• commentary
  • SATURDAY AUGUST 4 2007 8:00 PM

Dear Scarlett Johansson: Please Don't Suck



So I know I usually like to post about evil celebretards (or 'trons, or 'sters, depending) and the media outlets who fellate them as part of an evil government conspiracy to keep us from reading about the war in Iraq. But unlike most celebrities, whom I view as wasteful black holes sucking in air, water, cocaine, and plastic surgery that they do not deserve, I actually kind of like Scarlett Johansson. Though I'm a little annoyed at all the media exclamations of "OMG, she can actually act!" (isn't that what an actress is supposed to be able to do?) and "OMG she's not stupid!", she seems to have kept it fairly down-to-earth over the years, and The Island aside, she generally picks roles that (a) don't suck, and (b) highlight her particular talents. In the movie Ghost World, she did a great job helping to bring one of my favorite graphic novels to life in a way that didn't totally butcher it. And Lost in Translation, a masterpiece of quiet longing and irony, cemented her as every indie film lover's fantasy girlfriend and/or friend-girl.

Which is why I'm a little wary of her imminent album. As reported by Pitchfork:


Apparently, her album is being produced by David Sitek of TV on the Radio and features members of the Yeah Yeah Yeahs and Celebration!!!


And what's the movie star's music going to sound like?


Like a theater, big screen. Lots of heavy bass tones in it. Without a bass guitar, we used all kind of different instruments to create these sounds. It was a great experiment. Very avant garde. She sounds like Marilyn Monroe.


--Dockside Studio Owner Steve Nails

So in addition to her forthcoming Tom Waits cover album (which I'm not even going to touch), she's got this avant-garde thing that sounds simultaneously like TVOTR, the Yeah Yeah Yeahs, a movie theater, and Marilyn Monroe. Like many indie nerds, I am both excited and terribly, terribly frightened. On the one hand, I like all of those things separately, and it proves once again that the broad's got taste. But what if all the aforementioned elements (indie rock, movie theater, Scarlett Monroe) combine into a muddy hodgepodge that ruins each of its component parts? I mean, I like pickles and I like shakes, but a pickle flavored shake would just be awful.

Please know what you're doing, Scarlett Johansson. These are powerful forces you're playing with here. You could make the record of every nerd's dreams, mixing chocolate-coated awesome with your sexy, sexy intelligence to create something that will give people mind-blowing orgasms as soon as it enters their earholes. Or you could fail miserably and get yourself and your collaborators mocked by the very same people who used to praise you. They will say, "Silly Scarlett, musical crossovers are for egomaniacal, washed up, looks-fading hotties like Jared Leto."
I'm scared...I want to keep liking you! In any case, I'm excited to hear how it sounds. Maybe I'll even mix up a pickle shake for the occasion.

 

Previous

PAGE: 

1 | 2 | 3 | 4

Next

Comments
SmellsLikeSciFi

SmellsLikeSciFi

Houston, TX
April 2004

AUG 04, 2007 09:52 PM

She'd be even hotter if she didn't sell herself for Louis Vuitton and Chanel and shit.

nice_pun_bro

nice_pun_bro

Irvine, CA
January 2007

AUG 04, 2007 10:40 PM

Is there any way some deity can keep her from doing that Tom Waits cover album? I don't care if the Flying Spaghetti Monster has to descend on a cloud and swallow the recording studio, something must be done to prevent this upcoming tragedy.

78walk

78walk

Oklahoma City, OK
July 2005

AUG 04, 2007 11:13 PM

There's virutally no chance I will find Scarlett's music listenable. But I like her very much as an actress, so I will turn a deaf ear and let it slide...

_Brody_

_Brody_

Cardiff By The Sea, CA
February 2007

AUG 04, 2007 11:18 PM

ardour said:
She was in a Justin Timberlake video. A BAD video. Well, I think maybe it was supposed to be bad or something, because it is hilarious. I'm not a fan, so I don't know if the badness was intentional.

But yeah, after that I kind of wrote her off. Doesn't mean I can't enjoy her good work, though.


Are his video's ever good?

farva

farva

Portland, OR
November 2005

AUG 04, 2007 11:22 PM

She has an amazing voice, and usually, when you ask an artists/producer what their music sounds like, they struggle to come up with something appropriate. Rareley do things sound like they are touted beforehand. I will definitely give it a shot. I have not heard her sing, but she has a haunting voice and can probably do some amazing things with it. I trust that working with TVOTR, it wont suck.

Blaxton

Blaxton

New York, NY
September 2005

AUG 04, 2007 11:51 PM



Or you could fail miserably and get yourself and your collaborators mocked by the very same people who used to praise you.



