Chitin said:
In Canada, is it literally not POSSIBLE to get private healthcare if you really want it?
No, lots of things are private but they're all elective/supplemental. All the fundamentals are public.
Actually, General Practitioners' offices are technically privately-run businesses that are publicly funded. That tends to be one of the arguments against public healthcare, that doctors' offices have been private for decades and it hasn't spelled the end of the system and we could allow for more private clinics and hospitals.
But the problem with that is NAFTA: if we start privatising any part of the healthcare system, we'd be obligated to let American companies set up shop too. And many of us aren't comfortable with American corporations controlling something as fundamental as healthcare. They already have Tim Horton's for chrissakes.
do you have to be a canadian citizen to recieve free healthcare?
or live there?
(i am a citizen, though i don't live there, and i was just curious)
In Ontario, at least, to be eligible for a health card (and thus public health benefits), you must::
1) Be a Canadian citizen or a landed immigrant
2) Have your primary residence in Ontario
3) Spend 5 months of the year in Ontario
I suspect most provinces have similar requirements.
My dad was booked in for an emergency stress test because he has angina...that EMERGENCY stress test only took 7 MONTHS to book....now they have to book him for an EMERGENCY angiogram....so he should have had a heart attack by the time that hapopens if last time is any indication of how long it takes.
My boyfriends Dad had been having pains in his chest for a couple of days...he went to the emergency and the doc perscribed him muscle relaxants...didn't look at his file at all...didn't take blood pressure....nothing....he died...from a reaction between a medication he was on...and the one the doc in emergency gave him!!!!
If you go to emergency where I live...it is guaranteed that you will sit there anywhere from 2-8hrs before seeing a doctor!!!!
We pay for our health care....I have HAVE to pay for my Alberta Health Care....that gets me nothing!!!!
I would much rather have private...still pay, but at least I will get something when I pay for it!!!!
from skeptik's journal:
To all those lovely people who responded to my thread on personal experiences with healthcare in Canada: your comments are much appreciated. I am presenting my report tomorrow (Mon., 4/11), and the personal aspect has been very helpful. I'll let you know how it goes.
To Arete: I hope you feel better soon, and my condolences on the loss of your grandfather. I'm glad you got to say goodbye. I have lost all 4 of my grandparents, and for one reason or another, did not get to say godbye to any of them. Makes me sad.
Update: Well, averyone, I was finally able to present my report yesterday (Wed, 4/13) and it went very well. Everyone was impressed with the personal aspect I was able to bring, thanks to all of you.
As I said before, the next time I'm in Canada, anybody who wants to meet up, gets a martini (or whatever).
Xavery, I'm sorry to hear about your experiences. If it's any consolation, things are still not that bad, comparatively. The average emergency room wait (that's even before being shown to a room) in most urban areas in the U.S. is 9 hours.
troglodyte
Victoria, BC
May 2003
APR 07, 2005 12:00 AM