lostarchitect said:
you know, generally if there's something i want or need i just go buy it. if i want it and i haven't bought it, it's too expensive to ask for as a present anyway. so a wish list wouldn't do me any good.
this is why you are basically getting something out of a cracker jack box this year...
nobodaddy said:
It's best when someone thinks of something you'll really like, which you'd have never gotten for yourself, because you don't know about it, or it hadn't occurred to you. That's what I try to do when I give gifts. I never ask what they want, and I don't look at their wishlists.
That is the best, but honestly, does your grandmother or your aunt you see twice a year know you well enough to look deep into your soul and recognize something you'd like? Do you know what they'd like or need? Odds are: no. That is why the Gods gave us wishlists.
damn, that is one hip pseudograndmother.
It's funny you say that, because my stepfather's mom (sort of like a grandmother). gets me the most awesome gifts. A 78 RPM of Leadbelly one year - an old paperbabck from the 50s of Hemingway in French, another time.
If I don't know someone well enough to be able to come up with a gift for them on my own, why am I giving them a gift? And if they don't know what I'd like, why are they wasting good time and money on me?
Can't we just exchange greetings and maybe a token gift, like flowers or baked goods?
Wishlists should be for those items you'd never buy yourself, so that when your best friend inherits a bajillion dollars he knows right away how to surprise the bejesus out of you in the most delightful way.
For some of the people I love, I am able to find things that I *know* they would buy for themselves if they only knew about them . . . but they don't! Ninjagift, fucker, BAM!
i have an amazon wishlist set up simply because i cant even remember things i want but i never really paid any attention to it.
i completely stopped though when i asked a friend what he wants for a gift and he sent him his link that contained 20 pages.
lostarchitect
Brooklyn, NY
January 2004
DEC 22, 2004 07:30 PM