Creativity is creativity. If she's at a point where she can do anything she wants creatively speaking, then who should try and cast a shadow on it?* I'm guilty of it at times as well, hell I wish Yellowcard never happened, but people like them (do they?**). Scarlett Johansson likes indie music, theaters, and Marilyn Monroe and she got the spark to put it all together. Good for her. And she's pretty. Good for us. Everyone should be happy that her outlet is music and movies and not doing nipple slips and endangering infants, as creative as that is (Britney Bash!).


*I am aware that the internet was in fact created for whining about things just like this, but I can't get behind it. But it's cool if you want to...because that was kind of the point I was trying to make...forget it.
**They don't.
***There is no third citation (are these called citations?) but I never want to think of pickle shakes ever again. Ralf.

claudewildman

claudewildman

Decatur, GA
June 2006

AUG 05, 2007 12:01 AM

oyaji said:
She's really not a very good actress. She's still way hot, though. And she was amazing in Lost in Translation. I have an emo crush on that movie.



Who is a good actress then? I think you have a case of the "I dont like anything that even resembles mainstream." Scarlett is a fantastic actress. If you need proof watch Match Point.


ninjatoes

ninjatoes

Newport, KY
August 2005

AUG 05, 2007 12:22 AM

eeee. I'm kinda imagining the Tracy Lords album. frown

Calamity

Calamity

SUICIDEGIRL

New York, USA

AUG 05, 2007 12:40 AM

I mean, I like pickles and I like shakes, but a pickle flavored shake would just be awful.



The reasons why i love you never cease! Also, I knew about (/am scared by) the Tom Waits thing, but I didn't know about this....

Calamity

Calamity

SUICIDEGIRL

New York, USA

AUG 05, 2007 12:41 AM

j1mdot said:
Is there any way some deity can keep her from doing that Tom Waits cover album? I don't care if the Flying Spaghetti Monster has to descend on a cloud and swallow the recording studio, something must be done to prevent this upcoming tragedy.



HAHAHAAH. yesssssss.

MrKingMob

MrKingMob

Chicago, IL
January 2003

AUG 05, 2007 12:42 AM

oyaji said:

rebelwithstyle said:

oyaji said:
She's really not a very good actress. She's still way hot, though. And she was amazing in Lost in Translation. I have an emo crush on that movie.



Who is a good actress then? I think you have a case of the "I dont like anything that even resembles mainstream." Scarlett is a fantastic actress. If you need proof watch Match Point.




I thought she kind of sucked in Match Point. Reasonable minds can differ on this, can't they? Lost in Translation was a mainstream film, backed by Miramax and shown to a wide audience. Much wider than Match Point, for example.



Yep... I'm a huuuge Scarlett aficionado and I thought she kinda blew in Match Point, too (though that didn't prevent me from enjoying the fuck out of that movie).

I hope that Scarlett's foray into music will mimic Charlotte Gainsbourg's. When you think about it, the two are kinda like the french fries = frites version of one another%u2013 well respected, sultry, barely (yet hauntingly) in the mainstream as actresses. Charlotte's last album is not what I would call groundbreaking and timeless, but because I like her for all the same reasons I like Scarlett as an actress, I musically judged it on a different (not lesser or greater) scale. In other words, my appreciation of Charlotte's music is, in many ways, a reflection of my relative appreciation of her other endeavors.

In general, boxing-in our favorite artists can only result in their eventual stagnation.

MrKingMob

MrKingMob

Chicago, IL
January 2003

AUG 05, 2007 12:45 AM

Also...

Regardless of how bad the music is, there will be videos. I can't see a downside...



but hopefully we'll all see some backside. [ wacka, wacka, wacka! ]

Jennifer_

Jennifer_

Venezuela
November 2006

AUG 05, 2007 01:34 AM

I'm tempted to say Scarlett Johansson can't act, but I've never seen her try. She never seems to have bothered to develop a detailed idea of the character she's playing; she always looks fairly vacant, bored and humourless on screen, and whenever she needs to show anger or passion, she just reuses the same trite techniques of scowling and yelling. I think part of being a good actor is realising that real people portray these emotions in so many different, subtle and nuanced ways and conveying that to the audience with understated and powerful mannerisms; something she never manages to do.

Go watch the different ways Cillian Murphy portrays his characters in The Wind That Shakes The Barley and then in Breakfast On Pluto; that is truly brilliant acting. In comparison, SJ is so painfully average that all this fuss made over her is just disappointing and a disservice to people that actually put the effort into their roles.

XamaX_is_Dead

XamaX_is_Dead

La Mesa, CA
March 2007

AUG 05, 2007 02:06 AM

I had an avacado shake once, and truth be told i kinda liked it, pickles however... well that just seems way to out there for me...

Jennifer_

Jennifer_

Venezuela
November 2006

AUG 05, 2007 02:11 AM

XamaX_is_Dead said:
I had an avacado shake once, and truth be told i kinda liked it


eeek
Who would make such a thing?

(...although I did have basil ice cream once, t'was surprisingly nice.)

Previous

PAGE: 

1 | 2 | 3 | 4

Next