BLOG VIEW  |  HEADLINE VIEW
SUBMIT NEWS  |  RSS FEED  |  SEARCH

Romeo Not So Romantic

FRIDAY FEBRUARY 17 2006 1:00 PM

Submitted by dem_z. Edited By crispy.

Kissing, probably an important part of a romantic play like "Romeo and Juliet", has been banned in Wales (and soon the rest of the UK) in new advice from the Welsh Assembly.

The advice, which could soon be extended to the rest of the UK, says love scenes between pupils should "stop at a peck on the cheek to protect youngsters from abuse".

It goes on: "Drama teachers must cut or adapt plays if they have to in order to protect children and young people. They should not rely on arguments about the artistic integrity of the text."


I'm not the biggest Shakespeare fan, but I'd hesitate to start chopping bits out.

You can imagine how some people feel about messing around with the texts of one of the greatest writers.

However, Margaret Higgins, of the National Association for the Teaching of Drama, told the Times Educational Supplement: "You can't just cut out scenes like the kiss in Romeo and Juliet. It is a crucial moment."


I'm sure that people in Wales won't mind about the pisspoor state of the health service so long as ministers are concentrating on the important stuff.

 

Previous

PAGE: 

1 | 2

Next

sixbysix

sixbysix

United Kingdom
December 2004

FEB 17, 2006 01:06 PM

I always thought all that death in Macbeth was rather too distressing for kids... couldn't Duncan have gone and lived on a farm in Dorset instead?

TheFly

TheFly

Eagle Springs, NC
November 2003

FEB 17, 2006 02:22 PM

And I hear all the swordsplay in Hamlet must be done with Nerf Products. And all language must be changed for the modern era.


"Out, Out, silly spot!"

I thought stuff like this only happened in America.

alpha_hazard

alpha_hazard

Fort Collins, CO
April 2004

FEB 17, 2006 02:23 PM

"Then let lips do what hands do" does not imply a high five or a hand shake.

It's good to know that the US isn't the only place in the world with wacky laws regarding intimate contact.

I imagine that there will be a new version of "The Complete works of William Shakespeare: Abridged" focusing entirely on kissing, just as a nice little protest.

calami00

calami00

I'm lost
November 2005

FEB 17, 2006 03:27 PM

gaddamn kids, its all their fault being all vulnerable and shit. Why cant they just get some mutant powers already. God!

chilung

chilung

Australia
April 2005

FEB 17, 2006 03:33 PM

I suppose the next thing is to remove every smutty reference in Shakespeare. After all it is high art. One should remember to clap politely after each soliloquy and other than that to sit there quietly through out each scene...
puke
idiots

Sivart

Sivart

Saskatoon, SK
June 2004

FEB 17, 2006 04:18 PM

i don't see a problem with limiting shakespearean plays to a peck on the cheek. if anything it would be returning to the original artistic integrity of the text. at that time, a peck on the cheek was a huge public display of affection, and anything more than that was unthinkable. also, originally, all acting was done by men, and considering the heavy christian influence at the time, i doubt men were kissing other men on the lips back then.

i think the idea makes sense. of course, some nutjob is bound to want to push it so far that there can't even be physical contact between genders...

whitepuma

whitepuma

Australia
March 2004

FEB 17, 2006 04:27 PM

Hmmm let me see so kids can see ppl including their parents kiss let alone anything else related to sex, romance and love just as long as its not in a drama class as it is the drama class that will corupt their inocent mines.

Plz come one who are these small minded fuckwits that dont have a clue. Can someone tell me whats wrong with the worlds leaders today. They say they are in touch with the ppl but how about pulling their heads out of their asses and coming out of those nice big flash offices and spending some time in the real world with the youth of today so that they get a feel for the way society has changed since they were kids.

Cairo

Cairo

SUICIDEGIRL

Maryland, USA

FEB 17, 2006 04:29 PM

TheFly said:
"Out, Out, silly spot!"



This is the best thing I've heard all day.

gdarklighter

gdarklighter

San Diego, CA
August 2005

FEB 17, 2006 05:30 PM

I'm not the biggest Shakespeare fan, but I'd hesitate to start chopping bits out.



As silly as this story is, this comment is just ridiculous. Nobody performs Shakespeare without cutting. Nobody cuts out the kiss in Romeo and Juliet, but things get cut on a regular basis. Especially when you look at some of his larger works, like Henry V and Hamlet. It's also important to remember that when reading Shakespeare, the editor's intentions are as important to remember as the author's.

SimonTam

SimonTam

Oakland, CA
January 2005

FEB 17, 2006 05:58 PM

Connie Willis has an excellent and funny short story on political correctness and Shakespeare. I think it's collected in "Impossible Things".

FrankMask

FrankMask

Saint Paul, MN
June 2003

FEB 18, 2006 10:53 PM

What I remember about theatre is a lot of flirting, wrestling with girls, walking in on the female lead changing (orange panties FTW), staying out at denny's til 2AM after rehersals and cast parties that were broken up by the police.

And they want to ban a stage kiss?

anonymouse

anonymouse

Miami Beach, FL
OLD SKOOL

FEB 19, 2006 09:16 AM

Seriously, it's a fucking stage kiss. It's artifice. Your lips don't even touch in a stage kiss!

Puuck

Puuck

Brandon, FL
February 2006

FEB 19, 2006 09:36 AM

I don't see the problem in limiting the contact. It IS the school's responsibility to "protect" children, and PDA so to speak has always been one of the behaviors limited by school systems to keep them in line. There could be diseases. Kids could take all the "kissing" the wrong way.

Now don't go calling me a party pooper. I'm not saying I think it's necessary . . Just within the rights of the government and a valid concern for a bunch of old british people in charge of millions of young kids.

As far as artistic integrity goes .. Just don't edit the play. Fake a kiss. Kiss on the cheek. The audience will know why you're not making out up there.


It's not a big deal for either side. If kids want to kiss each other at drama club, they're going to do it whether or not it's banned.

They're just not going to do it on stage.

And that will keep everyone who could possibly object quiet.

Iseult

Iseult

United Kingdom
September 2005

FEB 19, 2006 09:47 AM

I played Juliet in a school play when I was 13 and even though I couldn't stand the lad who played Romeo, I still wouldn't have cut the kissing out; it's too important. The kisses aren't supposed to be full-on snogs anyway, so I really don't see the problem.

Jstone

Jstone

Victoria, BC
November 2004

FEB 19, 2006 09:55 AM

*punches Juliet in shoulder*
"take 'er easy eh?"
*slaps Romeo on the ass
"yeah good hustle out there"
surreal

Previous

PAGE: 

1 | 2

Next

Palin: A Perfect Train Wreck

Last Comment 1 HR

This really didn't fit anwhere else... (video) More ...

Vampires: State of the Genre Report

Last Comment 1 HR

oh, whups, i misread. yeah, i hope that's handled well in the show; Pam's great. and for the record,... More ...

Food Coma: What The Fuck Is Ethnic Food?

Last Comment 2 HR

Once again, I fucking LOVE these articles, and concur completely. Shut up and eat! Food is good, and... More ...

Biden Palin I

Last Comment 4 HR by MisterLinguist

Biden Palin I

Last Comment 4 HR

Makes you wanna drink beer with the Mavericks. Damn cool! More ...

Yes, Canada Had a Debate, Too!

Last Comment 22 HR

I understand that... I think it is pure pedantry to pretend to be a fan of a language or a culture: "I... More ...

SuicideGirls Interview: Terry Gilliam
SuicideGirls Interview: Marty Krofft
SuicideGirls Interview: David Mamet