• news
  • SUNDAY SEPTEMBER 24 2006 4:00 PM

Godless Kiddie Show Rankles T.V. Watchdogs

Children’s sensation VeggieTales has gone Hollywood... and lost its religion.

The popular Christian-themed series featuring Bob the Tomato and Larry the Cucumber recently started airing on NBC, but the network has edited out the show’s many references to God.

Not surprisingly, the changes brought a strong response from the watchdog group Parents Television Council.

"What struck me and continues to strike me is the inanity of ripping the heart and soul out of a successful product and not thinking that there will be consequences to it," said L. Brent Bozell, president of the Parents Television Council.


NBC defends the edits, saying in a statement that they don’t want to push one religion over another. (The VeggieTales video God Wants Me to Forgive Them?! didn’t tip them off?)

"NBC is committed to the positive messages and universal values of 'VeggieTales,' " the statement said. "Our goal is to reach as broad an audience as possible with these positive messages, while being careful not to advocate any one religious point of view."


As for the show’s creator, Phil Vischer, he says the show is Christian, should be Christian, and he wouldn’t have made the lucrative deal if he’d known about the edits. Phil, meet the turnip truck you fell off of.

Of course, the better question is, why expose your children to religion when you can expose them to great music, courtesy of SpongeBob Squarepants? A new "concept album" inspired by the yellow, undie-wearing sponge has pulled in a few top-notch musicians: Brian Wilson, Tommy Ramone, cult favorite NRBQ, Tex-Mex icon Flaco Jimenez, Mandy Barnett, acclaimed guitarist James Burton and multi-instrumentalist Corky Hale, whose career credits include playing with Billie Holiday, Tony Bennett and Frank Sinatra.


Meet God's veggies

 

Previous

PAGE: 

1 | 2

Next

Comments
mitchclem

mitchclem

San Antonio, TX
August 2005

SEP 24, 2006 04:38 PM

And nerds are upset that the Transformers don't look like they used to in the upcoming movie. Tell the Christians to get in line if they want to whine about unfaithful adaptations in Hollywood.

soft_shoulder

soft_shoulder

Madison, WI
May 2006

SEP 24, 2006 04:40 PM

i <3 veggie tales

mattereaterlad

mattereaterlad

Seattle, WA
February 2003

SEP 24, 2006 04:58 PM

They have every right to put the religious aspects into it. I just chose not to let my son watch it because it had to attach Christianity to morals, instead of just letting them be morals. But, people are welcome to make crap, even religious crap, it's a free country.

I actually got a kick out of smoking a bowl and watching vegetalbes talk about Jesus, though. (After the kids went to bed, of course)

Vaille

Vaille

Farmington, NM
December 2005

SEP 24, 2006 04:59 PM

I scanned through, read "L. Brent Bozell", and sighed.

Eta

Eta

Portland, OR
November 2005

SEP 24, 2006 05:04 PM

For some reason, this reminds me of when the Christian company Clean Flicks started putting out DVDs of Hollywood films with all the nudity, sex, and profanity edited out. In a way, it's funny that the Christians are getting a taste of their own medicine and they don't like it. On the other hand, I don't think anybody's work should be edited without their permission. By the way, I love Veggie Tales; I think it's adorable and the writing is very funny. But I think it would be more appropriate for NBC if it weren't Christian.

OctEgon

OctEgon

Tustin, CA
July 2005

SEP 24, 2006 05:44 PM

It's a shame that the series about the Jewish Pork Products (The Hambergs) never gained a following like Veggie Tales before being cancelled.

It was way ahead of it's time.

Bombastic

Bombastic

I'm lost
June 2006

SEP 24, 2006 05:51 PM

Waitaminute. Does anyone really think putting religion in a kids show is a good idea? I certainly don't. I expect the kind of television that caters to its audience. I don't think it's appropriate to show to those whose mental acuity is not at the point where they can be responsible for what they're watching. Be it religion, sex, violence or other major influencing factors on a person's behaviour, children have a tendency, I think, to ape what they see rather than consider its validity and making a choice as to whether or not they believe it.

