to have that ability is neither compassionate nor realistic.

saintjavi

saintjavi

Kissimmee, FL
January 2007

APR 23, 2007 07:57 PM

man, talk about a drop of knowledge on the community there. Dr. Lizardo and Droog make really good points as well. Unfortunate event, truly I sometimes wish events like this would never exists. I got to see the video when it first came out and I could sense his misplaced anger and sorrow and horribly enough I understand it. Fortunately I saw a way out of the darkness and found the light within. I had people show me, before I too drove into that same path of unnecessary murder. I'm truly grateful to these people for they thwarted my destiny. I've met people just like that kid in my town. I've become friends and created a sort of "wolf pack" that grows and grows throughout the years.

if you don't get out what's inside it will eventually consume you and you fall into the darkness within humanity. To think at this age I could have been a thug and caused so much grief. A piece of philosophy i picked up along the way is that one's own darkness is equal to their light, and vice-versa. Who knows, maybe if that guy would have gone the way of light he could have become a life saver instead of a killer.

but aside from my lil philosophy spread there, awesome article mr. brad warner. really made me think and others too. props to u dr. liz and droog as well!