• commentary
  • MONDAY DECEMBER 18 2006 4:00 PM

Miss USA busted by Miss Ogyny


If beauty queens can be dethroned for "dating too many men," or posing nude, what hope is there for the rest of us? Clearly, these women are of superior moral virtue. I mean, just look at them! Could anyone that gorgeous really do anything wrong?

I guess that's Donald Trump's reasoning behind his consideration of the current Miss USA's bad behavior. Tara Conner was allegedly caught partying in a variety of NYC clubs, even though she's only 20 and the legal drinking age in New York is 21. (Silly Americans! Don't you know Montreal's only an eight hour bus ride away and the drinking age here is 18?) Apparently this kind of thing is bad enough that Trump, "the self-described teetotaler," is questioning her ability to...um...lead the country's beauties. Or just stand around being beautiful? Er...huh. Well, I guess that brings us to the real question: what the hell is it that Miss USA does, anyway?

According to a Yahoo! News article,

Miss USA organizers declined to hand over a list of rules for their titleholder, but said she had to be a role model.


So role models can't be naughty, right? Wait a second, then why do lots of women grow up wanting to be porn stars, strippers and SuicideGirls?

The article goes on to state that

Miss America, another beauty pageant institution, said [...] the titleholder [...] had to "protect and enhance the image, good name and broad public acceptance of (Miss America)."


Right. So, unless you're promoting our organization and keeping us in the public's good graces so that we can sell more advertising and make more money off your pretty smile and hot body (which should never be seen naked, god forbid!), you're gonna get the boot, sweetheart.

So, why would anybody want to be a chaste beauty queen?

Oh, right:

* The new MISS USA will be crowned with a custom diamond and pearl crown designed by MIKIMOTO, valued at $200,000
* A year long salary as MISS USA
* Opportunity to represent the USA at the 2006 MISS UNIVERSE Pageant
* Personal appearance wardrobe
* A New York City apartment for the year of her reign including living expenses
* Official MISS USA pearl tiara, valued at $17,500 from Mikimoto
* A $5,000 cash prize and year supply of COVERGIRL cosmetics
* A swimsuit wardrobe from BSC SWIMSUIT THAILAND
* A custom designed wardroe by TADASHI
* A two-year scholarship from The School for Film and Television in New York City valued at $60,000
* A 4 day/ 3 night "All Inclusive" vacation from AMERICAN AIRLINES
* A $3,000 cash prize and a shoe wardrobe from Steve Madden
* A year supply of haircare by FAROUK SYSTEMS
* A one-time, speaking role on NBC's Passions
* Personal services including a year-long membership to Reebok and year-long pampering at New York City's John Barrett Salon
* Modeling portfolio by leading New York City fashion photographer Fadil Berisha
* Casting opportunities and professional representation by the Miss Universe Organization
* Extensive travel opportunities with a personal travel manager representing sponsors and charitable partners
* Access to various New York City events including movie premiers and screenings, Broadway shows and launch parties
* A professional CD Rom of interviews and appearances
* Consultation with stylist Billie Causieestko and access to an event wardrobe from leading fashion designers.
* Professional public relations media training
* Professional media/public relations representation by Rubenstein Public Relations and Planet PR in New York City
* Year-long dermatology services provided by Dr. Cheryl Thellman-Karcher


I guess selling your soul to Trump isn't such a bad idea after all. I mean, you basically get treated like a goddess for a year, so long as you remain discreet about your sexual habits and refrain from letting people take nude pix of you for a year.

After that, of course, all bets are off.

It's just funny that we hold our celebrities, no matter how minor, to these puritanical roles, expecting them to be bright, beautiful, perky and squeaky-clean 24 hours a day, 7 days a week when most of us would prefer a girl who likes to fuck to a girl who's got "all-American" values. Can't we get past this madonna/whore dichotomy in all its many guises? Beauty queens aren't so different from the rest of us ladies (except maybe in their awesome beauty and equally awesome bimbosity). Undoubtedly, they like to get shagged rotten, too. So why should we put them on pedestals and expect them to behave like angels? Because we're giving them money and material possessions that only supernatural beings deserve?

I think I see the problem. We're trying to make gods out of mortals again, and when our mortals fail, we're pissed off. We want to live vicariously through them, to attain that state of grace we don't think we've got the ability to achieve for ourselves. So we nominate our best, our brightest, our tallest, our skinniest, our best-looking-in-a-swimsuitiest and when that girl goes out drinking and vomits like the rest of us, we're understandably affronted.

The problem is that a beauty queen is just that: she is beautiful, but she is not a goddess. I wonder what would happen if we all started to realize that these idols we manufacture are just ordinary human beings? Would we still pin pictures of these lovely ladies up on our walls and aspire to be like them? Probably. They're beautiful, after all, and just being good looking goes a long way in North American society. We'd have to start expecting these girls to solve the world's problems before anything really revolutionary started to happen.

 

Previous

PAGE: 

1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5

Next

Comments
Roethke

Roethke

SUICIDEGIRL

California, USA

DEC 19, 2006 12:00 PM

I'm shocked that everyone has managed to work up so much ire over this. Shocked!

apesamongus

apesamongus

Atlanta, GA
July 2002

DEC 19, 2006 12:06 PM

bean said:

FridgeMagnet said:
The simple fact is that she entered a contest that had certain RULES, and she no doubt signed a form that said she would adhere to those RULES. She didn't, she got caught, and there may be...wait for it..consequences. OH NOES1

If I enter into a boxing match and bring a lead pipe with me into the ring and hit my opponent with the lead pipe. I'll be disqualified, it isn't because the governing body of boxing hates lead, or pipes, it's just that, you know, I broke the fucking rules.


