yeah, i don't know, i'm sorry if i upset anyone by making this thread but the thought of suicide comes up a lot when i get depressed. not that i wanna kill myself, i just think about life and death a lot
CaptBlackHeart said:
isn't it self fish to mourn the death of someone who wanted to be dead. shouldn't you be a friend and relize that if thats what they wanted then thats what they should have
Hmm..I dont know about that. You can know and accept that is what they want, but that does not mean you wont miss them when they are gone. Like if you love someone in terminal pain, you can accept and understand that they might want to die, but you can still be sad that you will never see them again and they are gone forever.
So, I've had some recent experience with a kid who wanted to commit suicide. He's like ten years younger than me, and except for a few notable differences is in the same shit-boat I was at that age. I've thought often of killing myself back in the day, when the hormones are surging and life seems to be shitting only on you.
he broke up with this girl, and he thought it was the end of happiness for him. I've been there, and a shitload of people have been there, but his lack of...I guess maturity or experience or whatever you'd call it, caused and causes him to ignore that. To think he's the center of the world. He's so depressed by this that he feels like there will literally never be any joy for him.
I do think it is a selfish attitude. After a fashion, that is.
But every case is probably different. I've known three people who have killed themselves and they did so probably because they couldn't bear a pain that they felt was world-ending. One of them was a woman with a 12 year old son, whose father had left them long ago, and whose step father decided to cheat on the mom with a crackhead. Right around the time she took the pills, after she'd taken the liquor, she realized she had a responsibility to her kid to stay alive. She called 911, but it was too late. one of the others let his roommate find his corpse; that's something that guy will just have to live with. Finding your best friend dead like that. And the first person I knew who killed herself, she let her parents find her brains on the bedroom wall behind her skull.
is that selfish?
When we say "selfish" it has a negative connotation to it. I think it's more accurate to say that, often times, people who commit or consider suicide aren't thinking of anyone beyond themselves. I don't think that means they are selfish people. None of the three people I mentioned above were "selfish". They were all fucking good people with good hearts. But they encountered terrible situations which stole their perspective.
My perspective was similarly stolen, and I was a highly depressive teen at times. I came up with all kinds of dark philosophies to account for the fucked-upness of life. One day, I came to the conclusion that while no happiness is ever guaranteed to last, no pain is guaranteed to last either. And that led me to the belief that regardless of anything else, things change. You might be sad now. Next week, though, you might be happy. It'll change again and again and again, crests and troughs and shit. But none of this shit is constant. My recent experiences in life have cemented this belief. It's not an entirely positive or negative view...and really, it might be a little more negative than positive. I don't feel entirely comfortable sharing that philosophy with this kid. I can deal with it, but I don't know that he can, in other words.
I think it's hard to see that when you're a kid with zero life experience. And I think, if there is such a thing as the "instant gratification generation", this also comes into play.
This kid is still alive so far. He blames me for that because of certain actions I took when i thought he was serious about doing it. He's also recently been having coffee with a new chick. Hopefully, this will change his perspective a bit. He has good days and bad days.
either way suicide is fucking stupid, as heartless as it is i have no mercy for it, and yes, i have lost some very close friends to it. like you learned in highschool, it's a permanet solution to a temporary problem. what ever happened in your life that was so bad to make you want to kill yourself. sit back. look at its real impact and intensity and fucking get over it. i hate to sound so harsh and blunt. i'm not a mean person but, it really is that easy.
That's pretty reductionist. Most of the time suicide is the result of a lifetime of mental illness and anguish and not one specific incident, so it's a little more complicated than just sucking it up.
Yeah but lifetimes come in varying lengths. A lot of teen suicides are probably more situational than a life time long mental illness.
Agreed, but that's why I said most of the time. Maybe 'some of the time' is more accurate, I can't claim to be speaking from any actual statistics or studies.
I'm completely with BrokenGavel. Put it this way: would you go into a hospital and tell a cancer patient to suck it up?
Mental illness is just as real. So regardless of the stats, I think it's completely unfair to say that in all cases, sucking it up is an option.
Ryan_Dipietro
Naples, FL
April 2004
MAR 20, 2005 04:32 PM