This morning while trying to fall back asleep, I had thoughts swirling around in my head about various discussions online I've had/read about men approaching women and women's boundaries. I've been thinking about this a lot more than usual in the past couple of months mostly because of what was called "Elevatorgate". If you don't know of it, I'll warn you that googling it will lead to a LOT of 1000+ comment threads, though I think the best posts about it in general were at were at pandagon and Greta Christina. If you do know about it, you're probably tired of hearing about it. Long story short and probably pretty edited behind spoilers:
I think I finally hit on what upset me about this the most. First I'll say that there were plenty of men who got it, who listened to the women in comment threads about this stating their boundaries (which of course were varied) and internalized it instead of arguing with every little point. But they were the vast minority. The undercurrent of almost every post saying Watson was in the wrong was that if women stated their boundaries, men would have "no place" where they were allowed to approach women. Again and again women posted about what made them uncomfortable (again, this was varied): being approached on the street while they were clearly listening to music, being stopped on the street, being approached on the subway, and yes being approached in elevators late at night. Women said that these behaviors could make them feel nervous, degraded or even scared.
And again and again the response from SO MANY MEN was "but if we can't do that when do we get to approach you for dates/sex/conversation?". Many of these men started off bemoaning the fact that they don't know what women want and what their boundaries are but then responded to women explicitly stating their boundaries by bemoaning that this limited their opportunities to approach women. But here's the thing: when they responded that way what they were saying, in my translation, was that THEY DON'T CARE that women said some behaviors make them feel nervous, degraded or afraid. They were telling the women in these threads that what is more important to them, in the end, is their "right" and entitlement to approach women. And that is horrifying and scary to me. The response when another human being says "this is hurtful to me" should generally be "oh shit, I shouldn't do that, then". It speaks to a really fucked up priority system in our society that so many of these men felt that their desire to get to know a woman trumped a woman's general right to feel safe.
There are two other common responses that bothered me, and they were:
1. Women saying Watson was over-reacting. To me this spoke to a general thought process of "this wouldn't bother me, so it shouldn't bother you". Which obviously just shows a problem with the ability to empathize. It's fine with me if being stopped on the street, being approached on the subway or even being approached in an elevator at 4 a.m. is okay with another woman. That doesn't mean it has to be okay with me.
2. Many people insisting that the Elevator Guy (and therefore almost any guy approaching a woman at any time) was probably just a genuinely nice guy with no ill intentions, and therefore Watson/women in general were over-reacting. Maybe he was a nice guy. No one involved in this can know. But here's the thing: people aren't mind-readers. I have no way of knowing whether or not a dude approaching me on the street just wants to have nice conversations or if he wants to hurt me. This is why the Schrodinger's Rapist article is such a good and important read.
Not only that but asking me to assume good faith on the part of every guy who approaches me is asking me to go against every single thing I have been taught about safety as a woman since I was young. It is teaching me to go against what society has ingrained in me. And you know what else? I can guarantee you that if I did assume good faith for every random dude and one of those dudes ended up attacking me, I would be asked why I wasn't more cautious. So I can't win here.
Anyway, that's my rant.














PAGE:
1 | 2