SuicideGirl: Morgan
suicidegirl

Morgan will crack open that book and read for fun's sake

I’m private
 
AUGUST 9, 2011 @ 10:29 AM


Warning: this is going to be long.

This morning while trying to fall back asleep, I had thoughts swirling around in my head about various discussions online I've had/read about men approaching women and women's boundaries. I've been thinking about this a lot more than usual in the past couple of months mostly because of what was called "Elevatorgate". If you don't know of it, I'll warn you that googling it will lead to a LOT of 1000+ comment threads, though I think the best posts about it in general were at were at pandagon and Greta Christina. If you do know about it, you're probably tired of hearing about it. Long story short and probably pretty edited behind spoilers:

SPOILERS! (Click to view)
Prominent atheist/skeptic blogger Rebecca Watson goes to convention, has a discussion in which she states that a problem at conventions is men treating all women there as possible dates/sex partners, says she does not want to be approached that way at these events. A man ignores this and approaches her anyway, in an elevator at 4 a.m. In a video she VERY briefly mentions this as something not to do, not identifying the dude in question. Que hundreds of posts of people telling her she's being unreasonable. Then Richard Dawkins gets involved and those hundreds of posts become thousands of posts across numerous skeptic blogs and feminist blogs. No feminist blog post about it goes without people arguing that she was being unreasonable, a bitch, that the guy was probably just a nice guy wanting to talk, that maybe he was non-neurotypical so how dare she question his actions, etc etc. Que me knowing I shouldn't read any more of this shit but doing it anyway and walking away depressed every time.



I think I finally hit on what upset me about this the most. First I'll say that there were plenty of men who got it, who listened to the women in comment threads about this stating their boundaries (which of course were varied) and internalized it instead of arguing with every little point. But they were the vast minority. The undercurrent of almost every post saying Watson was in the wrong was that if women stated their boundaries, men would have "no place" where they were allowed to approach women. Again and again women posted about what made them uncomfortable (again, this was varied): being approached on the street while they were clearly listening to music, being stopped on the street, being approached on the subway, and yes being approached in elevators late at night. Women said that these behaviors could make them feel nervous, degraded or even scared.

And again and again the response from SO MANY MEN was "but if we can't do that when do we get to approach you for dates/sex/conversation?". Many of these men started off bemoaning the fact that they don't know what women want and what their boundaries are but then responded to women explicitly stating their boundaries by bemoaning that this limited their opportunities to approach women. But here's the thing: when they responded that way what they were saying, in my translation, was that THEY DON'T CARE that women said some behaviors make them feel nervous, degraded or afraid. They were telling the women in these threads that what is more important to them, in the end, is their "right" and entitlement to approach women. And that is horrifying and scary to me. The response when another human being says "this is hurtful to me" should generally be "oh shit, I shouldn't do that, then". It speaks to a really fucked up priority system in our society that so many of these men felt that their desire to get to know a woman trumped a woman's general right to feel safe.

There are two other common responses that bothered me, and they were:

1. Women saying Watson was over-reacting. To me this spoke to a general thought process of "this wouldn't bother me, so it shouldn't bother you". Which obviously just shows a problem with the ability to empathize. It's fine with me if being stopped on the street, being approached on the subway or even being approached in an elevator at 4 a.m. is okay with another woman. That doesn't mean it has to be okay with me.

2. Many people insisting that the Elevator Guy (and therefore almost any guy approaching a woman at any time) was probably just a genuinely nice guy with no ill intentions, and therefore Watson/women in general were over-reacting. Maybe he was a nice guy. No one involved in this can know. But here's the thing: people aren't mind-readers. I have no way of knowing whether or not a dude approaching me on the street just wants to have nice conversations or if he wants to hurt me. This is why the Schrodinger's Rapist article is such a good and important read.

Not only that but asking me to assume good faith on the part of every guy who approaches me is asking me to go against every single thing I have been taught about safety as a woman since I was young. It is teaching me to go against what society has ingrained in me. And you know what else? I can guarantee you that if I did assume good faith for every random dude and one of those dudes ended up attacking me, I would be asked why I wasn't more cautious. So I can't win here.

Anyway, that's my rant.

Previous

PAGE: 

1 | 2

Next

Comments
mkayal

mkayal

USA
October 2010

AUG 09, 2011 11:06 AM

At 4 in the morning, there should only be bakers, crooks, cops, and drunks out on the street. The dude was an idiot to try talking to someone at that hour that was a total stranger.

I see where you're coming from.

Thistle

Thistle

SUICIDEGIRL

California, USA

AUG 09, 2011 11:10 AM

If you were raped it is probably because you weren't being careful enough but if you do everything people tell you to do to protect yourself you are overreacting, living in fear, and rejecting nice men who are just trying to be friendly. Can't win.

I appreciate your posts about these issues so much. You say very succinctly a lot of things I am thinking but haven't been able to articulate.

EEdork

EEdork

Ventura, CA
June 2011

AUG 09, 2011 11:25 AM

I hope I can chime in with the idea that (my own opinion) there is a time and place for everything. And I do believe that any man, if he stopped and thought about anything but himself, would be able to key into whether or not the time was right to approach a woman. I feel that self-centeredness is a huge issue with society right now. On both sexes. I don't want to rant too much, but respect and consideration of others would fix issues like elevatorgate. Thanks. B

Allegro

Allegro

Yonkers, NY
March 2007

AUG 09, 2011 03:12 PM

This whole war has been bizarre and disheartening. Lead to good conversations in my household though.