I do not want our children blindly apeing religion. We've all seen what religion without reason has caused.

crispy

crispy

NEWSWIRE

Philadelphia, PA

SEP 24, 2006 06:03 PM

cgilbe1

cgilbe1

Cambridge, MA
OLD SKOOL

SEP 24, 2006 06:06 PM

Bombast said:
children have a tendency, I think, to ape what they see rather than consider its validity and making a choice as to whether or not they believe it.

I do not want our children blindly apeing religion. We've all seen what religion without reason has caused.



so you want them blindly apeing secular humanism?

The whole notion of holding out until children could theoretically "choose" has, perhaps, noble intentions--but it is making a value judgment FOR children just as much as "pushing" religion on them does.

I just think it's silly that NBC picked up the show without figuring out the whole premise of the thing is christian.

i do find it enjoyable that now the conservative chrsitians are (finally!) getting a taste of their own censorship medicine.

Hooraydiation

Hooraydiation

Boston, MA
October 2005

SEP 24, 2006 06:45 PM

You'd think they'd be happy that Christian values (as if other groups don't share similar or the same values) were being brought to children who, due to being raised in non-Christian households, would otherwise have missed out on Veggie Tales. But I guess teaching kids to be decent human beings isn't worth a thing if they don't become Christian in the process.

Bombastic

Bombastic

I'm lost
June 2006

SEP 24, 2006 07:16 PM

cgilbe1 said:
so you want them blindly apeing secular humanism?



I don't want them blindly apeing anything. Unfortunately, they do. So we need to be careful what they're exposed to or else mitigate their exposure with proper parental support, which I would not credit most parents with being able to provide.

We can't choose to show children everything and we can't choose to show children nothing. And the argument will persist.

schoolboyjones

schoolboyjones

Brooklyn, NY
December 2004

SEP 25, 2006 05:09 AM

Bombast said:
I don't want them blindly apeing anything.



I understand your intentions and they're good, but kids blindly ape. It's what they do. It's how they learn, up until a certain point when the higher cognitive functions kick in and their analytical skills grow to a practically useful level.

As parents, what we don't want is all that happening in a vacuum. While we have unquestioned authority over their development, it's our responsibility to choose what they blindly ape, so that the values we want to pass on to them become as deep a part of their character as possible.

Given all that, I'd much rather they blindly ape a show with a true Christian message (love, forgiveness, generosity, peace, faith, optimism, inclusivity) than something that merely flashes and bleeps at them and sedates them with stimuli. Or, worse, the crap I grew up watching. (G.I. Joe anyone?)

(And if you're worried about the decidedly un-Christian stuff that often gets lumped in with Christianity - intolerance, judgmentalism, exclusivity, arrogance - well, that too falls under the above statement about kids not growing up in a vacuum. Parents gotta do some work. That's how we change the world for the better.)

Markus001

Markus001

United Kingdom
November 2004

SEP 25, 2006 06:25 AM

It's a shame Christianity gets such a bad rep, really.

It takes a few fanatics to ruin it for the rest of us. *sigh* But for me, a Veggie Tales movie will not be any good unless there's a reprise of the I LOVE MY LIPS song. It's perfect for stoners and drunkards alike.

Solaris

Solaris

SUICIDEGIRL

British Columbia, Canada

SEP 25, 2006 10:33 AM

even though i hated veggie-tales and disliked their preachiness... it makes me sort of sad that they're stripping the religion out of it. was that not it's essence? seems like a loss, somehow...

Drake

Drake

SUICIDEGIRL

I'm lost

SEP 25, 2006 02:04 PM

Hooraydiation said:
But I guess teaching kids to be decent human beings isn't worth a thing if they don't become Christian in the process.



Hah, yeah.

I think the "heart and soul" of Veggie Tales will remain, they're just editing out the product placement.

Previous

PAGE: 

1 | 2

Next