I had never read the book, but I saw the movie some time ago. I was indeed surprised, and to be honest I didn't really expect it. I enjoyed the film, though.
Having read the book, I thought the trailers were misleading, too. They make it look like, yeah, some kind of kids adventure story.
The book is good, especially for not reading like a children's book. It doesn't talk down to children (in my opinion) in the language, or tone, or in the concepts or situations presented to the reader. I'm skeptical that any movie adaptation would take the same approach with its young audience.
As a bit of trivia, the author claims that the story was inspired by the real-life friendship of her young son and a classmate, whose relationship took a similar course as in the book.
was this the one that involves the magical water that they stumble upon and its like a fountain of youth of sorts? if so, yes I remember and loved it when I was young, unless i'm thinking of a different book....
Lily said:
was this the one that involves the magical water that they stumble upon and its like a fountain of youth of sorts? if so, yes I remember and loved it when I was young, unless i'm thinking of a different book....
If you remember it as anything other than a tragedy, you're probably thinking of a different book.
Lily said:
was this the one that involves the magical water that they stumble upon and its like a fountain of youth of sorts? if so, yes I remember and loved it when I was young, unless i'm thinking of a different book....
I think that was Tuck Everlasting. I read them both the same year of school, so they occupy the same sort of place in my head, too.
I read the book in 5th grade. We had to read books in groups and I remember that no one else read the book. I told them the end so we would get a good score on the report.
The book does have a tragic end but I will not tell.
I remember thinking that the book was boring. I did not like it.
I mean, I think i'd be more disturbed now by "oh god, a child dies and the other child has to deal with that loss" than I was as a kid.
Bean and I also think kids should read more books like that (and stuff like Where the Red Fern Grows and the original Grimms fairy tales and whatnot, just to counteract the rounded-corners-on-everything every-child-gets-a-trophy thing that seems to be the norm now. Loss and grief and death are a normal part of life and it really sucks that such a massive effort has been made to shield children from those things. It's been my experience that kids have an easier time dealing with those things than adults have with telling kids about those things.
I felt as though I was tricked into seeing it. I absolutely detest sad films and never watch them if I know they're sad in advance. The previews made it look like a cross between Narnia and The Neverending Story. Liars!!!!
Having said all that, it was a really, really good movie. Not one that I would ever watch again though.
My class was forced to read it in 5th grade and I bawled. I remember it being a great read and more "adult" in it's content than other books at the time.
The trailer to the movie though looked lame and kind of pissed me off because it seemed to cheapen the whole idea. It would be like making "My Girl" into a Disney adventure.
I read the book when I was a kid. Actually, most the books I read as a kid usually ended that same way. They we're books recommended by my teachers....
TheEnnis
Chicago, IL
March 2008
DEC 29, 2008 03:29 PM