• news
  • WEDNESDAY JANUARY 11 2006 7:16 AM

Publisher Says It Doesn't Care If Frey Made It Up

Earlier this week, The Smoking Gun website published an article detailing the apparent lies that permeate the "non-fiction" best seller "A Million Little Pieces" by James Frey. According to TSG, Frey's graphic and often wrenching memoir of drug addiction and criminal exploits "wholly fabricated or wildly embellished details."

Frey appears to have fictionalized his past to propel and sweeten the book's already melodramatic narrative and help convince readers of his malevolence. "I was a bad guy," Frey told [Oprah] Winfrey. "If I was gonna write a book that was true, and I was gonna write a book that was honest, then I was gonna have to write about myself in very, very negative ways." That is repeatedly apparent in his memoir, which announces, "I am an Alcoholic and I am a drug Addict and I am a Criminal." It is an incantation he repeats eight times in the book, always making sure to capitalize the 'c' in Criminal.

But he has demonstrably fabricated key parts of the book, which could--and probably should--cause a discerning reader (and [Oprah] Winfrey has ushered millions of them Frey's way) to wonder what is true in "A Million Little Pieces" and its sequel, "My Friend Leonard."


Frey responded to the claims that he has really spent no more than a few hours in jail and has never been charged with any serious crimes by saying:

So let the haters hate, let the doubters doubt, I stand by my book, and my life, and I won’t dignify this bullshit with any sort of further response.


And today, Doubleday, the publisher of A Million Little Pieces, has essentially said it doesn't care whether the allegations, or the books, are true or not.

"Memoir is a personal history whose aim is to illuminate, by way of example, events and issues of broader social consequence," said a statement issued by Doubleday and Anchor Books, the divisions of Random House Inc. that published the book in hardcover and paperback, respectively. "By definition, it is highly personal. In the case of Mr. Frey, we decided 'A Million Little Pieces' was his story, told in his own way, and he represented to us that his version of events was true to his recollections.

"Recent accusations against him notwithstanding, the power of the overall reading experience is such that the book remains a deeply inspiring and redemptive story for millions of readers."

As far as the charges, which were made by the Smoking Gun Web site, "This is not a matter that we deem necessary for us to investigate," said Alison Rich, a spokeswoman for Doubleday and Anchor Books.


There have been differing responses throughout the rest of the publishing industry, with some concerned about integrity, and others agreeing that "memoirs" are often a blend of fact and fiction. Readers, too (and there are 3.5 million of them, according to book sales) are reacting with mixed emotions - some are outraged that they believed this gritty tale, others are fiercely defending Frey, and some have shrugged: fact or fiction, it's a damn good story.

UPDATE: Random House is now offering a refund to any consumer who bought "A Million Little Pieces" directly from them. It is also suggesting that those who bought it from book stores should attempt to return to the stores for a refund.

Only a small portion of consumers buy books directly from publishers. However, the agent said Random House normally sells books to consumers as nonrefundable but is offering refunds on Frey's book "because of the controversy surrounding it."

Random House subsequently issued a statement saying it was standard procedure to offer refunds. Bookseller Barnes & Noble Inc. also said it is standard practice to offer refunds for returned books.

 

Previous

PAGE: 

1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5

Next

Comments
Salome

Salome

SUICIDEGIRL

Illinois, USA

JAN 11, 2006 07:18 AM

I've never understood what drives people like Frey, or Jayson Blair, or those columnists who made up crap in their columns and had their careers ruined for it. You like making shit up? WRITE FICTION and leave the journalism to the people who know what they're doing.

ephotojunkie

ephotojunkie

Moscow, ID
May 2004

JAN 11, 2006 07:24 AM

Salome said:
I've never understood what drives people like Frey, or Jayson Blair, or those columnists who made up crap in their columns and had their careers ruined for it. You like making shit up? WRITE FICTION and leave the journalism to the people who know what they're doing.



I agree, leave journalism to people who know how not to get caught making shit up.

PointBlank

PointBlank

New York, NY
November 2004

JAN 11, 2006 07:31 AM

Salome said:
I've never understood what drives people like Frey, or Jayson Blair, or those columnists who made up crap in their columns and had their careers ruined for it. You like making shit up? WRITE FICTION and leave the journalism to the people who know what they're doing.


The thing is, he did write fiction. He originally submitted nearly the same story as a work of fiction, but it was rejected everywhere (one look at his writing, and you'll see why). So he took out some bits, claimed the rest was all true, and what do you know? Instant celebrity.

shacolwal

shacolwal

Waite Park, MN
February 2004

JAN 11, 2006 08:13 AM

This is crazy.

g_whiz

g_whiz

Hollywood, FL
October 2004

JAN 11, 2006 08:24 AM

Who gives a fuck? What, you're going to feel betrayed because you believed the story? Grow up.

The guy's not reporting the news, he's writing a story.

Ths Smoking Gun should be embarrased to be making such a big deal about it. Their motivation is highly questionable. It seems to be more about making a name (and free advertising) for themselves than any 'concern' for the public.

