Music

TOPICS:

11/14/05
11/13/05
11/12/05
11/10/05

Previous

PAGE: 

1 ... 

152 | 153 | 154

 ... 470

Next

Dr_Frank

Dr_Frank

Oakland, CA
May 2005

NOV 12, 2005 08:49 AM

Jim Testa of Jersey Beat recently wrote a good-natured but slightly snarky review of the Asbury Park Music Awards on his blog. Those who have ever followed their own local music awards will recognize the basic situation, for which Testa expresses an ironic fondness:

Asbury Park has this soft spot for frumpy, middle-aged, middle-of-the-road performers like Christine Martucci, Lance Larson, Jodi Joseph, Sonny Kenn, and Boccigalupe & The Bad Boys... and the Awards show always makes room for them. You gotta love that; it would be unthinkable for performers that far afield of trendy or stylish to be represented at a similar awards ceremony in Brooklyn or Hoboken.


One of the allegedly frumpy, middle-aged, middle-of-the-road performers, Christine Martucci, was not amused, and posted a poetic complaint on the item. The resulting exchange between Martucci and Testa and his readers is a bit like a Twilight Zone episode. Worlds collide, and neither side makes much sense to the other, but the viewer can discern an unmistakable, ironic moral: "we are not so very different, you and I." Martucci seems mystified that no one is impressed with her Dishwalla-invoking resumé, adding, "do you know I opened for Kansas?" And it's a good bet that none of the bands covered in Jersey Beat would have ever blipped on her radar. Someone has to explain to her what a Stella is.

In reference to that, Testa makes this interesting point about the different aspects of insularity on display:

One thing this debate has done is to remind me what a tiny, insular, elitist, self-referential world we indie rockers live in. There's a whole universe of people out there like Christine who believe that Dishwalla and Johnny Winter and Scandal constitute "real" music, while what "we" in the indie underground whatever community do is inconsequential noise. And in a way, they're right. When what you do reaches dozens rather than millions, it doesn't hurt to retain a little humility.

gut666

gut666

Moreno Valley, CA
April 2005

NOV 12, 2005 09:09 AM


Christine who believe that Dishwalla and Johnny Winter and Scandal constitute "real" music, while what "we" in the indie underground whatever community do is inconsequential noise.


amen to that . take that you hipster snobs.

Keith

Keith

Oklahoma City, OK
August 2002

NOV 12, 2005 09:14 AM

If being a hipster snob means I don't have to listen to Dishwalla and Johnny Winter, I don't feel so bad. tongue

Baise

Baise

USA
January 2005

NOV 12, 2005 09:27 AM

thrashmaster74 said:

Christine who believe that Dishwalla and Johnny Winter and Scandal constitute "real" music, while what "we" in the indie underground whatever community do is inconsequential noise.


amen to that . take that you hipster snobs.


Whatthefuckever.

The Velvet Underground influenced a ridiculously large portion of mainstream rock'n'roll bands of the last three decades, yet in their heyday sold very few records.

Having taste has NOTHING to do with being a hipster--hipsters listen to what they listen to because it's trendy and because they were unpopular in high school and want to feel like part of an elite crowd, not because the music genuinely moves them.

So eat me.

PointBlank

PointBlank

New York, NY
November 2004

NOV 12, 2005 09:29 AM

Jim Testa is great.

soul_fire

soul_fire

Snoqualmie, WA
January 2005

NOV 12, 2005 09:36 AM


"btw, what's Indie Underground?"

awesome.

[Edited on Nov 12, 2005 12:36PM]