the fathers of nirvana

good ole melvins, yep

like talking to a self-assured wall, and i dont care.

[Edited on Sep 23, 2004 by Sadistic_Miike]

I'm surprised the thread went as long as it did before this was mentioned.

All of you are wrong.

Black Oak Arkansas are the fathers of ALL music.

like talking to nothing at all... i stand where i do, leave me alone.

don't reply to this.


edit: hey idgit (how apropos), A NUMBER of other people mentioned other people asides from The Melvins, but you piss all over me as if I'm your whipping post... please just leave me alone, I don't have any more time for 'online rivalires', or bullshit arguements about 'the melvins'... grow up and stop using the MUSIC board to get your Grunge MENSA certificate, nobody cares.

ps. again, LEAVE ME ALONE. don't comment to this.

[Edited on Sep 23, 2004 by Sadistic_Miike]

Aren't the Pixies the Fathers Of Nirvana?

Grandfather-The Sonics
Father-The Melvins
Cool Older Siblings-The Pixies

OMG #)$(#FFF whjat #NAN TOLLL uR are2!!!111

Everbody knows:

the Monks: grandfathers
the stooges: grand pappys
the sonics: the happy medium boogie
the velvet underground: the loud boogie relative
grandfuerher: das melvins
dadddy: nerdvana
son: britney spears.


NOw stop filling up my airspace, i've got Yak's to jerk off! (for medical purposes)

you know kids, just because we maybe we differ on our oppinions in music, doesn't mean we can't hate each other in silence!

INCREASE THE PEACE YO!


[Edited on Sep 23, 2004 by Sadistic_Miike]

Green River?

Up the dosage....seriously.

it's relative to my life. not abstract, but

L'intelligence est venue apres la sttise,
laquell l'a toujours sodomisee de pres,---
ET APRES.

Ce qui donne une idee de l'infinii traject.

my apologies to the lingua Franca, no keys for those little slashes

cheers mate, just a reaction , from a post-reaction stress disorder. wolves gathering.

[Edited on Sep 23, 2004 by Sadistic_Miike]

the thing is, pretentious means, that you are pretending to be, something, anything... it's often missued, so no fault on you... pretention, is pretending.... and im not.

you know... to know the french? pretentious? no.... pretending to be 'cool', fuck that, i'm not cool, i'm a sucker, a loser, a fucking piece of shit.

Et, je te condamme parce que tu sais pourquoi.... je te condamme, ------
et moi, je ne le sais pas.

Flipper released their only true album three years before the date the Melvins claim is the time they first formed.

shut up you neophyte... just quit when you're out matched. you're nothing.

Will you two give it a rest?!
I have no idea about any of the comments you are making toward each other. Sorry - I guess I haven't been keeping current on your rivalry. At any rate, a Melvins thread is not the place for your pissing match.
Unless, of course, you guys are really friends and you're just busting each other's balls. In which case, um...carry on!

donald cobain?

um..grandfather's of NIRVANA.... the sonics. the wipers.

The thing is, i dont care! If Grandpa Munster was the kin to Nirvana I could care less.

I was just listing some influence, not trying to win double jeopardy...
Idgit just feels the need to act like a big man.

I listed the Wipers, to much discord... and The Sonics, I think the Sonics are any loud bands influence!

Well, I mean, when I think of Grandfather of Punk, I think Iggy Pop and MC5 and The Monks, but who knows... it's just my opinion. There is a definite direct connection to Nirvana & the Melvins (they did a show last night here, and I forgot to go.... ).

No, I'm quite interested in meaningful conversation, but I thought it was vauge, and a number of other people listed other bands as well. It's no problem, biggest influence, Melvins? maybe... who is to say... I think that Nirvana Bleach Era sounds a hell of a lot like Scratch Acid...

I can support my statements, but I guess I didn't fit the mold of the thread topic, I see things broader than The Melvins, who are still rocking. It doesn't matter, just a misunderstanding, and water under the bridge.

Oh, was it mentioned here or elsewhere that the fellow from The Melvins taught Kurt how to play... my sis insists he taught himself.

AHHHH MELVINS YESSSS! *bond* *bond* *bond*