PointBlank

PointBlank

New York, NY
November 2004

JAN 11, 2006 08:26 AM

g_whiz said:
Who gives a fuck? What, you're going to feel betrayed because you believed the story? Grow up.

The guy's not reporting the news, he's writing a story.

Ths Smoking Gun should be embarrased to be making such a big deal about it. Their motivation is highly questionable. It seems to be more about making a name (and free advertising) for themselves than any 'concern' for the public.


Uhh...they're reporting the news, not writing a story.

trocc

trocc

Chicago, IL
March 2003

JAN 11, 2006 08:29 AM

PointBlank said:

Salome said:
I've never understood what drives people like Frey, or Jayson Blair, or those columnists who made up crap in their columns and had their careers ruined for it. You like making shit up? WRITE FICTION and leave the journalism to the people who know what they're doing.


The thing is, he did write fiction. He originally submitted nearly the same story as a work of fiction, but it was rejected everywhere (one look at his writing, and you'll see why). So he took out some bits, claimed the rest was all true, and what do you know? Instant celebrity.



is this true? has he said this somewhere?

PointBlank

PointBlank

New York, NY
November 2004

JAN 11, 2006 08:32 AM

trocc said:

PointBlank said:

Salome said:
I've never understood what drives people like Frey, or Jayson Blair, or those columnists who made up crap in their columns and had their careers ruined for it. You like making shit up? WRITE FICTION and leave the journalism to the people who know what they're doing.


The thing is, he did write fiction. He originally submitted nearly the same story as a work of fiction, but it was rejected everywhere (one look at his writing, and you'll see why). So he took out some bits, claimed the rest was all true, and what do you know? Instant celebrity.



is this true? has he said this somewhere?


From the article:

According to a February 2003 New York Observer story by Joe Hagan, Frey originally tried to sell the book as a fictional work, but the Talese imprint "declined to publish it as such." A retooled manuscript, presumably with all the fake stuff excised, was published in April 2003 amid a major publicity campaign.

trocc

trocc

Chicago, IL
March 2003

JAN 11, 2006 08:37 AM

ok - wow. it seems that alone should be enough to keep him from protesting too much. funny stuff, i think. i wonder how Oprah has reacted?

g_whiz

g_whiz

Hollywood, FL
October 2004

JAN 11, 2006 08:38 AM

PointBlank said:

g_whiz said:
Who gives a fuck? What, you're going to feel betrayed because you believed the story? Grow up.

The guy's not reporting the news, he's writing a story.

Ths Smoking Gun should be embarrased to be making such a big deal about it. Their motivation is highly questionable. It seems to be more about making a name (and free advertising) for themselves than any 'concern' for the public.


Uhh...they're reporting the news, not writing a story.



Fray wrote a story. It's not news.

And incidentally, I don't think anyone could confuse what the smoking gun produces as news.

[Edited on Jan 11, 2006 11:45AM]

mamet

mamet

Charleston, SC
March 2005

JAN 11, 2006 08:38 AM

g_whiz said:
Who gives a fuck? What, you're going to feel betrayed because you believed the story? Grow up.



Wait, are you trying to say that someone is immature if they value honesty?

MsStabby

MsStabby

I'm lost
November 2005

JAN 11, 2006 08:40 AM

I wouldn't be surprised if Frey's next step is to capitalize on his fake non-fiction/fictionalized truth ala "Shattered Glass" (great movie btw). He could write the screenplay about a troubled moderately talented writer prone to overstatement with an addictions history who just could not crack the world of competitve fiction, so he calls it memoir and BINGO! hits the jackpot. Academy awards all around.

who would play Frey?


[Edited on Jan 11, 2006 by skooter]

g_whiz

g_whiz

Hollywood, FL
October 2004

JAN 11, 2006 08:42 AM

mamet said:

g_whiz said:
Who gives a fuck? What, you're going to feel betrayed because you believed the story? Grow up.



Wait, are you trying to say that someone is immature if they value honesty?



No I'm saying they're immature if the feel betrayed.

MissTyrios

misstyrios

NEWSWIRE

Allston, MA

JAN 11, 2006 08:42 AM

I am curious to know if book sales have gone up in the past few days just becuase of the headlines.

PointBlank

PointBlank

New York, NY
November 2004

JAN 11, 2006 08:43 AM

g_whiz said:

PointBlank said:

g_whiz said:
Who gives a fuck? What, you're going to feel betrayed because you believed the story? Grow up.

The guy's not reporting the news, he's writing a story.

Ths Smoking Gun should be embarrased to be making such a big deal about it. Their motivation is highly questionable. It seems to be more about making a name (and free advertising) for themselves than any 'concern' for the public.


Uhh...they're reporting the news, not writing a story.



Freay wrote a story. It's not news.


Ummm....you don't know what you're talking about. Frey's story was sold as nonfiction, was a number one bestseller because he claimed it was nonfiction, made the author very rich because it was nonfiction. Finding out that it was made up is certainly news. By any definition.

Previous

PAGE: 

1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5

Next