Otoki

Otoki

SUICIDEGIRL

Minnesota, USA

AUG 09, 2011 06:47 PM

And you know what else? I can guarantee you that if I did assume good faith for every random dude and one of those dudes ended up attacking me, I would be asked why I wasn't more cautious. So I can't win here.


So well said.

Keith

Keith

Oklahoma City, OK
August 2002

AUG 09, 2011 07:45 PM

It's really sad to see, when you dig down, how little progress has actually been made in enlightening people's attitudes.

Otoki

Otoki

SUICIDEGIRL

Minnesota, USA

AUG 09, 2011 08:34 PM

Hah, I do that shit all the timetongue Sorry you couldn't join in the interview tonight. I'm looking forward to hearing yours.

hoorayparade

hoorayparade

USA
May 2006

AUG 09, 2011 10:31 PM

I have been getting pretty into this feminist stuff the past few months, although I have always had leanings, and my boyfriend just doesn't get it. His mother lied, a lot, about important things and his dad has always been kind of a player who doesn't respect women too much anyway so I have that working against me too.My venturing into this stuff,especially the subject of rape and sexual assault, has been kind of rough on us. When we talk about the stuff I have been a victim of, he lays no blame on me but he still thinks it is my responsibilty from here on out to not put myself in any situation where something could happen (ie not drink when I go out to bars without him) it seems to make no difference to him that my most significant instance occured in my home when other people were there.

It just really sucks and I want to shake him.

Otoki

Otoki

SUICIDEGIRL

Minnesota, USA

AUG 10, 2011 06:42 AM

Mostly talked about Atheism, SG's mod style, and feminism.

corinthia

corinthia

Philadelphia, PA
March 2005

AUG 10, 2011 10:33 AM

I've always wondered why the hell men even bother wasting their time by approaching women on the street. Do they expect to start a relationship that way? Has it worked for them, or anyone they know, in the past? I've never heard a couple say, "Oh, we met one day on the street." I think men hitting on me on the street is the most obnoxious thing, and I've done things like not even taking off my headphones to respond to it, but just kept walking.

In fact, I have a story. Once, I was at a bus stop in center city Philly. An African American man starts hitting on me, and I tell him I'm not interested. He walks away mumbling, "Racist." As if a Caucasian man hitting on me would have had a chance! Yeah right.

jonnytrrrash7

jonnytrrrash7

Vatican City
February 2004

AUG 10, 2011 01:37 PM

will there ever be a time when i won't feel ashamed of my gender?

schiavona

schiavona

Chapel Hill, NC
July 2004

AUG 10, 2011 06:01 PM

I hope you get to come spend some time here sweetie. I miss you and would love to see you.

And now my 2 cents...Men do not, by and large, understand the fear that women women have by something as simple as being alone in an elevator later at night with a guy there. Pick any guy. I can intellectually understand the fear, sympathize, and be very sensitive to the issue when I face this (in the elevator, I would stand as far away as possible without seeming obnoxious, trying to allow this woman to have some small comfort). Anyway, I can intellectually understand this, but I cannot actually feel this fear. When I go out at night, anywhere, I'm always very cautious of my surroundings, where people are what they are doing and if they are watching me. Again, I can imagine multiplying that by 10 or 100 times, but I cannot experience that actual fear. If men, on the whole, can actually feel this way, this lack of security, this fear of simply walking out of work and to your car, then there would be a whole lot of changes in society. If that guy who whistles at you from his car was exposed to the same level of constant fear, he'd problaby have his doors looked and windows rolled up tight all the time.

Anyway, love, I'm in with you on this. it is frustrating, and if someone doesn't want to be bothered, then they should be able to say leave me alone, and be left alone.

Love , hugs and kisses as always. We miss you!
kisskiss

malkav11

malkav11

Saint Paul, MN
July 2003

AUG 11, 2011 04:02 PM

I try to apply the golden rule. I grant you that if a hot woman started hitting on me in the middle of the street that this would be entirely welcome, but in general I'd rather people not randomly approach me and try to talk to me, particularly when I am clearly doing something else - reading, for example. When I compound that with the fact that I am not wildly attractive myself and that strange men approaching women at random are automatically somewhat suspect, I tend to opt for the "keep to myself" option.

I do feel the social expectation that the man make the first move combines with this policy to close down most possibilities of actually getting a girlfriend, but at least there are venues where I can be reasonably assured people are interested in finding a partner, however unsuccessful they've been for me. (OkCupid, for example.)

_Tab

_Tab

USA
September 2004

AUG 13, 2011 01:08 PM

I've not been on SG much lately and I missed reading your journal. smile
This post reminded me of a couple things, one being a guy I used to work with at the library in undergrad who said he tries to be really aware of things like this. For example, if he's walking down the street at night and a woman is on the other side walking, he stays on his side cause he knows crossing over by her can make a girl a bit nervous. I though that was sweet of him. tongue It also reminds me of a women's self defense class I took once. The only man involved in it was a campus cop who I'm sure was a really nice guy with the best intentions, but was totally clueless to how ignorant he sounded sometimes. He would say things like "Woman might want a lamp next to the bed and think it's just some pretty little thing to have in the room, but that cord is a weapon an attacker can use on you!" I got his point, but seriously? -_-

Calico

Calico

New Zealand
April 2007

AUG 16, 2011 08:38 PM

You expressed really perfectly what I've been trying to pinpoint about my feelings on this situation.

PreviousNext
Past
SEPTEMBER 2011

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

29

30

AUGUST 2011

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

29

30

31

JULY 2011

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

29

30

31

JUNE 2011

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

29

30