What sort of logic states that one can't criticize rules one disagrees with, simply because the participants agreed to those rules?

Oh, that's right, it's the same logic that says we shouldn't criticize the "Don't ask/Don't tell" policy of the military, because members of the military agreed to those policies when they signed up.

If baseball had a rule that the national champions would be stripped of their title if they didn't live up to some silly and arbitrary measure of "being a good influence," one might consider that rule a wee bit...idealistic, and one would be perfectly right to question the place that rule had in the sport.

I couldn't give two shits about the Miss USA pageant, and I'm opposed to beauty pageants in general, but there's nothing wrong with criticizing its rules.


+1

And really, there's a big difference between a rule that limits behavior during a competition or in ways that can affect the results of a competition and rules about how someone behaves in their private life totally unconnected with the competition and even after the damn thing is completely over. Add to that the stupid message it sends and it's a downright bad rule to begin with.

FridgeMagnet

FridgeMagnet

Chicago, IL
November 2004

DEC 19, 2006 02:03 PM

PointBlank said:

FridgeMagnet said:
This is like saying that, Manny Ramirez was called out after 3 strikes in a baseball game because he's Dominican.



Except that she didn't break any specific rules. Don't pretend like it's not a judgement call on Trump's part.

So, unless you can cite the specific rule that she broke,

Miss USA organizers declined to hand over a list of rules for their titleholder, but said she had to be a role model.


which is the same as the three strike rule in baseball, you should probably save the terrible analogies.



1) How do you know she didn't?

2) Nice try but get off your high horse. She signed papers with contest rules, if she broke them Trump can can her. If she can legally prove that she was not made aware of specific rules that she is being penalized for after the fact, she'll have a valid grievance.

Cigarette

Cigarette

Cleveland, OH
April 2004

DEC 19, 2006 03:55 PM

BTW I just got the Miss Ogyny joke
OMGWTF

Huck

Huck

United Kingdom
July 2004

DEC 20, 2006 03:45 AM

what's the point of it all?

i think a 21st-century beauty pageant should include a Daintiest Live Shitting challenge.

Huck

Huck

United Kingdom
July 2004

DEC 20, 2006 03:48 AM

p.s. why not argue that she's a "role model" for young women who drink responsibly, ha

apologees

apologees

Antarctica
February 2003

DEC 20, 2006 09:51 PM

I love watching the 24 hour news networks cover this. Inevitably, they have an ex-beauty queen and some ivy leaguer female reporter in her early to mid 30s. Whenever they are on camera at the same time, you can see the disgust in the reporter's eyes every time the beauty queen opens her mouth. Pure hatred. Its so awesome.

AceT

AceT

Portland, OR
April 2004

DEC 22, 2006 02:21 AM








AMERICA! Fuck yeah!

AceT

AceT

Portland, OR
April 2004

DEC 22, 2006 02:28 AM

All 23 uncensored pics...

PointBlank

PointBlank

New York, NY
November 2004

DEC 22, 2006 07:31 AM

^^^Errr, thats a different girl. That's Miss Nevada, who had her title stripped. Those are also pictures of her when she was underaged.

Miss_Noise

Miss_Noise

Canada
August 2010

SEP 17, 2010 09:35 PM

the thing that makes me laugh is being a role model to someone should be about what you look like it should be about who you are be proud of yourself and respectful, posing nude does NOT mean you dont respect yourself, it means quite the opposite. And in all reality lets put things into perspective Marilyn monroe is looked up to as a role model to this day and she was the first ever playboy centerfold, also prostitution is one of the OLDEST professions in the world, I know times have changed but really who are these peope that call themselves judges?! shouldnt we be changing with the times too, its called evolution!

TheFuckOffKid

TheFuckOffKid

NEWSWIRE

Australia

SEP 17, 2010 10:50 PM

For a moment I thought the new Newswire had gotten interesting again.

Thistle

Thistle

SUICIDEGIRL

California, USA

SEP 18, 2010 05:44 PM

Miss_Noise said:
Marilyn monroe is looked up to as a role model to this day and she was the first ever playboy centerfold



Anyone who considers Marilyn a role model needs to seriously re-evaluate. I am a huge Marilyn Monroe fan but there is no part of her life anyone should ever try to emulate.

Lemonkid

Lemonkid

Canada
May 2003

SEP 18, 2010 07:35 PM

Who cares? Next.

Cash

Cash

USA
OLD SKOOL

SEP 19, 2010 07:51 AM

Miss_Noise said:
the thing that makes me laugh is being a role model to someone should be about what you look like it should be about who you are be proud of yourself and respectful, posing nude does NOT mean you dont respect yourself, it means quite the opposite. And in all reality lets put things into perspective Marilyn monroe is looked up to as a role model to this day and she was the first ever playboy centerfold, also prostitution is one of the OLDEST professions in the world, I know times have changed but really who are these peope that call themselves judges?! shouldnt we be changing with the times too, its called evolution!



The only people that pageant models are role models to.....are OTHER pageant models.

These pageants are about one thing and one thing only.....making money. They make money on image.....and the image of a pageant queen is that of the wholesome, All-American Girl.

If you fuck with the image...you fuck with the ability to make money. If you fuck with the money...you lose the crown.

It's not meant to be fair, or righteous...or about anything other than making money.

Previous

PAGE: 

1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5

Next